. >> i came here to speak with the family's attorney, richard rosenthal. he makes numerous leaps of faith as to what exists. there is no in-depth analysis here of statutes or the law. quite honestly i believe she's wrong. >> the family has been fighting caesar's return saying it will take extra measures for his safety and the safety of others including muzzling and sending him to a special obedience school. this is something that the family of the victim, the 12-pound chihuahua charlie, says says is absolutely not enough. >> this fight is not over yet. >> unfortunately, sometimes judges do what's expedient rather than what's right. >> not only are they going to appeal this judgment but they have filed a different lawsuit for the treatment of caesar while he was behind bar. >> the fact is the new york state agricultural and market requires they provide veterinary care. >> caesar lost over 30% of his body weight without the people even noticing. >> this is modern-day idiotic see. i would've flipped the switch and ended his snarling murderous life. >> i think

rosenblum >> joshua alan rosenthal >> richard david rosenthal >> philip martin rosenzweig >> daniel rosetti> richard barry ross >> norman s. rossinow >> nicholas p. rossomando >> michael craig rothberg >> donna marie rothenberg >> mark david rothenberg >> james michael roux >> nicholas charles alexander rowe >> edward v. rowenhorst >> judy rowlett >> timothy alan roy, sr. >> paul g. ruback >> ronald j. ruben >> joanne rubino >> david m. ruddle andrew,y cousin, one,enant fdny, engine formerly of the nypd. i spoke to one of his guys, the last one to see him. he said he got everybody out and had to go back in for one more woman. that is what firemen do. god bless the fdny, the nypd because we needed you want a day like that, and thank you to new york city for making a place like this, that we can remember, and people can come from all over to see what happens on this date 15 years ago. for all of my family that can't bring it to themselves to come down here, andrew, we love you. a true hero. [applause] my two equally lovely and beautiful first cousins, maria.d much.e and miss you so it has bee

. >> joshua allen rosenthal. >> richard david rosenthal. >> philip martin. >> daniel rosetti. >> richard>> nicolas p resume on no. rochford. craig >> donna rothenberg. >> mark david rothenberg. >> james michael group. >> nicolas charles alexander rove. >> at word rowan horst. -- edward. timothy allen roy senior. >> paul ruback. >> ronald ruben. >> joanne rubio. >> david am ruggles. andrew, lieutenant engine one, formerly of the nypd. , theke to one of his guys last one to see him. he said that he got everybody out and had to go back in for one more woman. that is what firemen do. god bless the fdny and the nypd. thank you to new york city for making a place like this that we can remember people can come from all over to see what happened on this day, 15 years ago. that can'tfamily bring it to themselves to come you,here, andrew, we love a true hero. [applause] >> to my two equally lovely and judyiful first cousins, fernandez and maria. we love and miss you so much. it has been 15 years, yet the pain and sorrow is still else by your family, relatives and friends. most especially, your par

rosenblum joshua alan rosenthal richard david rosenthal philip martin rosenzweig daniel rosetti richardsomando michael craig rothberg donna marie rothenberg mark david rothenberg james michael roux nicholas charles alexander rowe edward v. rowenhorst judy rowlett timothy alan roy, sr. paul g. ruback ronald j. ruben joanne rubino david m. ruddle >> and my cousin, lieutenant fdny engine 1 formerly of nypd. i spoke to one of his guys, the last one to see him. he said that he got everybody out, had to go back in for one more woman and that's what firemen do. so god bless the fdny, the nypd. and thank you new york city for making a place like this so we can remember and people can come from all over to see what happened on this day 15 years ago. and for all my family that can't bring it to themselves to come down here andrew, we love you, a true hero. [applause] >> and for my two equally lovely and beautiful first cousins, judy and maria, we love and miss you so much. it's been 15 years yet the pain and sorrow is still felt by your family, relatives, and friends. most specially your parents