this is randy scott. as eric knows i call him my counsel and he has been a very (inaudible) in a number of issues that we face from a governance standpoint during my tenure on the board and i very much am going to miss your sense of humor, good will and most of all your integrity as counsel to this commission so congratulations on your new assignment and i wish you all the best. >> thank you. >> this is commissioner hao and i want to add a few words as well. our time on the board together eric has been short i think that i know eric from my previous life time with the city. he was one of my attorneys on the labor team and i think one thing about eric you can say he a (inaudible) make great combination when you seek sound advise so thank you eric. >> this is commissioner zvanski. i think actually commissioner beslen since you i have been on the board i dont think we had a meeting where we haven't had eric as counsel so i thank you for your many years because it was-when i was an active employee and on this