toil investigators, she and other white house officials were so concerned about activity the of rudy gulianiin ukraine they consulted with a lawyer with national security council, "new york times" and associated press went further saying that bolton, compared guliani to a grenade blowing everybody up. today guliani responding telling fox in a statement saying: >> today democrat on the committee defend their tactic, the fact that interviews are secret and not publi publicly rd the transcript. >> here is eric. >> it corroborates wit with whae president said. reporter: they have deposition scheduled for the week, today george kent, a senior state department official, he matters, he was at u.s. embassy in ukraine between 2015-18. you have an overlap between obama administration and trump administration, he can speak to the specific allegations that rudy guliani was allegedly part of this push to get rid of sitting u.s. ambassador. republicans say, they want to precedent on -- kent on other riches related to corruption on joe biden and his family. >> what did he know about burisma? a corrupt fore

and says that he was concerned that rudy guliani was influencing the president's view on cooperation in ukraine. he writes -- >> shepard: volckers will said this about joe biden. >> shepard: in addition, three house committees released dozens of texts last night between u.s. diplomats discussing how to handle the president's request for ukrainian officials to investigate his political rival, joe biden. one of the texts suggests the country's new president would get a high profile visit to washington. it reads -- >> shepard: we're learning more from key witnesses about what happened leading up to and after the july the 25th call at the center of the whistle-blower complaint. and we're getting more signs from the white house that president trump plans to stonewall house democrats just as he did today. john roberts with the latest on that live from the white house. first, catherine herridge reporting live from outside the hearing room on capitol hill. catherine? >> in the last few minutes, we reached out to the whistle-blower's legal team. we have new information from sources familiar w

to rudy guliani speaking with our lou dobbs about his talk with former ukraine prosecutor who he told rudy guliani. >> ukrainians came to me, they told me for a year and a half they were trying to get to fbi, they believed there was something wrong with our fbi because they would not take the investigations, reason i gave it to state department, my witnesses did not trust the justice department, i tried to convince them once bill barr was there, they didn't have to worry, but they don't understand, that i said, okay, i gave it to mike pompeo, pompeo they'd say would investigate, i delivered some notes back. i never heard back. elizabeth: democrats say this is all you know conspiracy theories, what your reaction? >> you know, i don't have any evidence in front of me, we know that former vice president biden, while vice president, bragged to fact he was holding the lone to ukraine government until a prosecutor who was investigating company that his son was on, as member of board who had no basis or background to be on a board of an energy company, was getting paid 50,000 a month to sit

and also more questions surfacing about joe biden and his son hunter as trump's personal lawyer rudy guliani asking, does anyone really believe that china and ukraine companies made for hunter's expertise? how did a trillion dollar become the new billion for 2020 democrats? the democrat race is looking like a massive tax spend arms race. and we have latest on i.c.e. rounding out criminal illegals in a multitude of states, they were already charged with felony, including violence crimes. i am elizabeth macdonald. the "evening edit" is invested in you. we start right now. elizabeth: welcome, you are watching fox business network. we have all action in washington d.c., hillary vaughn on capitol hill. reporter: speaker nancy pelosi assuring her democratic colleagues, they are still on track to get something done with the usmca. she wrote this in a letter to her democratic colleagues yesterday, we're addressing our core concerns on strong enforce. labor pri prescription drugs and environmental protect. pelosi also interrupting her october recess to hold her weekly press conference tomorrow. we ar

there was an issue of whether or not he contacted rudy guliani. he said he sought out rudy guliani on advice of the president in deals with the corruption in ukraine. could that have affected his decision t to resign. >> time will tell. follow there is any responsible he has for contacting mayor rudy guliani. he has been there are think over two years. that is the general time frame in tenure a secretary would serve. i don't think that this sun usual. looking at ha he has done under trump administration, we've seen more growth in the energy sector. we look at job creation for every energy job, at least 6 additional jobs that have been created, he has done president trump as well as overall american economy very well. >> i think that is highlighted, there is questions around timing of his stepping down, since president did say that perry urged him to take the call in july with the ukraine president. then, most recently we know that perry has been subpoenaed and asked for documents relating to ukraine. there is a lot of information still yet to come

rudy guliani is a fine man. he was the greatest mayor in the history of new york and he's been one of the greatest crime fighters and corruption fighters. rudy guliani is a good man. >> would you like to see your justice department still investigate biden? >> i think what biden did and his son and now they're finding also romania, that just came out or some other country and i'm sure there's more than that. when a man walks away who has no talent, no skill, no experience with $1.5 billion out of china, when he walks away with $168,000 a month for him and his friends from ukraine, when ukraine supposedly gave him $3 million, whatever the numbers are, then he's got no experience in oil, no experience anywhere and now other nations are coming out. i heard one today, i want embarrass the nation. all he's doing in my opinion, that's a pay-off. you don't pay that kind of money for any other reason and then you look at what the father did with oil. let's get oil and all of a sudden let's not get oil. now he's a great e

the committee he had been uncomfortable with the involvement of the president's personal lawyer rudy gulianin policy. i'll have more on this with our north america correspondent in a few minutes. the head of the imf, kristalina georgieva, has welcomed progress in trade talks between the us and china, but warned that more needs to be done to resolve the issues that divide them. economists estimate that new tariffs and taxes will knock about $700 billion off the world economy next year. protests have continued for a fourth day in barcelona after senior separatist leaders were given lengthy prison sentences for their part in the 2017 independence movement. trade unions have called for a general strike on friday. tributes have been paid to veteran us congressman and civil rights leader elijah cummings who has died aged 68. as chair of the powerful 0versight committee, the maryland representative clashed a number of times with president trump. house speaker nancy pelosi said congress will miss his wisdom, his warm friendship and his great humanity. more than 2,000 oarsmen have rowed 52 boats down

today democrats subpoenaed rudy guliani, this is three days after secretary of state pompeo got a similar subpoena. today wal "wall street journal" reported that pompeo was on the other end of the phone call with ukraine. and after president released his transcript of that call. and in it, he asked for help investigating joe biden, but claims that call was quote, perfect. yes. his critics say it is proof of corruption. watch. >> president well understood that it was illegal to seek foreign assistance in a campaign. and immediately after mueller testified that is what he was back at doing again. >> your republican colleagues say that call is the call. but there nothing here that rises to the level of high crimes and misdemeanors. >> they are wrong. kennedy: they are wrong. all this impeachment talk making president angry. he has been tweeting about it almost nonstop, he should be -- from that carpal tunnel. much of i direct add lped add td adam schiff. saying: >> that is good. the president referring to schiff's opening statement last week, before the testimony of director of national inte

melissa: rudy guliani has been all over television show, how that different. >> not recently. of course, now having higher council and latest representation of my first reaction highwa how can he testd gaffe gat1/2 great around? -- navigate around, not easy. >> we'll need your expertise thank you. >> thank you. melissa: all right we're keeping an eye on other stories. in california, new rent control law to help fix the state affordable housing problem. under the law, california will captainial re rent increase, 5% plus rate of inflation, and it makes it tougher for landlords to evict tenants. >> chicago conde nast traveler survey of readers, picks. its architecture as first rate, and museums, great food unites e people. hong kong -- is abandoning the bid, to buy the london stock exchange. tie up would have created a 7 billion dollar giants. london expects concerned including hong kong exchange's ties to government of chinese territory that's gives mainland ruling communist party influence over its operations. >> and oprah winfrey made largest endow a endowment in hif moore hou

you know, i look at mayor rudy guliani, going on some talk shows, and sometimes he makes sense, some a great defender of the president, other times it seems like he is lost his mind. o understand that former south carolina representative trey gowdy has been added to the president's impeachment legal team. >> i think former congressman was coming out of congress, rudy guliani has been looking into this as others have for many years, there are legitimate questions about business dealings of vice president bidens son while he was the vice president. but trey gowdy was in congress at the time, and up until recently a fox news contributor, great to have him on the team. >> is he legal face of the fight? >> i leave that foe lega to leg. kennedy: it might be a good idea. >> no doubt this president will be fully armed and ready to go in thelma and louise -- squad. >> they might, they may impeach him. i don't think he will be removed, he could be energized and reelected. i don't think they can impeach him again in second term, not because of double jeopardy but they would lose badly. >> i thi

deirdre: in new york city, a court die for associate of president's personal lawyer, rudy guliani areillegally funneling foreign donation to president trump and others, fox news reporter lick k levin thaleft. >> the arraignment lasts less than 15 minutes, they pleads not guilty, calling this a smear campaign, federal government said it has evidence to prove both men funneled unaheads of thousands of dollar foreign money in shell companies to make illegal contributions, the men and worked with president trump's personal attorney rudy guliani, and reportedly collected dirt on the former u.s. ambassador to ukraine, and pushed ukraine government officials to investigate joe biden, and his son hunter. "wall street journal" released a video pictures from the instagram account showing him with guliani on a private jet, and campaign evens and dinners, leading to 2018 election, also traveling with guliani, to london, paris and warsaw. >> but florida real estate entrepreneur who government said were trying to form a recreational marijuana business, said they did nothing wrong. >> good afternoon

how is that situation with rudy guliani any different? he was paid 500,000 because of his "political connections" and personal attorney to president. >> and how different from trump family, they have done the same thing as bidens, and obama and bush and clinton family, jonathan is right, nepotism has been going on forever. it does not make it right, but it does not make it illegal also, if you are a company and can hire someone with that influence, that is not breaking the law. should the vice president perhaps have stopped it yeah or maybe the obama administration or president trump with his family. david: the thing that i think you are all forgetting that vice president biden stopped to stop thes investigation of the prosecution that was looking into the corruption of the company, largest natural gas company in ukraine, burisma. loaded with corruption. this prosecuter, lord knows whether he deserves to be fired. but for the vice president to try to demand the firing of a prosecutor who is looking into his son's business that rookies of

the committee he had been uncomfortable with the involvement of the president's personal lawyer rudy gulianiica correspondent, peter bowes, has the latest on mick mulvaney‘s admission. it really came out of the blue. he was talking to journalists at the white house and he appeared to acknowledge that there was a quid pro quo scenario in relation to ukraine, the withholding of funds, of military aid, in return for an investigation — not an investigation into the former vice presidentjoe biden, but an investigation into the hacking of that democratic national committee server that has also been the subject of an investigation. but the key point being the possible withholding of funds in return for that investigation. i was involved with the process by which the money was held up temporarily, 0k. three issues for that. the corruption in the country, whether or not other countries were participating in support of the ukraine, and whether or not they were cooperating in an ongoing investigation with our department ofjustice. to be clear, what you just described is a quid pro quo. it is funding wi

the committee he had been uncomfortable with the involvement of the president's personal lawyer, rudy gulianiy, peter bowes, has the details. guys! could this bet gun? an apparent admission from one of the most seniorfigures in an apparent admission from one of the most senior figures in the white house that military aid was being withheld from the ukraine in return for a politically motivated investigation. a quid pro quo. mike mulvey new surprise reporters when he said funds were held back to put pressure on ukraine over an investigation into the hacked server belonging to the democratic national committee. i was involved with the process by which the money was held up temporarily, 0k? three issues for that. the corruption in the country, whether or not other countries where participating in support of the ukraine and whether or not they were cooperating in an ongoing investigation with the department of justice. to be clear you, you just described a quid pro quo, funding will not flow unless there is an investigation into the democratic server? we do that all the time with foreign policy.

that is valid, i think sending rudy guliani to talk to ukrainian operatives is where you have a heardime explains it. that is where president appeared to be a little bit flat footed. >> people have a right to say does this president do everything in the most diplomatic and articulate way. in the best -- of good diplomacy, we could have a debate about that, but that is not a debate about impeachment. the mutua impeachment did the president perform high crimes or misdemeanors now, did he pis off al green, the fact is that -- >> that not a the reason to imtype of impeach someone. >> that is al green's reason. kennedy: you could make a case bill clinton selling satellite technology to chinese government, and some of the wmdfraud in launching the iraq war, up -- potentially that was impeachable for president bush and every administration, look at pallet 400 million in mixed denomination cash to iran from president obama, every administration has something by this standard is impeachable. >> you are saying right thing, we have to get past the idea that i-word is something we use, we never h

rudy guliani should not be trainses across eastern europe unregular president's errands in name of nationalecurity, flip side so far weirdness has not risen to reach impeachment threshold, we just have scraps to feed the hungry ofs cancel culture, that needs to sit its down before it bites itself in the ass, that is the memo. kennedy: president obama of face of democrat party for 8 years. you can hardly recognize him among current spate of 2020 dems, so has the left gone too far left? our party panel here, chris. the president -- former president is right about that. problem is there are so many on left, they get mad at you, you are then the enemy, they want to insulate themselves from you, but they are fed this hysteria by the current crop the candids run aring for president. >> barack obama is an alt-right sympathizing biggy on the, what sympathizing bigot. what he said there people have been canceled for saying, he is right. how insane things are. the political process has become so emotional, all sides everyone is justifieding their emotion there is no conversation about what is good or

. >> this is -- he is using america's foreign policy, sending rudy guliani, and his henchmen there come on. kennedy: that is wrong, i will give you that, so is using fbi asset christopher steel to drum up information from the kremlin. kremlin. >> would people on left any american, prefer we not investigate this? what if people sitting here ready to attack this country electoral process a year from today, we have the opportunity too find them, stop them, we have a new president, zelensky saying i am against corruption, can you please fine them or be we it don't investigate and a year from now, same people would attack. >> deroy, deroy,. kennedy: okay. >> fbi. mueller -- >> everyone is saying, guess what there is no -- >> john brennan did they say that? >> yes. >> i think you are mocking -- >> but you know -- >> no antipatriotic antiamerican hack. >> everyone is deep state except trump, you are kidding me? >> a new president. >> dedicated to fighting corruption. would you look into this, find out who people who tapped into our election make sure they don't do it again. >> juan. kennedy: a

today democrats subpoenaed rudy guliani, this is three days after secretary of state pompeo got a similar

potentially rudy guliani with house contempt charges they if they cone cooperate, now saying that, dems you have to wrap it up by the end of the year, bring in congressman mcclintock. thank you so much for joining us, it could take cares in the court. >> not necessarily, united states versus nixon in watergate water was handled in weeks. i think steny hoyer understand -- >> said in the court, no to using contempt. your take? >> i think he understands, how crazy the talk about out and arresting administration officials and holding them in the capital. sounds to the general public. this is crazy. when there is a dispute on issuing subpoenas between two branches, judiciary makes those decisions, ideally suited to do so. elizabeth: here is the thing, will there be a shut down over impeachment before thanksgiving? the government is running on fumes, we have continuing resolution for government. >> i can't read minds or tell fortunes. but, i can tell you, that democrats are so obsessed on impeachment, nothing else is happening it would not surprise me if we run afoul of the deadline. elizabet

. >> here we are in middle of an impeachment inquiry, joining us president's attorney, rudy guliani.at he calls an illicit impeachment inquiry on the part of radical dimms. we will talk with the congressman jim banks about his motion to censure nancy pelosi, and ronna mcdaniel, head of chair of republican national committee. we'll talk with pet peter navar, about all of the work that the president is getting done. it is a big deal, while being savaged from all quarters by the left and radical dimms, it will be a hoot of a show, liz, i hope you will join us. elizabeth: a hoot of a show, lou dobbs thank you so much. >> thank you. elizabeth: get to republican governor kim reynolds of iowa. your honor thank you for joining us. >> i am happy. elizabeth: elizabeth warren is rising in polls your reaction? >> well, you know, i really don't think it matters who the candidate is, she is leading for the first time. as first in nation caucus we encourage the candidate to come to iowa, come often, talk about their message. that is best message to help reelection republicans up and down the ticket

evidence of text messages between state department officials expressing concern as early as may that rudy guliani- there was a guliani-biden thing going on that had concerned a state department official. >> these are very tense times between house democrats and the white house. neil? >> neil: thanks very much. greg is we me from florida. very important guy here. a lot of things and people will go through him. where is this going, congressman? what is your sense? >> well, the democrats will stop at nothing to impeach this president. that's very clear. started with the russian collusion hoax. the mainstream media sold a farce to the american people. that turned out to be nothing. so adam has moved from obstruction to corruption and now to the whistle-blower complaint. there's nothing in that transcript that i have said and i read the transcript that would be a high crime or misdemeanor that would be an impeachable offense. none of the democrats have articulated to me or to the american people what that specific high crime or misdemeanor would be. >> neil: so a lot depends on what -- we've got the t

you know, anderson cooper, asked kamala harris what laws did president trump's personal attorney rudy guliani break, she could not answer. watch. >> are there specific laws that you believe guliani has broken or may have broken? >> well, i , i, i don't know, we'll find out. elizabeth: so she is a former prosecutor, she conditio can't . >> i am a former prosecutor, i can't answer to the president or mr. guliani, i think that what we need to do is focus on moving important issues forward get off this impeachment, this is a distraction and causing a lot of tensions between the sides that pro heb itprohibits us from worg together to solve important issues. elizabeth: a piece from kimberly stlastras el, she is concerned t impeachment will be used in a partisan way to attack opponents, and saying that democrats are moving the goal post here on what is impeachable. >> offense is that donald trump demanded a quid pro quo he would with hold ukraine aid to the ukraine unless the country gave him dirt on joe biden, we saw the transcript, we had ukraine say, no there was no quid pro quo, they said they d

rudy guliani, joining me.he is looking to possibly suing adam schiff. kennedy, begins now, see you here tomorrow. kennedy: nba shot an air ball to china, now lawmakers want to kick them in the loose balls. saying i league ignored china's human abuses. hi. >> mori tweeted. fight for freedom stand with hong kong that sparked a backlash in china, causing mori to delight the tweet, and issue a lengthy apology, still calling

because he's the secretary of state, he can provide most insights and rudy guliani is dealing with shadowy individuals which what gave the president of the united states the opening to conduct foreign policies off the books in a sense - for that reason, he's critical and we have to hear it from him and answer questions like that just under oath. it is only so far he can sort of stall and hide. we are going to hear from him at some point. these privileges that you hear executive privilege and so on. we are going to hear from him. he's going to testify. >> the cable bill that was sent, this was when taylor expressed frustration of the situation where the aide had been held up. bolton says tell pompeo directly send him the cable. taylor does. pompeo gets asked about this cable and here is his response. >> what did you do with that cable? >> i am not going to talk about it. >> did you relay his concerns to the president? >> look, i came here to talk about the great things that are going here. >> john, it was simple question. and he just did not want to answer it. what does that tell you? >> i

perry said he did seek out rudy guliani, but he said he never heard anyone in the administration or anyone connected to the white house, which is code for guliani or the ukrainians discuss the possibility of an investigation into the bidens, trace. >> i know you been busy this week. what's on the schedule for next week? >> one of the big witnesses is bill taylor. he's a top diplomat in ukraine. more of someone that you want to think of as a career diplomat, someone at the state department. we know from the texts that he challenged the administration's approach to ukraine and these are the texts that everyone points to that involves gordon sondland appointed by the president and the point man for the european union. bi >> what we learned through sondland's testimony this week is that he was uncomfortable with the use of the president's personal attorney as a conduit with the ukraine. he felt this was a job better suited to the state department. as a final piece of bookkeeping, the republicans on the house intelligence committee sent a letter to the democratic colleagues. i lays out the amou

security adviser john bolton was concerned about the impact of the president's personal attorney, rudy guliani. "he cautioned that mr. guliani was a key voice with the president on ukraine, which could be an obstacle to increased white house engagement." the house is expected to vote on a resolution to outline next steps for a more public phase, including open hearings and giving white house attorneys access. >> today in my view, the majority is admitting what we all know. that's that the house was not following an appropriate process. >> some democrats are noting this moment in history. >> five or ten years from now, peach will ask each of us what we did in this moment. they'll ask us what we did when confronted with this crisis. >> not all democrats are sold. new jersey's jeff van drew is vocally opposed and some from the midwest are fielding tension with members on the left. >> it's flatly not a resolution that impeaches the president of the united states. why do you want to call it -- why would anybody want to call it that when it's clear lieutenant not the case? >> the senate majority lea

investigation have been charged with federal campaign finance violations they're associates of rudy gulianiere arrested trying to board an international flight with one-way tickets. cheryl: a government watcher has been arrested for stealing taxpayers' identities. tracee carrasco has the details. tracee: an irs agent is accused of stealing multiple people's identities and racking up nearly $70,000 worth of charges in their names. he allegedly used the names, addresses, dates of birth, social security to open credit cards and go on vacations and shopping sprees over two years many it is unclea unhow the empe got the personal information. dyson is shutting down plans to make an electric car. they've been working on plans for the last four years and claims to have developed a fantastic car but couldn't find a way to make the vehicle commercially viable. most of the employees working on the project are expected to be absorbed into dyson's home division. boeing and porsche are partnering up to make an electric flying vehicle. earlier this year boeing tested an aerial car that could fit four peop

republicans who want to defend the president to be able to do so especially when you factor in rudy guliani'svement here, the reporting that he's under federal investigation right now and the fact that rudy giuliani and donald trump are so intertwined, they're almost interchangeable within this ukraine scandal. s that's what democrats are trying to hammer on here as they build a case to impeach the president. eric: is that boom ranking for the republican -- boomeranging in terms of the president's support. >> you mentioned francis rooney earlier, the fact that he's not seeking re-election right now. there's more than just fran sigh rooney happening right now -- francis rooney happening right now. a lot of it is republicans grumbling about the fact there is no coherent messaging strategy from the white house, making it harder for them to defend the president against the allegations, as many of the hearings are conducted in secret and lawmakers are technically not allowed to talk about what they see behind closed doors. eric: how much of an impact will that be? you have rooney, you have a few o

guliani is a highly respected man, he was mayor of new york city, a great mayor, i would like him to call you. i will ask him to call you with the attorney general. rudymuch knows what is happening he is a capable guy. you could speak to him that would be great. the former ambassador from united states, woman was bad news, people she was dealing with in the ukraine were bad news, so i just want to let you know, that other thing, oh, there a lot of talk about biden's son. that biden stopped prosecution. and a lot of people want to find out about that. so whatever you can do, with the attorney general, would be great. biden went around bragging he stop prosecution so if you could look into it, it sounds horrible to me. what in the world is wrong with that? everything that president talks about here is public. joe biden bragged about stopping the prosecutor. president of the united states, raises it. and so the democrats and media say, he was trying to interfere with the election, to draw the ukraine into interfering with the election. how so? how so? joe biden did not do anything. what is the problem? drawing ukraine into the election, what this idea th

rudy giuliani. there's no doubt about that. so we're going to want to know what guliani knew about them.at attorney general bill barr based on fox news reporting knew about the investigation when he took the job, was informed of the arrest, that the arrest would be happening. that's daylight. that says that, again, following the rule of law and doing his job. that's very important to point out. maria: byron, we're waiting to hear from bill barr and john durham in terms of their findings in the origins of the russia probe. i've been reporting that we're going to get the ig report from michael horowitz on or around the 18th, which is of course next friday, october 18th is when i'm hearing that report is going to be out and it's i heard from one source it's as thick as a telephone book. what are you expecting in terms of the ig report? any new information to add, byron? >> i heard you say that, as thick as a telephone book. i wouldn't be surprised at all about this. one of the things i'll be looking for, remember, we were talking about this report possibly being released in june. so it's fo