. >> 65-year-old richard gottfried was a dentist for the north hill school district. superintendent calls him a fixture in the community. joyce fienberg was a specialist at the university of pittsburgh and a grandmother. a former student says she lit up the room. >> and cecil and david rosenthal were brothers. they always sat in the back of the temple to greet people as they came to worship. listen to cecil's long time friend. >> a sweet, sweet, gentle soul that was friendly to everybody. helpful to everybody. he came, i understand, all the time because he wanted to help and be part of the community and to make it accessible to everybody. >> daniel stein was 71. his sense of humor was legend y legendary. his son wrote that saturday was the worst day of my life. >> bernice and sylvan simon were the sweetest couple you could imagine. they were 84 and 86 years old and always trying to help the community and temple. 97-year-old rose mallinger attended the synagogue with her daughter. even at 97, rose was full of life and vibrant. >> the holocaust and ugly times. she made

richard gottfried, one of the wonderful people that were gunned down.ey myers. he was presiding over his congregation at the time of the shooting. the hearts of the nation are with you. >> the world. >> indeed, the whole world. you haven't been back here since saturday. this is your synagogue, your home, your house of worship. what crosses your mind? >> i didn't see the stars and the tributes to people until i caught a little of the news last night and i saw it in person this morning. for a moment, i felt like, i'm standing at a cemetery and this is a massive mausoleum. it's my home and it's been desecrated. >> you said to me a few moments ago, you could never use that sanctuary again. >> it can't be used again in its present condition. the bullet holes are too numerous to count. but we will rebuild because we're tree of life. we've been here 154 years. and you can cut off some branches but the tree will continue to grow and we will be back. >> you can see how this community of all faiths, how people are pulling together in this moment. and i can't imag

richard gottfried. he was a 65-year-old husband, a brother, a father, a sentenhe. was known as dr.eered his services and he was on the verge of retire wnt when he gunned down. his family says his generous life will not be overshadowed by his senseless death. we sat down withwo sisters last night. >> growing up, he was the only boy. he had three sisters that he had to deal with. >> reporter: he was your twin. >> he was my twin. just, unimaginable that someone that was so full of life is gone in an instant. >> reporter: honey, you are shaking. >> i know. i'm falling apart. >> reporter: it must be such a shock. >> there aren't even wor to describe how i feel. i'm devastated. i mean, he was my baby brother. >> h a touched lot of people. in all areas of his lifeus that speaks to who he was. he loved his wife. he loved his family. and he loved life. >> family was very important. family first. >> reporter: dr. richard gottfried was at the synagogue with his youngest sister, carol, when the shoaring began. >> and our rabbi a two other congregants went in a closet with a steel door a stayed

most survivors say richard gottfried was the heart of the synagogue. >> it's just unbelievable that someoneo full of life is gone in an instant. >> reporter: his sisters, debbie and bonnie are stunned. their other sister, carol, was inside the synagogue and survived, a blessing and a tragedy for the same family. >> i'm devastated. i mean, he was my baby brother. >> reporter: lives lost and saved, forever intertwined, a community in need of its faith now more than ever before. as this community tries to heal, many are divided as the president is coming to pittsburgh tomorrow. many jewish leaders say the president must denounce white nationalism, but the rabbi here at the tree of life says he is welcome at any time. lester? >> all right, miguel almaguer, thank you. the synagogue massacre is the most extreme example of a disturbing increase in anti-semitic incidents across the country recently. for more on that, we turn to nbc's stephanie gosk. stephanie, how much of a threat are jewish institutions across the country facing? >> reporter: well, lester, security's beefed up at this synagogue in

most say richard gottfried was the heart of the synagogue. >> it's just unimaginable that somebody that was so nefull of life is in an instant. >> reporter: his sisters debbie and bonnie are stunned. their other sister carol was inside the synagogue and survived. a blessing and a tragedy fothe same family. >> i'm devastated. i mean, he was my babybr her. >> reporter: lives lost and saved forever intertwined, a community in need of its faith now more than ever before. as this community tries to heal, many president is coming to pittsburgh tomorrow. many jewish leaders musay the presiden denounce white nationalism but the rabbi here at the treeif ofsays he is welcome at any time. lester. >> miguel almaguer, thank you. >>> the synagogue massacre is the most bixtreme example of a dist increase of anti-semic incidents across the country. for more, we turn to stephanie gosk. how much t ofeat are gjewish institutions facing? >> reporter: leste security is beefed up at this synagogue in new york like others around the country. the reality is anti-semitism is on spikes in the last ic couple year

the pittsburgh synagogue shooting, irving wax, jerry rabinowitz, joyce fienberg, daniel stein, richard gottfried, cecil rosenthal, and david rosenthal. >> president cohen: all right. thank you. ladies and gentlemen, i just want to say thank you to our friends at sfgov tv for assisting us in this broadcast, and our meeting is adjourned. thank you. >> we broke ground in december of last year. we broke ground the day after sandy hook connecticut and had a moment of silence here. it's really great to see the silence that we experienced then and we've experienced over the years in this playground is now filled with these voices. >> 321, okay. [ applause ] >> the park was kind of bleak. it was scary and over grown. we started to help maclaren park when we found there wasn't any money in the bond for this park maclaren. we spent time for funding. it was expensive to raise money for this and there were a lot of delays. a lot of it was just the mural, the sprinklers and we didn't have any grass. it was that bad. we worked on sprinkler heads and grass and we fixed everything. we worked hard collecting eve

and bernice, lost their lives in the very place they were married 62 years ago. 65-year-old richard gottfriedt celebrated his 38th wedding anniversary. daniel stein was a newly-minted grandfather. melvin wax was a pillar at the tree of life synagogue, performing many roles there. 69-year-old irving younger was in real estate and also a youth football and baseball coach. joyce fienberg, 75, was a mother of two sons and a proud grandmother. funeral services will be held tomorrow for 66-year-old jerry rabinowitz, a family doctor who always took the time to check in on his patients. and two special needs brothers, cecil and david rosenthal, who shared an unbreakable bond. >> we will honor them in some way that distinguishes them to get beyond this atrocious act and show the world that these folks did not die in vain. >> reporter: nikki battiste, cbs news, pittsburgh, pennsylvania. >> glor: and this is the "cbs evening news" from pittsburgh tonight. i'm jeff glor. as people continue to gather here at the tree of life synagogue to pray and remember and say good-bye. i'll see you in new york tomorro

year-old rose mallinger of squirrel hill. 66-year-old jerry rabinowitz of edgewood. 65-year-old richard gottfried of ross township. 75-year-old joyce feinberg of oakland. 69-year-old irving youngner of mt. washington. 59-year-old cecil rosenthal of squirrel hill. 54-year-old david rosenthal. david and cecil rosenthal were brothers. >> reporter: this note to the brothers was left at that memorial today. members of the congregation telling us cecil and david, both with special needs, had been coming to the synagogue since childhood and were always there. they never missed a service. freddy rabner says cecil was known for his kindness and was often the greeter when members arrived. >> he was someone that we all knew. you know how there's people in the community that everyone knows. he's one of those guys where if i'm driving home, i would toot my horn and give him a honk and he'd give me a wave. and for us to learn that he passed away, it's a symbol of how senseless this act of violence was. because you don't get a more innocent, harmless individual. who doesn't have an ill bone in his body. >> 84-y

richard gottfried, 65, had just celebrated his 38th wedding anniversary. 97-year-old rose mallinger was a devoted member of the congregation. jerry rabinowitz, 66, was a family physician. cecil rosenthal, 59, and david rosenthal, 54 were brothers who attended services every saturday. bernice simon, 84 and sylvan simon, 86 were husband a wife. 71-year-old daniel stein was a former president of the new light congregation. melvin wax, 88, was a retired accountant. and 69-year-old irving younger taught classes on current events at the local community center and had two grandchildren. newshour weekend's yvette feliciano traveled to pittsburgh last night and has been with meembers of the community. >> reporter: 17-year-old emily prheessmaed organize yesterday's vigil led by local hitugh schoolnts. >> i don't think i've accepted the fact that this happened to us. >> reporter: emily and her thother stacy were glued t television this morning when the names of the 11 people killed at the tree of life synagogue were released. emily and her siblings went to hebrew school there, and the amy often go

daniel stone, richard gottfried, jerry rabinowitz, and two brothers, cecil and david rosenthal.itjewish communities in america. one of those places which speaks of the immigrant story. one of those places, according to rabbi chuck diamond, that‘s long felt vulnerable. i used to be the rabbi there, and one of my biggest fears was always, in the back of my head, something like this happening. so, there‘s a lot of hate, and when you mix hate with guns, it‘s not a good result. with congressional elections looming, donald trump has continued to hammer his democratic opponents, only briefly interrupting this political rally to offer words of condemnation. this evil, anti—semitic attack is an assault on all of us. it‘s an assault on humanity. mass shootings have become a permanent feature of american life. flowers and police tape, we see them over and over again. nick bryant, bbc news, pittsburgh. let‘s return to our top story, and the confirmation of the death of the owner of leicester city football club. it came from the club just a couple of hours ago, and shortly after the statemen

among the 11, there were two brothers, one married couple: a professor and a doctor. 65-year-old richard gottfried had a successful dental practice, and had just celebrated his 38th wedding anniversary. both in their 50s, brothers cecil and david rosenthal were at services every week. cecil loved to greet people at the door. dr. jerry rabinowitz ran a family medical practice. one of his patients wrote that he always took time with each of his patients. "there was no rush to get out of his office. it was like i was the only patient he had." the oldest of the victims, 97- year-old rose mallinger was almost always the first to walk into services, and was described by a relative as "the most caring, gentle, loving woman." daniel stein recently became a grandfather. his nephew said, "he was somebody that everybody liked." melvin wax was a retired accountant, and was known for his generosity. he was described by those who knew him as a pilar at the tree of life synagogue, performing many roles there. the married couple were bernice and sylvan simon, both retired and both liked to take walks around the n

daniel stein, richard gottfried, jerry rabinowitz, and two brothers, cecil and david rosenthal.munities in america. one of those places which speaks of the immigrant story. one of those places, according to rabbi chuck diamond, that‘s long felt vulnerable. i used to be the rabbi there, and one of my biggest fears was always, in the back of my head, something like this happening. so, there‘s a lot of hate, and when you mix hate with guns, it‘s not a good result. with congressional elections looming, donald trump has continued to hammer his democratic opponents, only briefly interrupting this political rally to deliver words of unity and condemnation. this evil anti—semitic attack is an assault on all of us. it‘s an assault on humanity. mass shootings have become a permanent feature of american life. flowers and police tape, we see them over and over again. nick bryant, bbc news, pittsburgh. earlier i spoke to adam hertzman from thejewish federation of greater pittsburgh, and i started by asking him about how the jewish community is fighting some of the online hate speech against

daniel stine, richard gottfried, jerry ridden a bitch and two brothers, cecil and david rosenthal.of the most close—knitjewish communities in america. one of those places which speaks of the immigrant story. one of those places, according to rabbi chuck diamond, that's long felt vulnerable. i used to be the rabbi there. one of my biggest fears was always, in the back of my head, something like this happening. so, there's a lot of hate, and when you mix hate with guns, it's not a good result. with congressional elections looming, donald trump has been hammering his democratic opponents, only briefly this political rally to offer words of condemnation. this evil, anti—semitic attack is an assault on all of us. it's an assault on humanity. mass shootings have become a permanent feature of life here. flowers and police tape. we see them over and over again. nick bryant, bbc news, pittsburgh. let's take a look at some of today's other news stories. trains running in and out of paddington station in london have been disrupted for the second time this month because of damage to overhead p

richard gottfried, daniel stein, a husband and a wife and two brothers cecil and david rosenthal. they are much more than just names to many in this area and that is why the attack is hitting home for a lot of folks here. >> this is an awful, awful. for a jewish community and especially for the families did and it's real into your the names. we will do everything we can to help the families. >> pittsburgh is a strong town. we are a resilient city. we have been knocked down and found ways to send back a. we'll get through this darkest day of pittsburgh's history by working together. >> the medical team is doing everything it can to process these bodies and get them released to the families as soon as possible so they can be buried in accordance with jewish law. they will release several bodies today and tomorrow as well and they hope to wrap this up very soon if the investigation begins to unfold and they'll play a big role in this going forward. arthel: this hits home for people who don't even live in pittsburgh. >> president trump says he will travel in the near future to show su

. >> 65-year-old >> 65-year-old richard gottfried rorter: seve were held saturday night including here in pitsburgh. many said they could not avoid placing the shooting in a context ofwhite supremacist ask the likes are feeling more confident to go out and express their hateful beliefs. >> i have been blind sided by it. >> reporter: pitsburgh mayor is hoping to see it unity. >> let this horrific episode be another mark in the march of humanity toward recognizing that we are all one. >> reporter: robert bowers is facing 29 federal charges. most could carry the death penalty. he will make his first appearance in court monday afternoon. in pitsburgh, fox news. >> late this evening robert bowers had been posting antihours to move to another service. >> it is a special network that launched in 2016 as an alternative to twitter or facebook or youtube. it is a place where people can come together and talk about anything they want. it is no holds bard. >> several hours after saturday's attacks paypal banned the network. he said since major social media companies began banning hate speech alter

richard gottfried, age 65. rose malenger, 97. jerry rabinowitz, 66. david rosen thaul, 54.sylvan, simon, 86. daniel stein, 71. melvin wax, 88. irving younger, 69 years old. may they rest in peace. may their memory be a blessing. d in them therr hills on your vacation. but we can guarantee the best price on this rental cabin. or any accomodation from hotels to yurts. booking.com, booking.yeah i may not ♪ when the moon hits your eye ♪ ♪ like a big pizza pie, ♪ that's amore. ♪ when the world seems... ♪ applebee's new neighborhood pastas. now that's eatin' good in the neighborhood. first, it continues to pay paramedics while we're on break. second, it ensures the closest ambulance can respond if you call 9-1-1. vote yes on 11. proposition 11 "proposition 11 is a vote to protect patient safety." it ensures the closest ambulance remains on-call during paid breaks "so that they can respond immediately when needed." vote yes on 11. thank you for joining us. you are live in the "cnn newsroom." i'm alex marquardt here in new york in tonight for ana cabrera. tonight a vigil is held in

the pittsburgh synagogue shooting, irving wax, jerry rabinowitz, joyce fienberg, daniel stein, richard gottfried, cecil rosenthal, and david rosenthal. >> president cohen: all right. thank you. ladies and gentlemen, i just want to say thank you to our friends at sfgov tv for assisting us in this broadcast, and our meeting is adjourned. thank you. in this san francisco office, there are about 1400 employees. and they're working in roughly 400,000 square feet. we were especially pleased that cleanpowersf offers the super green 100% clean energy, not only for commercial entities like ours, but also for residents of the city of san francisco. we were pleased with the package of services they offered and we're now encouraging our employees who have residence in san francisco to sign on as well. we didn't have any interruption of service or any problems with the switch over to cleanpowersf. this clean power opportunity reflects that. i would encourage any large business in san francisco to seriously consider converting and upgrading to the cleanpowersf service. it's good for the environment, it's good

. >> richard gottfried was a dentist, who often did charitable work and would treat patients that couldn't afford dental work. gottfried was set to retire in the next few months. daniel stein was 71 and he had just become a grandfather. he was seen as a real leader in the congregation. he was president of the synagogue's men's club and was passionate about his community. he is described as somebody that everybody liked with a generous spirit and a dry sense of humor. rose malinger was 97. she was dedicated to her children and her grandchildren, they say. a local jewish leader told the "pittsburgh post-gazette," you have never met a more vie v vacious 97-year-old. dr. jerry rabinowitz was 56, a family physician that was beloved by his patients and the kind of doctor that treated the whole person. that's how friends and colleagues described him to the newspaper. a doctor who worked with him told the "post gazette," i have been taking telephone calls all morning long from patients. erving younger was 69, went by irv. according to the local newspaper, he always showed up early and stayed late

sisters, one a twin of 65-year-old victim richard gottfried, about how they want the nation to remember their dear brother. >> he touched a lot of people and in all areas of his life, and that just speaks to who he was. >> it not easy for you, both to be here talking to me. >> no, it's not. . >> you but i know you wanted to for a reason. >> and the reason is you have a job to do and you're going to be talking about it anyway, so the things that you say about him, i want them to be who he is. and he is, was the kindest, most loving, caring person. >> joining me now, msnbc analyst howard fineman, my friend, my colleague, howard is a pittsburgh native, he grew up attending services at tree of life synagogue where his parents taught sunday school and he was bat mitzvahed. his opinion pieces appear in the "new york times" and "wall street journal." our hearts are grieving with pittsburgh and i think it affects all americans and certainly those of us who grew up in synagogues, who understand the grief of this congregation, i think. lou, first to you, tell me how pittsburgh and you yourself ar

richard gottfried killed in the attack, and we're told she asked to meet with the president, to thank him for coming and let him know, unlike the protesters, there are many others who wanted him to be here today. kennedy? kennedy: thank you so much, garrett. >>> all right, coming up, tech companies and the government spying on you for years, apple ceo tim cook says that's enough. he wants to enact better privacy laws, but what's his motivation now, and is there any hope he'll succeed? my monologue is next. ron! something's going on at schwab. oh really? thank you clients? well jd power did just rank them highest in investor satisfaction with full service brokerage firms...again. and online equity trades are only $4.95... i mean you can't have low cost and be full service. it's impossible. it's like having your cake and eating it too. ask your broker if they offer award-winning full service and low costs. how am i going to explain this? if you don't like their answer, ask again at schwab. schwab, a modern approach to wealth management. . kennedy: tim cook was spitting mad at brussels a

richard gottfried, 65. jerry rabinowitz, 66. he was a doctor, and we have spoken to people who know him and talk about his kindness and his care. there was cecil and david rosenthal. bernice and sylvan simon. irving younger. melvin wax, and again, rose mallinger. victor. >> sara sidner, thank you so much. >> now let's get the latest on the investigation. miguel marquez, we just got some new reporting about what investigators are finding. they're searching the suspect's car. that's now complete. what else have you learned? >> well, look, we are trying to get an understanding of who this person is. and what is becoming very clear is that this was a person who was almost a ghost in life. kind of went through life without making any sort of impression on anyone, from neighbors to others. we have just spoken to a person who does not want to be identified who knew, knows mr. bowers and has known him for most of his adult life. this person describes him as a lost soul. someone who went from job to job and never really fit in. also desc

richard gottfried a respected dentist. mildred was the first to arrive for shabbat services and the last to leave. jerry rabinowitz one of the kindest human beings in the community. rose mallinger as one of the kindest people he's known and a major volunteer in this neighborhood. joyce feinberg and irving younger, and cecil and david rosenthal who lived with disabilities and never missed a saturday of worship and husband and wife sylvan and bernice simon. people bringing flowers and cards outside the synagogue. one group carried 11 stars of david with a name inscribed in the middle. folks are expressing a lot of appreciation for the police officers whose quick response prevented this shooting from becoming much worse. >> i still want to praise the officers for what they did. they reined in the gunfire to help others. some of that is training, some of that is experience, it's their inner core that wants to save others, save lives and they did that yesterday. reporter: there's been an outpouring of support from around the gl

richard gottfried was 65, a fixture in the community. a dentist in the area. rose was 97 years old, and regularly attended with her daughter. always offered a friendly greeting, a hug and a small. smile. brothers david and cecil rosenthal was 54 and 59 years old. they were both so devoted to their faith and synagogue they were deemed ambassadors to the temple. known for his laugh. and spirit. and sylvan and bernice simon, 86 and 84 years old, they died together in the same synagogue where they were married more than 60 years ago. a neighbor says they were loving, giving and kind. tonight all of the love and joy that these victims shared with their synagogue and their community lives on. may their memories be a blessing. . . today is the day you're going to get motivated... get stronger... get closer. start listening today to the world's largest selection of audiobooks on audible. and now, get more. for just $14.95 a month, you'll get a credit a month good for any audiobook, plus two audible originals exclusive titles you can't find anywhere else. if you don't

richard gottfried, 65 years old. rose mallinger, 97 years old. dr. jerry rabinowitz, 66 years old.nd his brother david rosenthal, 54. bernice simon, 84 years old and her loving husband, sylvan simon, 86 years old. daniel stein, 71. melvin wax, 88 years old. and irving younger, 69 years old. dr. jerry rabinowitz, one of the 11 people gunned down saturday morning at these religious services, in the worst anti-semitic attack in u.s. history, let's remember a little bit about him. he was a beloved pittsburgh area physician. a colleague says, and i am quoting, he was a kind, joyful man. one of rabinowitz's nephews posted a very moving tribute to his uncle, jerry, online. let me just read one part. quote, uncle jerry wasn't killed in the basement of the building where the congregation was praying, he was shot outside the room. why? because when he heard shots, he ran outside to try and see if anyone was hurt and needed a doctor. dr. jerry rabinowitz was 66 years old. brothers cecil and david rosenthal both killed saturday morning in the tree of life synagogue, as well. and a family frien

richard gottfried, age 65, dr. rich as he was known in this community.practice with his wife, had been practicing dentistry for years. his wife is catholic. the two of them -- he was jewish -- helped prepare members of the community for marriage. he was a fixture at north hills school district. they're remembering him as well today. melvin wax, 88 years old. we're told he was a big joke teller. he had a daughter, son-in-law and grandson, who he was very close to. and irving youngner, age 69, a little league coach who interacted with a lot of kids in this community, attended tree of life regularly and we were told he was a very kind man. again, these few little anecdotes don't begin to do these people justice, people who lived full lives and people who clearly dedicated their lives to bettering their community, to loving their friends and family, poppy and jim. without question, these were people with deep roots in this community and are certainly be grieved today. a lot of broken-hearted people trying to grapple with this. >> jessica dean, thank you. don

richard gottfried.ich's wife was catholic and they prepared couples for marriage at their catholic church. he was 65 years old. >> tech: at safelite autoglass, we really pride ourselves on making it easy to get your windshield fixed. >> teacher: let's turn in your science papers. >> tech vo: this teacher always puts her students first. >> student: i did mine on volcanoes. >> teacher: you did?! oh, i can't wait to read it. >> tech vo: so when she had auto glass damage... she chose safelite. with safelite, she could see exactly when we'd be there. >> teacher: you must be pascal. >> tech: yes ma'am. >> tech vo: saving her time... [honk, honk] >> kids: bye! >> tech vo: ...so she can save the science project. >> kids: whoa! >> kids vo: ♪ safelite repair, safelite replace ♪ ♪ ♪ our new, hot, fresh breakfast will get you the readiest. (buzzer sound) holiday inn express. be the readiest. first, it continues to pay paramedics while we're on break. second, it ensures the closest ambulance can respond if you call

. >> reporter: overnight we spoke with two sisters of victim richard gottfried. >> still numb. it hasn't really sunk in yet. >> reporter: his third sister carol was inside too. she survived. >> he is -- was the kindest, most loving, caring person. he always did for others. >> emotional tributes from those folks. i want to bring in ron allen outside the federal courthouse. we know the suspect in the shooting is due to court today. this will be his first court appearance since police captured him over the weekend. >> reporter: that's correct. good morning to you. there's a bit of possible breaking news developing. one media outlet in pittsburgh roberting that robert bowers may have been released from alleghany hospital this morning. if that's the case, then we do expect him to show up in person at the courthouse for this first appearance which is scheduled right now at 1:30 p.m. eastern time. if he does come in, obviously, there will be heavy security and believe he will come in through the north side. i just got word from my producer, it's confirmed he's been released from the h

richard gottfried was 65 years old. he was a dentist who was generous about serving patients who didn't have dental insurance. he and his wife had just celebrated their anniversary and were planning to retire. two brothers were murdered. a member of the synagogue said, quote, they were like the ambassadors because they were always there and they will always be there in our hearts. there was also a married couple who were in the -- in the synagogue who were killed. they died together. they all had to die. they all had to die because they were supporting an invasion. that's what their murderer believed. that's why he killed them. he put it in writing. many of president trump's allies have been telling that mass murderer and everyone else in the country that jews are funding the long walk of the refugees in central america and that the president and the mass murderer call that an invasion. fox news, which is owned and operated by an australian immigrant to this country has been relentlessly pushing that invasion rhetoric a

shot and killed at worship, richard gottfried, 65. this is a photo of him with his wife peg.lso cecil rosenthal. hooefs kill he was killed with his brother. also daniel stein, joyce fienberg, irving younger, a father and grandfather, husband and wife, bernice and sylvan simon. and rose mallinger, the oldest was 97. rose was alive during the holocaust. all murdered on a day of prayer. their benediction for us, their tragedy is our nation's. that wraps it up for me this hour here at ms nbc. let's turn it over. >> very poignant. it's always difficult when you see the names and faces. you're struck by the humanity of those that have given their life. hel lor hello, everyone. a lot to breakdown. two men, two acts of hate. one driven by anti-semitic activity. why will neither one of them be charged with what the law appears to define their actions as? terroris

richard gottfried was 65 and had a dental practice with his wife. he was jewish, she was catholic. they counseled other interfaith couples at her church about what to expect. bernice and sylvan simon were married at tree of life years ago. imagine that. devoting time to charitable work, charitable causes. they were always ready to help said a neighbor and always with a big smile. b bernice and sylvan simon died as they lived, together. we will remember them. dr. jerry rabinowitz has treated all kinds of patients with kindness and compassion, particularly those with hiv/aids, at a time when fear of the disease was running high. one patient wrote he always shook our hands without rubber gloves. the doctor who sent us on our way feeling fwhert all respects. reports are he was shot as he rushed to help wounded congregants. his patients remember and so will we. melvin wax's sister said she always used to kid him that he should have been a rabbi. instead he was a dedicated congregant attending fridays and saturdays and would always be the first to arrive, she said, always in a good mood.

richard gottfried was a dentist. they celebrated a 38th anniversary and planning to retire soon and passed out toothbrushes instead of candy for halloween. >> rose mallinger was 97 years old and barely missed a service in decades. she was called full of life. her daughter is recovering. jerry rabinowitz lost his life trying to help others at the synagogue. when he heard the shots, he ran outside to see when anyone was hurt and then gunned down. he was one of the few doctors to take time to listen, understand and empathize even when he was busy. >> david and cecil rosenthal were attending the synagogues since they were boy. when the synagogue held services, the two brothers served as honor ary helpers. >> daniel stein, his 1-year-old grandson was the love of his life. he was killed in the same room where his grandson's ceremony was held this year. melvin wax was 88 years old. he was leading services for new life congregation when he was killed. a family spokesperson said he was always available for a conversation or t

she is being remembered as a, quote, engaging, elegant and warm person. 65-year-old richard gottfriedhis wife for more than 30 years. the couple helped prepare other couples for marriage at his wife's catholic church. bernice and sylvan simon were wed at tree of life back in 1956, and their neighbors said they were the sweetest people you could imagine. cecil and david rosenthal were brothers who always sat in the back of the temple and greeted people as they came in to worship. the 59 and 54-year-old brothers were described as inacceptable. their funerals are scheduled for tomorrow. >> cecil was tall. david was small. they stood proud at the front door, at the door that was open into the sanctuary, which ever sanctuary it was. they just stood there, hello. they gave you a book where they said hello or they were the good ambassadors. >> irving young was a former realtor and little league coach. neighbors say he was a wonderful father and grandfather who went to synagogue every single day. and our deepest condolences going out to the families and the squirrel hill community and beyond.

richard gottfried was 65, a fixture in the community.lways offered a friendly greeting, a hug and a small. brothers david and cecil rosenthal was 54 and 59 years old. they were both so devoted to their faith and synagogue they were deemed ambassadors to the temple. and sylvan and bernice simon, 86 and 84 years old, they died together in the same synagogue where they were married more than 60 years ago. a neighbor says they were loving, giving and kind. tonight all of the love and joy that these victims shared with their synagogue and their community lives on. may their memories be a blessing. delicious pasta marinara. but birds eye made it from zucchini. mmm... mashed potatoes...and rice! but made from cauliflower. looks like i need a fork! oh no. (giggles) birds eye veggie made. so veggie good. at booking.com, we can't guarantee you'll good at that water jet thingy... but we can guarantee the best price on this hotel. or any accommodation, from homes to yurts. booking.com booking.yeah ♪ ♪ eastbound and down. ♪ loaded up and truckin'. ♪

. >> richard gottfried, friends repped h remembered him as a genuine nice guy. he had just celebrated his 38th wedding anniversary. joyce feinberg, a mother of two sons. native of toronto, a researcher at the university of pittsburgh. she was described as caring, generous, and a thoughtful human being. melvin wax was 88. the first to arrive and the last to leave. he was leading the services when the shooting began. those who knew him said there was always a smile on his face. daniel stein spending his retirement traveling with his life. he made even the toughest tasks enjoyable. he was killed in the same room where his grandson's bris was held earlier this year. ir vi irving younger. a former tree of life president said i wouldn't be surprise first down he saw the gunmen walk into the room and his first thought was can i help this stranger get settled? and finally ber niece and sylvan simon. they died in the same place they were married 60 years ago. they married in 1956 at the tree of life sin dog. she wore an ivory gown. a neighbor recalls them as a sweet, kin

richard gottfried was a dentist. he opened a dental practice with his wife. the families in the area were his patients. melvin wax was a passionate member of the synagogue. his sister said he was always one of the first people to get there in the morning and was, quote, always full of jokes. lastly, irving younger. he was known for his big smile and big hand shake, which is fitting, since he was a greeter at the tree of life synagogue. our hearts and our thoughts are with these victims, and their loved ones and their community. may their memories be a blessing. >>> the man accused of committing that awful and hateful act appeared in court today. he's now being held without bond. also this afternoon, the other man, the one accused of sending at least 14 pipe bombs to cnn and critics of the president faced a judge in florida. we have components corivering bh huge stories. we start with miguel marquez covering the horrific mass shooting there. we know the shooter expressed a hatred of jews online. but would his anti-semitism have been obvious to a casual observe

richard gottfried. >> there aren't even words to deribe how i feel. i'm devastated. i mean, he was my baby brother. >> reporte he hidnside a utility closet with his younger sister. she is still too shaken to talk about what happened, but her sisters say she told them. >> he walked in and id, all aws must die opened fire. >> the complaintant says they have an active shooter in the shilding. >> reporter: blooded in his wake, armed with an ar-15 and three handguns. authorities say 46-year-old richard bowers tried to shoot his way out of the synagogue, wounding six others, including four police officers before surrenring. the suspect's neighbors, stunned. >> very upsetting knowing that someone who had that much hate was on the other side of my wall. >> reporter: a community looking to faith to move forward. >> you can cut o some branches, but the tree will continue to grow and we will be >> reporter: back after yet nother senseless loss. wendywoolfolk, nbc news, pittsburgh. >>> the effects ofsaturday's shooting are felt right here in our area. a montgomery county woman w

the victims have been identified as cecil rosenthal -- cecil rosenthal, joyce fienberg, richard gottfriedrose ballinger, jerry rabinowitz bernice simon, sylvan simon, , daniel stein, melvin wax, and irving younger. they ranged in age from 54 to 97. six others were injured, including four policemen. the worshippers were gathered on saturday morning for sabbath services when a 4646-year-old mn named robert bowers entered the synagogue armed with an ar-15 and three e handguns. he yelled "all jews must die" as he opened fire on worshipers. when bowers was finally taken into custody 20 minutes later, he reportedly told a swat team officer he "wanted all jews to die." this is fbi spspecial agent bob jones. >> this is the most horrific crime scene i've seen in 22 years of federal bureau investigation. members of the tree of life synagogue conducting a peaceful service in their place of worship were brutally murdered by a gunman targeting them simply because of their faith. amy: just before the shooting rampage, the gunman robert bowers, wrote a message online saying -- "hias likes to bring invad

richard gottfried. >> there aren't even words to describe how i feel. devastated. i mean, he was my baby brother. >> reporter: he hid inside a utility closet with his younger sister. she is still too shaken to talk about what happened, but her sisters say she told them. >> he walked in and said, "all jews must die" and opened fire. >> the complainant says they have an active shooter in the building. >> reporter: bloodshed in his wake, armed with an ar-15 and three handguns, authorities say 46-year-old richard bowers tried to shoot his way out of the synagogue, wounding six hours, including four police officers before surrendering. the suspect's neighbors, stunned. >> very upsetting, knowing that someone that had that much hate was on the other side of my wall. >> reporter: a community looking to faith to move forward. >> you can cut off some branches, but the tree will continue to grow and we will be back. >> reporter: back after yet another senseless loss. wendy woolfolk, nbc news. >> a man due in court after surrendering to authorities in connection with last yea

richard gottfried killed in the attack, and we're told she asked to meet with the president, to thank him for coming and let him know, unlike the protesters, there are many others who wanted him to be here today. kennedy? kennedy: thank you so much, garrett. >>> all right, coming up, tech companies and the government spying on you for years, apple ceo tim cook says that's enough. he wants to enact better privacy laws, but what's his motivation now, and is there any hope he'll succeed? my monologue is next. i can do more to lower my a1c. because my body can still make its own insulin. i take trulicity once a week to activate my body to release its own insulin, like it's supposed to. trulicity is not insulin. it works 24/7. it comes in an easy-to-use pen. and i may even lose a little weight. trulicity is an injection to improve blood sugar in adults with type 2 diabetes when used with diet and exercise. don't use it as the first medicine to treat diabetes, or if you have type 1 diabetes or diabetic ketoacidosis. don't take trulicity if you or your family have medullary thyroid cancer, y

these will be available to you afterwards. 75-year-old joyce feinberg of oakland. 65-year-old richard gottfried of ross township. 97-year-old red cross mallinger of squirrel hill. 66-year-old jerry robinowitz of edgewood. 69-year-old cecil rosenthal of squirrel hill. 54-year-old david rosenthal. david and cecil rosenthal were brothers. 84-year-old bernice simon of wilkinsburg. 86-year-old civil simon of wilkinsburg, husband and wife. 79-year-old david stine of squirrel hill. 69-year-old irving younger of mt. washington. the bodies are currently at the medical examiner's office. autopsies have begun on those. we are doing everything in our power to complete the process in a way that honors both civil and religious law and the cause and manner will be released to the media as they're determined. we have not established a time framework for this. we're only in the initial process of evaluating what will be required to do that. and finally, in talking with the familiies last night, they are n shock and grieving, as you can imagine. my colleagues and i join the authorities in asking for you to pleas

richard gottfrie 65, met his wife at the university of pittsburgh. the pair were married in 1980 and would go on to open ant try practice together. dr. gottfried was a regular volunteer at free dental clinics, offering care to adults in nee rose mallinger was the oldest , ctim of saturday's massacre. her daughter, andrs among the wounded but is expected to recover, the "pittsburgh post- gazette" reported. friends of rose told the newspaper, "you've never met a more vivacious 97-year-old...fu she was just s of life.be and joyce fi was a researcher at the university of pittsburgh development center for more than 25 years. in a statement, the center called her "a cherished iend" and "the proud grandmother to her grandchildren." she was 75 years old. >> woodruff: now to the roiling dete over immigration, and recent moves by president trump to both stop illegal crossings into the u.s., and use the matter as the midterms approach. nick schifrin looks at this politically and socially divisive issue. >> schifrin: on dover force base, american soldiers head t

richard gottfried. he was dr. rich, as people called him. he was a dentist, he had a dentistry practice with his wife. she was actually catholic, and together they prepared local couples for marriage through her catholic church. he was also well known in one of the local school districts, treating a lot of these children and their families as they grew up here in the squirrel hill neighborhood and beyond in pittsburgh. the school district certainly remembering him today and saying their hearts are broken. also, joyce feinberg. she was 75 years old. she had been a research specialist at the university of pittsburgh. her husband had passed away from cancer a couple of years ago, but students remembered both of them, welcoming them into their home, mentoring them. serving them up love and also camaraderie. she was also remembered as lighting up a room. one person said she was a small woman, but she had a big personality, that she was elegant and warm and very kind. and also, a pair of brothers. cecil and david rosenthal. they were really known