we are the deputy speaker rosie winterton responding to the i rosie winterton responding to the smp'sr constituents, with mps “ust shouting each other down. how much shoutina shouting each other down. how much shouting has — shouting each other down. how much shouting has there _ shouting each other down. how much shouting has there been? _ shouting each other down. how much shouting has there been? i _ shouting each other down. how much shouting has there been? i mean, . shouting each other down. how much shouting has there been? i mean, a i shouting has there been? i mean, a lot really. this happens in the house of commons, is an adversarial chamber where debates have been on a day—to—day basis, where passions can run high. but this evening, a lot of finger pointing, rounds of applause and, you don't get applause in house of commons in support of individuals. dame rosie winterton is the deputy speaker, it isn't herjob to decide on what is happening with the voting on these amendments today, trying to work out a way forward. and sort of defend the decision that lindsay hoyle had made

that has been categorically denied by the deputy speaker rosie winterton. finds themselves in the firing line of the people who don't like those opinions being able to express whether they prevail or not. and this is i think a sign of how avirulent our politics is becoming, where the speaker is in the firing line. i think one important point we have to bear in mind about lindsay hoyle's decision — he admitted he had made mistakes, it wasn't the outcome he was looking for in terms of denying the snp�*s opposition day — but he has said since he became speaker, he is very concerned about the safety of mps. and we know that a lot of mps have come under pressure and threats over the positions which they're taking on the israel—gaza situation. we know some of them have contacted him, and basically what they were looking for was an opportunity, as we saw looking for was an opportunity, as we sanohn mcdonnell, the former shadow chancellor, due to put where they stand on the record so that their voters and people criticising them in the wider electric could know whe

would it be rosie winterton him.s ? other two, other tory deputies? um, it's not really clear. and it's not really clear why the tories want to get rid of lindsay hoyle. if not just to cause trouble for labour. cause some trouble for labour. i think that that's part of the concern and gone quite concern and it has gone quite far now . far now. >> some names being thrown >> yeah. some names being thrown around and include bradley around and include karen bradley , who of course is chairing the procedure committee in the house of commons. so she knows her procedural onions , if you want procedural onions, if you want to put it like that . some other to put it like that. some other names perhaps eleanor laing, one of the deputy speakers , um, of the deputy speakers, um, maybe even william wragg, who's putting forward this motion of no confidence. chris bryant well , chris bryant well, chris. >> well , yes. , chris bryant well, chris. >> well, yes. now you've mentioned three tory mps and one labour mp there. and that's b

house to know the decision making process, but actually we needed to get to the votes and it was rosie winterton who didn't allow us to have the vote, but the discussion took place and the discussion is important . and that, i think, is important. and that, i think, is what we must continue now . now what we must continue now. now with my very distinguished panel , the former editor of the sun, kelvin and the kelvin mackenzie, and the historian broadcaster tessa historian and broadcaster tessa dunlop, tessa, we have got into the interstices of the details of parliamentary procedure which may fascinate me, but actually is not what everybody wants to hear about. they want to hear about what should the british government do in relation to israel gaza, and what we israel and gaza, and what we have do today is send have failed to do today is send a united message from our nation to israel, but not to just israel, also to hamas. >> it is a mess. it's a disgrace. and actually it's somewhat ironic that strapped across big ben is the word stop . across big ben is the word stop. presumably it's a ceasefir

house to know the decision making process, but actually we needed to get to the votes and it was rosie winterton didn't allow us to have the vote, but the discussion took place and the discussion is important . and that, i think, is important. and that, i think, is what we must continue now . now what we must continue now. now with my very distinguished panel , the former editor of the sun, kelvin and the kelvin mackenzie, and the historian broadcaster tessa historian and broadcaster tessa dunlop, tessa, we have got into the interstices of the details of parliamentary procedure which may fascinate me, but actually is not what everybody wants to hear about. they want to hear about what should the british government do in relation to israel gaza, and what we israel and gaza, and what we have do today is send have failed to do today is send a united message from our nation to israel, but not to just israel, also to hamas. >> it is a mess. it's a disgrace. and actually it's somewhat ironic that strapped across big ben is the word stop . across big ben is the word stop. presumably it's a ceasefire me