rex dr. marshall does not have to withhold his vote. -- >> dr. marshall does not have to withhold his vote. >> i was trying to alternate which member of the commission i was starting with. >> oh, that is fine . is fineturman. >> thank you. -- oh, that is fine. . turman. >> thank you. commissioner german votes for himself. >> this is an embarrassment of riches with these nominations. commissioner turman's commitment to this department and his commitment to cooperation and collaboration, i think you also embody what president mazzucco said about this not been a divided body and i think you want what is best for this department. i have a tremendous amount of respect to you -- for you in the amount of time where work together. i, like commissioner kingsley, will vote for commissioner marshall because i think that team has been going very successfully and i want to continue that. commissioner loftus votes for commissioner marshall. >> commissioner michael -- thank you, commissioner. commissioner marshall? >> you cannot go wrong with either one of us. i

dr. marshall? rex i serve at the pleasure of the commission. -- >> i serve at the pleasure of the commission. >> commissioner turman. >> i have not been nominated. [laughter] >> i think that is wrong. >> i certainly do not have the years of service on this commission as dr. marshall. i certainly appreciate everything dr. marshall has done. and i look to dr. marshall as an example of what commissioners can do and should achieve. if elected to this position, i would also serve at the pleasure of the commission. having worked with you, commissioner kingsley come on exactly the obligations, the requirements of the commission -- i know there are no specific duties laid down for the vice president, but i have watched dr. marshall certainly take on certain kinds of obligations to make sure we address certain issues. i certainly have my issues that i think we should address. i am a busy man with a busy law practice, but we all have jobs and we all care. it is time we do what is important with this commission -