. >> joe, i don't think the historian richard hofstadter had this in mind when he talked about anticlericalism in america. >> taking it a step further, isn't it? >> this is beyond that, no more people, joe. how do you respond to those sorts of claims? how do you respond to that kind of lyrical performance? i don't know, it is pure practical, pure performative. how do you respond to that? you state your position, you state your position clearly, dismissed the foolishness, what the position is. you might even call it bullishness. at the end of the day, i want to go back to something as i was taking about my wrist wants to president biden's remarks in the oval office yesterday and i think about this in donald trump, i am working on this new book, joe, and the question, what happens to the american idea when the future is no longer available to it, because the past has followed everything up? we are so nostalgic about what has gone on before. we want to reach for something in the past. what joe biden did last night, no matter what you think about his policies, or whatever, whether you disagree wit