. >>> rick scott bans the word "climate change" from his state but does nothing to stop the effects. part three of our series riding tide, the climate crisis still ahead on "the ed show." stay with us, we're right back. you can call me shallow... but, i have a wandering eye. i mean, come on. national gives me the control to choose any car in the aisle i want. i could choose you... or i could choose her if i like her more. and i do. oh, the silent treatment. real mature. so you wanna get out of here? go national. go like a pro. >>> we are following severe weather in the state of oklahoma at this hour. a tornado warning is in effect for grady county near chickasaw, oklahoma. joining us by phone, msnbc meteorologist bill karins. bill, what's the latest? what are they facing out there? >> well good evening. we have confirmed tornados in kansas. the tornado threat goes until 10:00 this evening all the way from southern nebraska down through kansas oklahoma into texas. now, we're not going to see a widespread outbreak. this one storm we have been watching just east of interstate 44 about 4

. >> florida senator rick scott and others declined a request for a sit-down interview.erica tonight" tracked down to ask what should be done with the money. management. >> translated, no sugar land deal. it will be spent on other state projects that environmental activists insist were not part of amendment one. "america tonight" asked if lawmakers were living up to the votest expectations. >> any property use of amendment use? >> it goes to the overall objectives of the agency. >> reporter: if the state fails to buy the land by the deadline, the price tag surely will go up. now that florida's economy is surging, u.s. sugar no longer wants to sell. and the sugar industry usually gets what it wants in tela hassy, thanks -- tallahassee, thanks, critics say, to generous campaign contributions. u.s. sugar and executives made half a million to state candidates for 16 races, according to the "tampa bay times", sugar in south florida is anything but sweet. it's a bitter pill. >> back in the everyglad, the bad news echos for the saw crass and the cyprus tree. once billed as a bi

researcher joined a group of climate scientists for a meeting with florida's republican governor, rick scottted online. >> when we are trying to get resources from the state of florida they can't talk about the climate change part of it. >> christopher is a former florida state attorney, working on waterway issues. he told al jazeera america he was put on notice. >> they said if you know what's good for you we will not use the terms climate change, global warming, sea level rise or sustainability. >> reporter: governor scott denies there's a policy against discussing climate change. >> department of environment protection - look, there's lots issue. >> what is hard for politicians to get their head around is how to respond to what will happen in 2100. >> reporter: that's when miami beach could be under 6 feet of water. what is your opinion when republicans say man has not caused climate change. >> as mayor, i don't have the liberty or time to debate why climate change is happening. all i have is the opportunity to fix it. that bay is not republican, it's not democrate, it knows no limits. no

look what happened to florida gop governor rick scott. he said do not use the term climate change in epa -- in the state epa policies. and guess what? the greenies want to investigate him. i think it's really bad. >> john it's happening. those states -- these new rules won't be in effect for another year but it's already beginning to happen. is that right or wrong? >> i think the tragedy here is that fema exists in the first place. look back to hurricane katrina because that's very instructive. if we didn't federalize disasters, let's face it weather is different in all 50 states. the citizens of new orleans would never have elected such an incompetent as ray nagan who was clue less once fema struck. people might elect people with a clue such that katrina wouldn't have been such a disaster for new orleans residents. >> i don't want to bury the lead here. mike what do you think about john saying fema itself should be eliminated? >> i think he's absolutely right. in john's larger point really i think is the fact the more power we give the f

and in the tea party wave of 2010, you had rick scott and scott walker and john kasich who rejected severaley ended up getting diverted into incremental borrowing sort of not so interesting projects. so the obama promise which was earnestly made and -- and in good faith ended up not working in part because there was a partnership that wasn't fulfilled between the states and the federal government. >> so amtrak cites the acela top speed of 150 miles per hour. a symbol of progress. the reality is a lot different. the acela averages 69 miles per hour on that corridor, the most popular one between washington and boston. other rail corridors are even slower. why can't amtrak speed things up? >> i mean, look, if you look at the acela corridor, it's chugging along, hitting different cities. it's hard -- there's a madrid to barcelona which goes an average of 150 miles per hour or so. there are lots of stops in between. part of it is the infrastructure is old. you would need something like $150 billion to upgrade the track, to gets newer cars. to get dedicated tracks. one of the big problems -- this

and we are blessed to have rick scott as our governor in florida and i am representing the governor right and we are suing over, this saying basically if you don't accept the medicaid expansion we're going to pull or we can pull your low income pool. >> let me ask you quickly. >> these are the poorest of poor families, greta. that's what is so sad. this is over a 2 billion-dollar program that they are threatening to take away from floridians, our tax dollars if we don't expand medicine cadz that is not a job for the president. >> follow what the court says. i want to get to another court issue. there was some charity frauds in florida there has been a recent settlement for agreement. >> yes. absolutely. this is a great warning for consumers. we have great cancer programs out there. but there are three. it's called cancer fund of america. children's cancer fund. and breast cancer society. this is a national settlement that we have done with ftc cancer charities. if you are going to donate check with better business bureau go online and make sure it's a legitimate charity. >> finally, are y

>> i'm going to be with my friend rick scott in florida next week. neil: see you there. >> we're not conceding anywhere. i'm pointing out jeb bush and marco rubio will have a distinct advantage. neil: you think one of them is going to whip that state? >> i think we'll make the case anywhere in the country including florida. neil: you're not nicking it? >> no. in the end if i run and if i become the nominee florida is critically important, it's a state my grandfather was a machinist, spent last retirement years in ft. myers to go fishing. neil: not a bad place to do that. on the august iowa straw poll, are you going to participate? >> we're not committing to anything until we make a decision whether we're in or not. anything that requires -- neil: many are dropping out. >> i guess many have said that. we'll make a decision whether we make an announcement what our intentions are. we're not committing to forums and straw polls. neil: you can't win on this one, you lead in polls in iowa if you nicks that iowans might be offended. if you participate, you

the meantime don't forget neil cavuto coast-to-coast we will have the ohio governor john kasich, rick scottgovernor bill richardson we are going to have presidential donors from both sides and many more it starts at noon eastern. many of you have been saying that we want the very latest happening at that very minute. so we are going to do that for two hours. because we care, and that is howtartight we roll ♪♪ ♪ >> weird and unique. >> a man puts a dusty weigh station on the map, but the down and his legacy foul on hard times. >> i was hear from residence it was an eye eyesore. >> has he left his family a money pit. >> keep it in the family at all cost. >> or a monument. >> sometimes in life we don't appreciate things until they are gone.

under the current governor, rick scott, state officials have been banned from uttering the change climateg in public though his administration denied it. today, jeb bush was pressed on his characterization of people who accept the climb change as intellectually arrogant. >> why do we have to have a debate where people may have doubts about this are considered neanderthals. that's the arrogance. it's the arrogance of saying people who have a different well thought out view that somehow aren't as intelligent or capable. that's what i think in order to forge consensus, you can't have this kind of attitude. >> now the intelligence capable non-neanderthalist, writer for buzz feed news. >> all right. >> yeah. it's true. okay. let me get my spill here. this is what is fascinating. you see jeb bush on climate integration, which has been big this week. you got democrats, leaning into issues, climate and immigration. they think these are 55% plus issues, 60% issues. they're on the right side of the ledge. hillary clinton is going to be aggressive, she has hired a dreamer. she has executive action.

rick scott up into various parts -- break that up into various parts.ign investments and critical sectors, defense or insurance or construction. achieving all of that in the matter of one year is a great achievement. up,e: all right, coming just one hour into the trading day in japan and south korea. we look at the early market movers. ♪ let's do a quick check on the markets, gains on the nikkei to 25. a lower yen today. it is falling. what we are seeing on friday rising tostreet, snp a record but we are seeing a selloff for australia in equities, .1% down. online at 12:00 sydney time. seretary kerry is visiting oul today. in equity markets we are seeing losses, .2 percent lower. singapore is trading 15 minutes from now and it is pointing to a lower open after domestic oil exports contracted, dropped it .7%. but it was better -- dropped 8.7%. but it was better than what was forecast. >> welcome to the stock exchange, let's check in on what reporters are watching. electricwatching because one of the reactors could be getting the green light get atart and

. >> from rick perry to scott walker, 11 presidential hopefuls, 1300 republican activists in iowa with republican chatter to root beer float. donald trump was peddling a photo op with donald. each candidate got 10 minutes to sell themselves and their plan for victory in 2016. but hillary clinton beats all of them in head-to-head matchups. >> i think republicans have been disappointed that some of the stumbles that hillary clinton has encountered do not seem to have wounded her. >> but republicans believe that cumulative attacks will whittle away her strength. >> can you beat hillary? >> we don't know whether hillary is going to be the nominee or not. >> if there's many more scandals that come up, even the democrats are going to sour on that. >> serving up some wishful thinking or the recipe for a win. chris jansing, nbc news, des moines, iowa. >>> there is a new study tonight. it states that some of the kids suffering from as ma may also have an allergy to peanuts. i'm joining by dr. natalie azar. the upshot here, some kids who have asthma should get a peanut allergy test. >> yes. if y

jeb bush got higher marks as governor, rick perry longer, scott walker is more current. i don't see where george pataki fits in. mark: i agree that he's not emphasizing the one thing that would make him different by any means. i do think he could impact the race in three ways. one, he's a smart guy. if he cannot find his way to the literal debate, he could do some damage to other republicans. two, he will focus on new hampshire. only chris christie has got a centric a path. the last thing is this message, which we will listen to later -- smaller government. lots of other people are running on it, but he's running on it with an anti-washington sensibility that i think will help at least as the argument along. al: i want to cover the george pataki/bobby jindal debate, the battle of the 1% or's --one percenters. mark: you not only have to grow your support, but you have to pass over 16 other guys and one gal in order to get to the top. it is daunting. he needs a lot more luck than one or two people dropping out. in this crowded republican field, everyone is looking for a wa

. >> scott: [ echoing ] well, rick insisted on getting back to l.a. away. >> eric: we're lucky you were at the crash. >> scott: his car was off the road -- in the trees. he must've been going pretty fast. >> rick: [ groans ] where's maya? >> brooke: oh, rick, honey. >> rick: is she here? >> brooke: no. >> rick: has she called? she was in a car in front of me. we were on the phone, and she asked me a question. i have to see her. [ keys clacking ] [ maya sniffling ]

from rick perry to scott walker 11 presidential hopefuls plugged activists in iowa with everything fromse to ice cream. donald trump was pedaling a photo on with donald. the glad handling followed speeches. each candidate got ten minutes to sell themselves and their plan. but hillary clinton beats all of them in head to head matchups. >> i think republicans have been disappointed that some of the stumbles that hillary clinton has encountered over the past couple of weeks do not seem to have wounded here in a serious way. >> can you beat hillary? >> we don't know whether she's going to be a nominee or not. if there are many more scandals even the the democrats will sour on that. >> reporter: wishful thinking? >> and in case you missed it mitt romney showed up in a suit to face off against evander holyfield in the boxing ring. he went two rounds with the heavy weight champion been throwing in the towel. the event raised more than $1 million for a charity which provides eye surgery and screening to poor people in other countries. scrambled politics is next. there's some facts about seaworl

from rick perry to scott walker. 11 presidential hopefuls in front of activists in iowa from everythingrom wisconsin cheddar to root beer floats. the grand handling followed speeches. each candidate got just ten minutes to sell themselves and their plan for victory in 2016. but hillary clinton beats them all in head-to-head matchups. >> i think republicans have been disappointed in some of the stumbles that hillary clinton has encountered over the past couple weeks do not seem to have wounded her in a serious way. >> reporter: still, republicans believe cumulative attacks will what wear away at hillary. can you beat hillary? >> we don't know if hillary is going to be a candidate or not. >> reporter: serving up some wishful thinking or a recipe for a win. >>> in case you missed it over the weekend, former presidential candidate mitt romney jokingly showed up in his suit. to face off against evander holyfield in the boxing ring. romney went two rounds with the heavyweight champion before throwing in the towel. the event raised more than $20 million in charity that will provide eye surgery

rick perry. scott walker. even jeb bush has officially told us that he is running. there are only a few spots there. are we overcrowded? >> it is hillary clinton or cricket. a plethora of alternatives. donald trump is a kind the kind of guy that means what he says and he will mix up the race. they will have to be careful that they do not create a certain firing squad. that will be critical. at this point they should be quite pleased that there are this many capable qualified people. melissa: maybe that is why hillary clinton has been so quiet. >> it is also because she is so dominant. to your point pete they are curtailing the number of debates. that will create more disciplined this time around. far more diverse city. we have a generational mix as well. bernie sanders and hillary clinton who are both eligible for medicare. you put texas on the stage next to hillary clinton you cannot put any more contracts and terms of a generational shift. >> thank you very much. appreciate it. thousands of air traffic controllers. demanding an investigation into the faa. adam sha

rick scott over in florida. i can promise you, rick gets up every day and figures out way to make his state more competitive. bobby ginnedjindal. bobby gets up every day trying to figure out how to recruit businesses from texas to florida. i have to look at my regulation policies to keep texas more competitive. but that's how you do it with competitive programs, and it's worked. josh: we're just about out of time this half hour. very quickly, for those wondering tonight in the audience, when will they know whether ricky perry is running again? rick perry: end of may, first of june. 2015. josh: you came in late last time. that is all the time we have for the television portion of this program right now. coming up next on our conversation with the candidate series. we have former erer hewlett packard ceo carly fiorina. and this conversation continues online and the mobile app. you'll find a full 30 minutes more, all of it, commercial free. for now, thanks for watching, have a great night. [captioning performed by t

governor rick scott, mayber bob buckhorn, the county commissioners have been so supportive of our projectampa is on the move these days. this city is doing great. >> speaking of being on the move jon cooper the coach has done a tremendous job. how much longer is he going to be with the team. >> i hope for a long time. he's not on the move. the only place he's moving to right now is madison square garden. steve yzerman is our general manager, up for gm of the year we have great people in the organization. whether it's hockey, real estate, the stock market it's all about good people. >> you also have a lot of former rangers on the team as i understand pitting some former teammates against once another. how is this going to contribute to the game seven atmosphere? >> there are several former rangers players on the lightning, former lightning players on the rangers. you don't need extra motivation. this is for a trip to the stanley cup final. >> doesn't it always seem like hockey goes to seven games. >> it does because it's the greatest sport. it's so even during the season it's a dogfight to

it's much easier for rand paul, for rick perry, scott walker who don't own those decisions, who don't have a lot of the members of their staff being part of the architecture of making those decisions in the first place. i think this sa big moment. and all these republican candidates are going to be interviewed by her. i think it demonstrates they better have their a game when they go sit down with her. she makes news every time she interviews a republican heavy weights. >> every republican candidate wants to take us backward. they all want to have at least a cold war with iran if not a hot war and they all want to go back to a cold war with cuba. >> the republican party is totally out of syny with policy toward cuba. they want a new path. on iran, majorities of americans want diplomatic resolution. they don't want more war. i will say both parties are complicit in forming a new cold war with russia. the united states has badly handed what could be an escalating crisis. >> we're going to bring everyone back after the break. we're going to talk about the big showdown tomorrow over trade

rick santorum hinted he is close to announcing if he will run for president. santorum was among a number of presidential hopeful hossa dressed conservative activist in south carolina today. the scott walker, rick perry marco rubio ted cruz, even donald trump spoke at the owe called freedom summit in greenville. santorum will hold an event at the end of the may in his hometown of butler, pennsylvania to announce his decision. >>> first lady of the u.s., delivered the the commencement against today at tuskegee university and michelle obama talk about the recent racial controversies playing out in some cities across the the country. >> while we've comeau far the truth is, that those age old problems are stubborn. and they have not fully gonna way. >> mrs. owe bam invoke story history of the university as she urged new graduates to face their fear and doubts with courage and conviction. she told 500 graduates to trust themselves and chart their own course toes leave a positive productive mark on the world. >>> it was also graduation day for a whole bunch of colleges and universities across our region. here at chestnut hill college hundreds of graduates some with brightly decorated cap

scott walker, marco rubio, rick perry, and donald trump. and more. mark, you will be there in group will be streaming the action on bloomberg politics.com. who am when i cast of stars was the most out of line? mark: the guy i am watching his marco rubio. his team is underrated. it is one of the strongest teams any candidate has put together. rubio might end up being a better cultural fit in a political force in south carolina then new hampshire and iowa. john: i would have said marco rubio would be my call, but i like to disagree with you. today, i will choose scott walker because right now, if he had to pick a front runner just based on polling, scott walker is two of the head of the field. you can see marco rubio coming up fast. all are has not had a big moment in weeks. he has to try to re-seize the momentum or he will see himself eclipsed by rubio. jeb bush is already hovering in the wings. mark: another guy not in south carolina is john kasich. he is in columbus today. we are reporting that he is having a big powwow. other big figures in the par

also speaking was governor scott walker, former governor rick perry. we will show you some the speeches starting with governor walker's. [applause] ♪ gov. walker: freedom. freedom. endowed by our creator, defined by our constitution, but defended each and every day by the men and women who proudly wear the uniform of these united states. let's begin by asking all those who have served, our veterans, all those who are serving, active-duty, the guard, or the reserve, and since it was military spouses day yesterday let's invite their spouses and family members, let's have them stand up and give them a round of applause. [applause] gov. walker: thank you to each and everyone of you. we are going to talk about freedom today. i know you love your country. that's why you serve. we love this great country we call america. thank you for making it possible for us to have events like this. i have to begin by saying thanks, it's great to be back in south carolina. the last time i was here we talk to grassroots activists, i went over to the harley-davidson dealersh

we will show you some the speakers at the freedom summit including wisconsin governor scott walker, rickerry, and real estate developer donald trump. chris tomorrow is mother's day. starting at noon, we present the children and grandchildren of america's first families, a tribute to first ladies. speakers include susan ford, lyndon johnson, caroline kennedy , the bush daughters and others bring here is steve ford talking about a mishap with the fireplace at his first family dinner at the white house. steve ford: the first the dinner , i will be quick. the first a dinner we had is a family. there is a tension when you first go there and you do not know the staff and they have been at there for years and you rotate through. you try to get to know each other and everybody is a little formal. we are sitting at the dinner table, myself, mom and dad, and sister, susan. everybody is trying to figure it out. my dad is trying to take the edge off and notices a wonderful fireplace. and he says, when we used to go to colorado for christmas, we always loved to have a fire. one of the people who work

jeb bush, scott walker, rick perry, chris christie, bobby jindal. south carolina senator lindsey graham has been a character for decades making more and more noise about making a serious run. ohio governor john kasich is talking about running. rick snyder of michigan is making similar noises about running now. he will come in at about the same tier as john kasich. mike pence of indiana did have a bit of a national setback with his anti-discrimination stance last month. he is a prospect for the presidency. i understand because i know you that you laugh at the prospect of a donald trump candidacy, but donald trump, believe me, is actually hiring campaign staff in multiple early voting presidential states. and donald trump polls surprisingly well among likely republican voters. this year, the role of tim pawlenty will be played by george pataki in the sense that to the outside world he is a bit of a snooze fest, but governor pataki is well respected and well connected in republican mainstream politics. john bolton, the angriest ambassador ever, another

here are the names of some carly fiorina, scott walker, rick santorum lindsey graham rand paul ben carson as well as donald trump. you can watch for the candidates to use quick one liners to separate themselves from the rest of the pack. >>> music lovers are remembering a legend an an icon this morning. ♪ >> overnight we learned that the king of blues, b.b. king died at his home in las vegas. king wrote unforgettable hits like "the thrill is gone." he was inducted into the blues foundation hall of fame and the rock and roll hall of fame. he suffered from dementia. he was 89 years old. people say his music will live on forever. >> if you ever listened to the music, no matter what the subject was. you sat there with a smile and a tapping foot whenever he performed. >> his music transended a genre. >>> 6:21. we want to get you up to speed on the forecast. we're starting off kind of cool. >> meteorologist tom kierein with our forecast. weather and traffic on the 1s. >> i'm so bummed about b.b. king. i saw him live back in the day. he was wonderful. the fingers on the guitar were like playing

cspan3, we're going to show you the first few hours of the summit including wisconsin governor scott walker, rick santorum, and former governor w jobs again that were previously unimaginable. >> tonight at 8:00 eastern on cspan2. >>> a number of republican 2016 presidential candidates and others that are likely to run spoke at the south carolina freedom summit in greenville over the weekend. here on cspan3, we're going to show you the first few hours of the summit including wisconsin governor scott walker, rick santorum, and former governor rick perry. watch more of the day long coverage at cspan.org. >> please welcome david bossey. [ applause ] . >> well, good morning greenville! what a beautiful day. what an amazing event we have in store for you today. and i'm just so proud to be here co-hosting this event. this unbelievably important event with my good friend, jeff duncan. i want to first of all say thank you to each and every one of you for coming and spending your day. it is also a fitting way to start out by saying happy mother's day to all you moms out there. appreciate you. [ applause ]

jeb bush, marco rubio, ted cruz rick perry, you get the idea. today, scottalker spoke first written he delivered a new argument for why he is different. >> there are a lot of great people think about the race on the republican side. there are some people, some of those folks, particularly folks in washington who are fighting the good fight, waving the flag. but they haven't won a whole lot of victories. then there are other folks that have done an effective job of winning elections, a lot of them are friends of mine. they won a lot of elections but they haven't taken on a lot of those fights. the reason why i am thinking about what i am thinking about, we won't announce anything until the end of june, i have yet to see anybody in the emerging field who has done both. going forward, we need somebody who can fight and win the battles we need to move this country forward commonsense reforms, that is what we need to move america forward. mark:john: you can catch all the action for the next couple of days. how politically potent do think that argument will prove

ben carson, ted cruz marco rubio, scott walker, rick santorum and you're all vying for that bloc of votersn you differentiate yourself from all the other candidates competing for those christians? >> first of all, i think among evangelical christian, i'm not somebody who's just started talking about the message. this is who i am. and i have a long history of being consistent with this. but here's the secret my support in '08 and i think in '16 is not limited to evangelicals. i believe the heart-and-soul support i did have and have today is represented by the working class people across america who feels that washington is utterly disconnected from the lives they have to live. >> you said as president, i promise we'll no longer to contain jihadism we'll conquer it and deal with jihadis as we would deal with deadly snakes. what exactly does that mean? where would you send troops that we don't already have troops? >> it's not just about sending troops. it's about arming the kurds which we should have done from the beginning. they never asked us to come fight their battles for them. they just

ted cruz and ben carson and rick santorum and scott walker all chipping away at his base of evangelical in fifth or sixth or fourth place in iowa which is the race that he won back in 2008. he got more caucus votes than anybody in the history of the republican party in the iowa caucuses yet he's not caught fire there and that's where he needs to win. he can be a viable contender but the money's going to really matter and whether he can somehow consolidate that base because where he starts is where the people that love him most. >>> still ahead, a loving portrait of the legendary comedian joan rivers from her daughter melissa. she joins us on the set. >>> but first, a new documentary being shown at colleges nationwide and there's a good reason why. a stunning look at sexual assault on campus and what the filmmakers call an institutional effort to cover it up. when broker chris hill stays at laquinta and fires up free wi-fi, with a network that's now up to 5 times faster than before you know what he can do? let's see if he's ready. he can swim with the sharks! book your next stay at lq.co

jeb bush, mark -- marco rubio rick perry, you get the idea. today, scott walker spoke first.e delivered a new argument for why he is different from the rest. scott walker: there are a lot of great people that think about the race on the republican side. there are some people some of those folks, particularly folks in the washington area who are fighting for the good fight, waving the flag. but they have not won a whole lot of victories. there are other folks who have done an effective job at winning elections read a lot of them are friends of mine. they won a lot of elections but they have not taken on a lot of those fights. i have to tell you, part of the reason i am thinking about what i am thinking about, we haven't announced anything yet, we won't until the end of june when the state budget is done or if i have yet to see anyone who is done both. i think going forward, we need someone who can fight and wind not just in the battle box, but someone who can fight and win and reserve -- six reforms. john: you can catch all of the action for the next couple of days. how politi

you have a lot of candidates, including mike huckabee who won in 2008, rick santorum forum who won it in 2012 scott walker, then carson, potentially rick perry, a lot of candidates competing for that far right vote. if that vote splinters in iowa and you end up with a more establishment candidate say someone like jeb bush who is not very strong in iowa right now but given a huge field all conservatives, a more centrist candidate or more mainstream candidate, a bush or a rubio, if they come up and win in iowa and that vaults them in a situation to win new hampshire or, that could matter a whole lot. >> schieffer: mark -- >> i just think that there is no logical firewall for a general bush. i think new hampshire actually will be more interesting, sitting here a year and a half out than iowa just because there is much less -- actually not a year and a half -- well, sorry, i a am getting my calendar messed up. look it is more of a clean shot. i think the jeb bush campaign there, i think that would be the logical place for him to win, i don't think south carolina is safe for him and this big cluster of

jeb bush rick perry, rand paul rick santorum, lindsey graham scott walker john kasich chris christie richard wolf you cannot believe that every one of those names in the not yet announced column is going to jump over into the announced column. are we really going to have a pataki a jindal candidacy for presidency? >> a situation where each and every one of those think this is a republican year and if these other people are running, why on earth shouldn't they too? that kind of dilution is what is rampant through the republican field right now which is to say look we have a great bench. we have no star players. why can't i be the star player. that kind of mind-set is going to be each and every one of them. rick santorum can do it i can do it too. >> annie, do we have john edwards and joe biden to blame for this in that they ran presidential campaigns that ended up getting the vice presidential nomination? >> that's a good question. i think it is the more the merrier here that they all have a chance here. i can see they all have a -- here. the last time around there was a lot of republ