joining me now is robby suave, a staff editor at reason.com, one of the first journalists to consider that the story might be a hoax. robby, what was it about this that from the get-go caused you to have doubt? >> thanks for having me. there's several details in the account that are very, very incredible. namely, that she wasn't drugged or incapacitated through alcohol. alcohol is a common feature in most sexual assaults on campus. and also, that it would have had to be elaborately premedicated. they would have had to plan it out involving so many people to such a degree that it just kind of strained -- it would have been unique, unlike any other kind of assault that's happened on campus. so -- which is not to say it couldn't happen. but all those things made me say, is this -- is this absolutely true, is it perhaps embelli embellished? and particularly that she seems so grievously injured from glass shards and being punched in the face and raped, a terrible, terrible experience, that unfortunately didn't seem completely like it plausibly happened. >> robby, i want to show you a parag