rob aline says that between 2019 and today it is. quinn, toppled its exports to chile, bolivia, paraguay, and uruguay. their plasm afforded them and we have pushed hard on chinese and european products here with some targeting lower value products. and europe targeting higher value ones a little up and under a lot of road to them are short on that de la, both the war and the pandemic had a big impact on the increase in logistics costs and also on inflation. because they've been lame, flashy on. according to wrap aline, european ceramic companies have doubled the production costs due to the increase in energy prices. gina, a, china has had an impact that the greatest impact has been on the logistics level. the containers that were around $2000.00 before the pandemic. now, cars $20000.00 to $25000.00. prices have dropped again. but they're still much more expensive. but as you, but while it would your mccarrow latin american countries with some industrial development like mexico, brazil and argentina can take advantage of export opportunities in a region traditionally focused on the extrac

robbed. there is encroachment the historical bla, bla, bla, you know we see if mar system alined with jupiter. over gate stuff. i'm in support. any other thoughts before public comment. okay is there public comment. there is none. double checking, public comment? no. okay. close public comment. >> seeing no public issue public comment is closed. the synthetics was the mural. in new york they're phasing out the solid roll down gates they attract graffiti. parts of the city where graffiti is a significant problem. for all the reasons that commissioner ortiz brought up ip supportive of the legislation. i would not make that support conditional on my recommendation but i think i would like to include that recommendation. would everybody be amenable to the a motion that includes that as a recommendation but not as a condition? upon i mentioned there should be optionality for future policy makers. regarding the look and feel of it. i don't want to make it conditional on it like you gota do this or we don't support it. i hear had you say we near a you have a set of businesses very vulnerable and the