. >> good afternoon commissioners, virginia and rowson behalf of the permit holder. under the rules of the board rehearing can be granted except in extraordinary circumstances. we are showing new facts that at the time could have affected the time of the hearings. these could have not met the standards. mr. williams and his brief argued it was merited by a procedural formality. the motion failed by 3-1 with one of the commissioners absent. this doesn't justify rehearing in this case. first the board had the option of rehearing the matter. it wasn't required by rules or statute. as a result there was no procedural violation occurring from not continuing it and it doesn't constitute extraordinary circumstances. second, both parties appellants and respondents were conducted at the board to resolve this immediately as possible. respondent agreed immediately and appellant did not dough -- do so and this causes delay. the boards final motion for the reasonable balance on the interest. the trees aren't going to be removed until the advertisement hearing -- title hearing fro