robert carper. and his long—time friend, jim, was an actor in paris in the 1930s.. and that group was joined by george roger, who was a nonconformist adventurer. i think they changed photography in different ways. when you look at carper‘s wall pictures, he was more concerned with the pictures of suffering than any glory from the war. i remember another picture of the independence of indonesia. and robert capa's pictures from palestine... they didn't want to be told what to do. that was more important to them than having a nice fat salary. this was from a big magnum show. it was a cooperative at a family atmosphere. everybody was very affectionate. when robert capa and chim came in from paris, they brought perfume and elegant things. there was never any idea of being i'm the boss, or you're the secretary. a christmas parties, capa would come and dance with the bookkeeper. i don't know whether i was more enchanted with the personalities of the photographers than even with the photographs. and magnum photos is still going strong today. that is it from witness for thi