commissioners on that motion then to approve items three and four mr. content pulling - >> commissioner antonini commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fongbe the first item on the regular calendar that motion passes unanimously consideration of adoption of draft minutes for july 2nd i have one correction from commissioner richards. >> any any public comment on item draft minutes seeing none, public comment is closed oh, sorry, sorry. >> good afternoon, commissioners yes. i wanted to thank commission secretary for the examination of my summary statement for the sunshine provision any summary hundred 50 words or less shall be included in the meeting thank you very much. >> is there any additional public comment not seeing any public comment is closed. >> move to approve with the one small correction i gave to the commission secretary. >> second. >> on that motion commissioners to adopt the minutes campaigning commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero and mrs. place you on item 7 commissioners questions or comments. >> commissioner a

commissioner >> move to approve. >> on that motion to do you want the minutes for june 18th commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner president fong. >> so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 7 to zero and places you under commissioners questions or comments. >> commissioner richards actually 4 things today i'll try to be brief there was an article in sunday paper by carl about the change in the city a good article it talked about what if we hadn't of changed the way we're changing and if it is good or bad in the end he talks about san francisco's intackle soul and the fact that all the chances we're seeing we don't want to lose to soul you can interpret that but some of the soul of the city with the actors and other people are displaced it is a good balance article and the second in this morning's paper i see airbnb a new body being prepared by the mayor one of the items we had before us when we have the airbnb second round legislation 3 other processes of register of enforcement the additional folks we asked them to be move over okay. great then the fourth thing i know that during the budget discussions and furt

a prohibition an retail conversion commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore no commissioner richards commissioner wu no commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 4 to 2 about commissioner moore and commissioner wu voting against. >> commissioners that will bring us back to item 13 for the case pca in violation of the code correction ordinances a planning code amendment. >> playing music chairs here good afternoon, commissioners aaron planning department staff today, we're asking you to initiate an ordinance to correct the errors that repealed in the reorganization update the code and make non-substantial code to clarify the text since the packets went out the city attorney has amended it by additional clerical errors and amended the title to better reflect the ordinance staff a.d. park with cu when was inadversarial deleted in they organization and a amendment to the planning code to make at planning code consistent with the city's charter action before the commission is the initiation of the initiation did not involve a substance of the amendment it only requires the 20 day notice period the commiss

good commissioners there is a motion and a second to initiate and schedule a hearing commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner fong so moved commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero commissioners that places us on item 16 cu a on van ness street a request for conditional use authorization please note on may 21st the commission directed the sponsor to look at retail spaces and continues to july 2nd by a vote of 7 to zero and on july 2nd the commission approved an intent to disagree with the option for the project sponsor to look at the retail activation and continue the matter until today. >> good afternoon commissioner president fong and members of the board the item before you a request for a confusion for the proposed project on the ground floor of an existing 5 mixed use building on van ness street the mixed use has 18 dwelling units above the vacant and a below grade parking garage with 18 parking spaces the project site is locate open 79sdz northeast corner of valencia and 20th street within the van ness transit zoning district and a 55 height and bulk it is psyching conditional use authorizati

commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you under our cohere calendar items 13 ab for the case third street those are mandatory discretionary reviews. >> good afternoon commissioner president fong and members of the commission i'm jeff planning department staff ms. the application for a marnd or mandatory discretionary review for the property on third street project site on the west side of third street and in a zoning district and 68 height and bulk the proposal to demolish the mixed use building and construction of a new 6 story building commercial on the first floor on a lot of 25 feet wide and 90 feet deep a 7 unit residential building for parking garage underneath and the rooftop and elevator mandatory discretionary review hearing is required for the removing removal of an existing dwelling unit and the neighborhood notice was implemented and no discretionary reviews were filed we've received one e-mail and no comments in opposition to the pro

commissioner antonini. >> move to approve. >> second. >> commissioners on that matter. >> commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 5 to zero and zoning administrator, what say you? on the variance, close the public hearing and noting the lot the size and shape thank you i believe the commission will be taking a short recess or no? >> you guys need commissioners to let you know commissioners need a break but the next three or four 4 items are supervisor legislation we'll take a short break they have a conflict another community meeting we'll take items 14, 15 ab and then 13 in. >> good afternoon and welcome to the planning commission regular hearing for i'd like to remind the members of the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. please silence any devices that may sound off during the proceedings. commissioners, we left off on your regular calendar and taking a few things out of order item 14 15 ab and 13 and then continue as agendized so commissioners on item 14 accessory use and entertainment in the western districts. >> goo

>> commissioners there is a motion and a second to not take dr commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu no commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 5 to one is commissioner wu voting against commissioners general public comment there are no speaker cards cards. >> sue hester can you turn on the oh, there's some games were being played here the agenda for the board of supervisors land use commission came out at 1041 before the planning commission started and supervisor wiener and supervisor christensen asked their motion to be on mondays calendar to be vote on, on monday i'm sorry tuesday so all the time you've all saying there is enough time to deal with this when half the board of supervisors was a big lie and you have to face if you're playing a game supervisor christensen and supervisor wiener did they know it, of course, that calendar came out this morning and pout u put on the calendar by them i'm asking you to do what you have the power to resend our vote to have a tiny bit of serious discussion what is happening in district 3 and 8 because people were deceived i've been trying to

commissioner wu. >> i'm shot of it is a step in the right direction i move to approve. >> second and commissioners on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 15 ab pca planning code amendments to allow the seary dwelling units in district 8 and 3. >> hi kim with the dispatching before you today are two ordinances appropriated by supervisor wiener and supervisor christensen to allow the dwelling units in district 8 and respectfully i want to invite supervisor wiener that want to talk about the ordinance and followed by supervisor christensen who will join us later. >> thank you and commissioners good afternoon and thanks for having me today and hearing those items i understand that supervisor christensen leaving committee and walked u walking up here she'll be here momentarily this legislation is existing we're gradually step by step adding accessory in-law units into their buildings and to make that one piece of the solution in addressing our housing crisis and housing shortage and so the legislation that i am authorizing will take what i previously au

. >> commissioner antonini no commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong no that motion passes 5 to two with commissioner antonini and commissioner president fong voting against commissioners, that places you under your on item 10 this is a planning code and zoning district map to rezone a place of diego rivera even though street to and it will rezone dagget street to right-of-way public space if i may have the slides so the notion of dagget street started during the eastern neighborhoods this is the open space on the eastern neighborhoods that identifies a need in the area where show place square meets mission bay showing in the circle the show pates e appetites square identified the opportunity site for open space that's site number 5 on that map in 2010 the project sponsor of the housing on the other side of dagget right-of-way wanted to build the parish for the eastern neighborhoods fees that was supported by the eastern neighborhoods and this commission in kind agreement an updated in kind agreement will be coming to you next week so the park will be

commissioner wu. >> move to approve draft minutes and second. >> on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 5 commissioners questions or comments. >> commissioner antonini. the court: yeah. i have a couple of things first of all, an article in the online part of the san francisco business times by corey wen beggar he did an analysis of the cost to build affordable housing new or to acquire existing housing and turn it into affordability the latter is cheaper than building it new worth taking into account and the other thing it is kind of we discussed a lot of times who's driven up the costs in south of market area to include the mission integrity and the eastern neighborhoods i remember as a child coming out san francisco from the east bay where i grew up smelling the smell of coffee and giants games and the before hery and in practice having patients with steel mills in the district best foods had a factory and fashion lawn had a factory to build lens heavy industry in the area south of market and incl

commissioner antonini and commissioner johnson and others. >> is that amenable. >> two motions otherwise a motion to deny. >> sure. >> on that motion commissioner antonini commissioner hillis excuse me. commissioner johnson. >> commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioner, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero commissioners that will place us on item 12 for case no. california street this is a question for conditional use authorization. >> commissioner. i'd like to introduce you to another new planner you've not met yet excuse me. one minute folks have the conversation out in the hall please. excuse me. susan sorry could we take the conversation out in the hall sorry. >> i wanted to introduce you to another new planner is joined the department as a planner one on small projects she began as a interim and worked on the storefront she has a batch in architecture from the university of illinois and holds a master from the school of the arts in chicago we welcome her. >> thank you good afternoon commissioner president fong and members the commission i'm planning department staff case before you is a request for qualifying inform allow the standards 5 and dime a hardware and general store to expand over 5 thousand dollars 894 feet

commissioners for clarification the motion to take dr and take it as modified the last set of plans priority by the project sponsor. >> commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and . >> thank you to lou lou. >> and place. >> yes. thank you lou lou. >> thank you for on the job those children being as well-behaved it is equal understandable but want to acknowledge they were fabulous i hope you'll - >> congratulations. >> commissioners that will place us on our last dr item 19 at clayton street. >> lou lou lou lou can i explain it to her outside. >> good evening. i'm david lindsay of dispatching? a discretionary review of a building permit application to legalize the edition of a between within the building fourth floor the subject building is at clayton street between waller in the argument the immediate area is characterizations by three and four residential buildings that contain generally two to three units with some larger residential buildings the property zoning is rh3 fourth floor to your knowledge was added to the two unit building in the late 1940s and it was described as a social room

private agreement with t n d c commissioners commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 13 for case no. 2014 at 250 howard street and beale street app an office allocation. >> i'm kevin guy with planning department staff the request before you is an allocation of office space under the limitation program it will constrict a new tower with a roof height of 4 hundred 50 feet and the building will contain 7 hundred and 667 gross office space and approximately ground floor retail and bloov parking if i could haveoverhead the lower area in pink is the lower areas of the site but drektd in green it adds 18 thousand square feet of open space at the northwest and southwest of the lot and the tower additional open space around 44 hundred secret is protruded within the redevelopment area there is open space at howard and beale street this open space satisfies the sites for the previous sites at howard and fremont street the lot cantonese a deck with a retail use so this existing open space tha

commissioner moore. >> move to approve. >> second. >> commissioners on that motion to approve the updated and all the time in kind agreement commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and place you on tomes k ab at 3 61 turk street and las vegas worth this is a conditional use authorization as well as a downtown project please note at this hearing and closing the public hearing it was continued to july 9th on a vote good afternoon commissioner president fong and members of the commission kate planning department staff you have before you a project to construct two buildings on two separate lots 2 m.d. units mrs. it is 10 thousand 3 hundred square feet lot area leavenworth cantonese approximately, six hundred square feet of lot area both lots are as many parking lot are a total of 64 parking spaces the project sponsor will give a presentation for the updates i'd like to focus on the regulatory issues per in other words to proceed the project has a granting of two entitlements a downtown authorization for leavenworth a conditional use authorization for turk street the property on leavenworth requires a

commissioners there is a motion and a second as proposed with the modifications commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and item 15 for case 19th street discretionary review has been withdrawn that places you commissioners on item 16 for case lake effort court a discretionary review. >> good evening devin washington located on lake forest court a new 4 story vertical addition over a sfarment that is zoned rh1 detached located opening statements on the northwest side of the lake court the project sites a relatively level lot with a slight lateral slope murray 24 feet wide with a lateral existing building constructed in 19 61 a defined and uniform character with two car garages due to the typography for example of buildings one street frontage but appears 3 story buildings usually at the rear it was set out for 367 notification in 2008 and a discretionary review was filed, however the dr was not sent before the planning commission and it remained in active until 2013 and renoticed no additional dr was filed but the early dr was city actual

commissioners there is a motion and a second to certify the environmental impact report commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 11 and good afternoon, commissioners i'm here to talk about the dagget in kind agreement for a points 9 acre park on a dagget street right away it is located in the intersection of 16 and 1-800 you've never driven counsel there but a land owned by itself city it is portland it is shores of mission bay and so it is in the state trust for a long, long time in kind is proposed by itself developer of joining development there is 4 hundred had he 50 units being built on the dagget street right-of-way and the proposal for the park a commemorate reduction of eastern neighborhoods so the original in kind agreement was approved in november of 2012 that was for one $.88 million and now we have in front of if you the reason we're in front of you a lot has happened the negotiation how to transfer it the rezone and the placing program for public site not on the park things that have not changed the design of t

commissioners there is a motion and a second to approve with continues as amended by the city attorney both a motion and staff report. >> commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong snauchld unanimously 6 to zero commissioners that places you in your discretionary review calendar on mammals after a discretionary review. >> commissioners are you okay motoring through here okay we're all slipping. >> good afternoon good evening planning commission washington the south west team leader the subject property is on mammals avenue it was a 5 feet by 31 that is extending beyond the first floor and adds one thousand 2 hundred and 9 secret it is located in the rh1 zoning district it is located on the north side just north of silver avenue in the outer mission neighborhood south of golden gate park glerp it has a wide construction and the early to 20 century and to the north rare property lines had has a total line and the existing residence is 9 hundred and 61 square feet footprint and was constructed in 1914 the primary dr filer is east of the subject property the filers southern side april's that is the north property line of the project manager two additional neighbors

president and 5 on that motion >> commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously and my thanks to you all as well commissioners shall we move on to the next item. >> yes. >> very good commissioners that places us under department matters directors announcements. >> thank you. >> thank you, john as several things to report on today one the final budget being related to short-term rentals and commissioners mentioned you approved a budget sent to the mayor's office that included the 3 position that were provisional is the wrong word but positions to be created but not necessarily filled unless there is funding identified and the mayors final proposal voted 3 additional positions were put spot zoning administrator, what say you? office with the two agencies form an office of short-term rental that frps in the paper you saw today, we're still working on the logistics but all 6 positions will be working together in one location at an office the public can come to register with anything with short-term rentals it is

. >> commissioner antonini human resources no arrest commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 5 to one with commissioner antonini voting against commission will take a full break. >> quickly if there's any member in the audience for item 21st century at 19th street a discretionary review that item has been withdrawn withdrawn. >> welcome back to the planning commission regular hearing the audience that the commission does not tolerate disruptions of any kind. xhefs under your regular calendar for case numbers 5 m and t and e sunnyvale hope sf presentation for the environmental impact report please note the paesh on the draft eir is closed and the public period ended on february 17th. >> good afternoon commissioner president fong and members of the commission i'm matt with the department staff to all entitlements for the hope sf sunnyvale projects you have the certification the entitles are not before you net e yes, he did. we wanted to give you a presentation the substance of the prosecution and background open hope sf i'm joined by

commissioner antonini. >> commissioner johnson commissioner moore no commissioner richards commissioner wu no commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes 4 to 2 with commissioner moore and commissioner wu voting against. >> commissioner moore. >> commissioner president fong it might not important to refer the applicant to the small business commission and they're helping small merchants finding spaces perhaps mr. super could follow-up. >> or sf aid or any merchant in the city thank you. >> commissioners that places you under our discretionary review calendar for items 17 at 45th after a request for a discretionary review. >> good afternoon dell convenient southwest team leader subject property it is contradicted in 1904 a race base with concretes foundation the surrounding areas are sfanz that were constructed during the first half of the century locked in the rfp zoning district for a vertical expansion the work involved extending the building 7 and a half feet and adding a businessman became /* bathroom and the attic was to be combaerlg the plans were misdemeanor significantly reducing the

and a second to approve with conditions commissioner antonini commissioner johnson commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu commissioner president fong and congratulations so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero zero. (laughter). >> commissioners, that places you under your - one sort of housekeeping a request by commissioner richards to reopen item 7 to maybe change some votes or get clarification the problem is that aaron has left and scott has also left so i suppose what we can do we can reopen it and vote to continue it and hear it again, when staff is here to present it. >> or if you feel comfortable. >> i misunderstood i should have covered outline projects. >> for the da to be involved. >> i think you can open it to clarify that i mean and. >> so i'll amend - >> so we need to move to reopen item 7. >> can we open item 7. >> second. >> i'd like to amend my second having the zoning administrator be involved in all projects. >> clarify both categories the projects. >> question. >> commissioner johnson. >> well, i have to agree i'm the maker of the motion i'm architectural with that amended only to say th