we will start with the requestor or the requestor's agent? nobody is here on this item? ok. president goh, we can either hear from the zoning administrator are we can pull this item until later in the meeting to see if and when shows up. president goh: no, let's hear from the zoning administrator. >> for the record, the jurisdiction request was filed on april 8, and the receipt mr. pulte walked out of the room with was may 11, the no change. >> thank you, scott sanchez, planning department. this has been an extremely frustrating enforcement case for the planning department. prior to the hearing, i spoke with the enforcement planner who had been handling this, and she wondered if they would show up because they have not showed up, they have not been doing the things they need to be doing in order to come into compliance. there have been very non responsive. actually, we have directed them -- there is an outstanding penalty of $50,000. that may begin within the orbit of the history. 2000, there was a planning commission action that authorized activity at the subject property.

we will start with the requestor or the requestor's agent? nobody is here on this item? ok. president goh, we can either hear from the zoning administrator are we can pull this item until later in the meeting to see if and when shows up. president goh: no, let's hear from the zoning administrator. >> for the record, the jurisdiction request was filed on april 8, and the receipt mr. pulte walked out of the room with was may 11, the no change. >> thank you, scott sanchez, pl

requestor? i believe i have one speaker card. mr. barbee. john barbee. >> good afternoon, i'm john barbee. we have no problem with the interior renovation. the problem is with the trash containers and the design of these bin enclosures. we're very beset by scavengers in the neighborhood, they're very bold and resourceful. when i set my trash out, i get six competing parties who come by that night and raid the bins. some are responsible and kind of pathetic, others are visibly crazy or obviously substance abusers, they drink out of bottles that still have something in them, so that's unmistakable. the temporary enclosure these people have is still open at the top. the scavepjers can come in and raid. it's terrible for us because when they do this, they empty the general rubbish bin all other the sidewalk, things fly all other the place they don't clean them up, we are responsible for doing that. and it's an ongoing problem to have bins exposed seven days a week. that's awkward. you know. it creat

requestor? >> yes. thank you. my name is jerry goldberg, i'm a retired a tech and urban designer, i live on 21st street, the street we're talking about. as has been noted, the liberty hill neighborhood association passed the recommendation that mr. passmore drafted for us. i think that's a very positive

is there anyone here on behalf of the requestor? ok. commissioners, we can certainly invite the permit-holder up, if you would like. >> why don't we take another case and then come back and see if he had shown up. >> ok. >> is the permit-holders here? ok. >> has there been any communication with him recently? >> there has been nothing from the board office, although i believe that the permit-holder has been making efforts to communicate with the requestor. i think there was some claim on the part of the permit-holder that this may not be an appeal that was being pursued. >> ok. in that case, i change my mind. let's call the permit-holder, then. >> please step forward. >> i'm here. >> would you state your name? you have three minutes. >> i really don't have anything else to say. what i submitted in the brief, there is no basis for the request. >> could you speak into the microphone more clearly a more loudly? >> i don't have anything more to add but the brief that was submitted. the person responsible for this is in this room but will no

if the dr requestor is not here, we are going to move ahead with that. commissioner borden: i do not mean to be disrespectful, -- commissioner olague: i had not realize that a few weeks ago he indicated that he may not be here. i think it makes sense to go ahead with this. we will put this at the front of the calendar and just do it. there is the possibility that a couple of items may be planning of the next week's calendar. so that being said,president ole my inclination. now. are you going to be here next week? >> we will be available next week, but i would like to point out to the commission there is another avenue. that is what the board of appeals is for. i would encourage you to respect the process and the people who follow the rules carefully and diligently. in my opinion, this is inexcusable behavior. i am just telling you. we thought we were going to have this hearing in march. now it is made. it is almost six months since this was fog. this is very emotional, very trying for my clients. they are almost 80 years old. we want to get this done. ge

we will start with the request for -- requestor, mr. flanagan. you're three minutes. >> thank you for hearing me. i'm the appellant. i live at 124 lower terrace. i am here today, i reminded because i live that the top of one of the minister cases in san francisco. i -- it was inundated with tourists. it was one of the reasons it was called out in the plant to be included as an excellent view and one of the reasons i believe as the basis of my appeal. more and -- my request as submitted to you on march 24 outlines what happened with this situation. i learned of the project when i came home and some construction going on in my yard. i tried to contact nextg. i did not receive any call back. i contacted my supervisors and subsequently contacted the department of public works. at that point, numerous back and forth, i also investigated nextg and other work they have been doing. based on an e-mail from the department of public works, on the 21st, "the public has no opportunity for repeal." i believe the department of public works to be an exceptional

requestor? seeing none, project sponsor. >> my name is angela logan, i'm the project upon sor. -- sponsor. the scope of the project is an interior remodel on the ground floor, the purpose of the project is to utilize the ground floor as part of the habitable living space for the unit above, where the homeowners currently live. the final configuration at the completion of the project will be two dwelling units on three floors of occupancy, there will be no work done in the top floor which is a different living unit. the work on the ground floor will include a new lowered floor to achieve the legal ceiling height, new interior walls, there's a wet bar included there and new bathroom, relocated laundry, a new open guardrail will be added to the existing young to provide for an open spatial connection between the ground floor and there are no exceptional circumstances and the project is consistent with the planning department demrines. it has already been approved by the d.b.i. so their issues have