robert fruchtman, please go ahead. you need to unmute yourself. yes. okay uh, good evening commissioners. my name is robert fruchtman. i am a volunteer lead with, uh, san francisco yimby. uh, speaking in support of the appellants. uh, i think the planning department's position, um, on the housing accountability act does not make a ton of sense. this seems like a pretty blatant violation of the housing accountability act from where i stand. see, looking at the 2021 permit, um, the planning commission imposed conditions on the on the permit and referenced old findings, old conditions that were put on a different project. um, and the planning department is now saying that these new conditions have the same force of planning code. but this frankly, is an out and out violation of the housing accountability act, which says that, uh, objective standards must be knowable to both the, uh, the project sponsor and the department at, at, you know, when the project is filed, the project sponsor would have no idea what the planning commission would say at a discreti