insist, whether dear anriivna, but you did not answer how much money is in the road fund, dear ruslan oleksiiovych asked that there be fundamental, conceptual amendments, there should be a fundamental conceptual amendment, so that the people's deputies and those who watch us, our fellow citizens, not spectators, not supervisors, yes, so that they understand what the verkhovna rada did not vote for, what amount the verkhovna rada , together with the cabinet of ministers, did not want to allocate to the armed forces of ukraine, please answer how much money is currently in the road fund, and people we've got intelligent people will be able to calculate that we just did not want to transfer half of this amount to the armed forces of ukraine. the position of the committee on the 81st amendment, please, dmytro oleksandrovych, i specifically now asked the question to the state treasury, what are the cash expenditures for the road fund as of october 1, in order to give you the most accurate answer. insists savrrasov, does not insist. amendment 83: mykysha, insists? please, ms. raksalana, i have a question

please, 820th, gerasimov, ruslan oleksiiovych, look, the amendment concerns the allocation of additional money for the main intelligence agency, and we fully support it, i would also like to remind you once again that if this bill had money exclusively for the security and defense sector, then i think we would have finished this story a long time ago, we would have voted and gone to prepare until the next day, until the next bills, but unfortunately, there is more to it, and i want to remind you once again that one of the key sources is tfo, which will be taken from local budgets, from local communities, and you know, one of the communities that appealed to them not to take away the pdf, it is nizhyn city council, of course, the city of nizhyn, chernihiv region, it will be very interesting to see how zub valeriy oleksiyovych, who was just elected in the city of nizhyn, will vote for this, how will he vote, will he take or not take money from his community, we'll see tomorrow, stay tuned. thank you, and please put the amendment to the vote, amendment 820, authored by arev gerasimovych and

so as not to lose the state, whatever please, next, amendment 925, razumkovkov, thank you, ruslan oleksiiovychruksana andriivna, good afternoon, i would like to ask what the logic was in reducing the funding of the national academy of legal sciences of ukraine, to uah 717 , i understand that it may not be by myself a priority article, and i would be questioned if you would allocate additional funds for this, but what justified the reduction of such sums, by such amount of funding: of such a respectable institution, what is the logic? position on the 925th amendment of the committee, i will say in one, ok, thank you, please 9226 dmetro oleksandrovich, andriivna, i must be bad , you have a bad microphone, i didn't hear an answer why we don't fund, reduce funding, there is also a letter, or it is some kind of political position. andriivna, by the way, it will be interesting for oleksandr bakumov to hear the answer to this question, outgoing letter number 675 dated august 21, 2023, signed by the president of the national academy of legal sciences volodymyr zhuraravel, in which it is said that the

treasuries, people need to be paid extra for their risky work, rexlan andriivna, you tell me, ruslan oleksiiovychat you want to say, he just didn't know about it, thank you, solana andriivna, please, well, first of all , i do, i really liked your wording, where does this money go, while nowhere, all the money in a single treasury account? i will answer you: uah 51.6 million is directed to the state treasury service, uah 185.4 million to the state audit service, both of these programs to their territorial offices. namely, for salaries with increasing coefficients in territorial offices, in front-line regions , you will now ask how many such people are in the audit service who work in front-line regions, i tell you right away, i do not know yet, but i think that more a couple of hours and we'll find out, great, someday this was a film magazine, i want to know everything, let's move on, dear colleagues. 276 amendment 276, 277, 278, 279, 280, we have now told about them, i apologize, we have already answered this , the next one, and the 281st railway, 82 railway with a flap with a cheval, 284 next, d

thank you, ruslan oleksiiovych, i think that ruslan andriivna will be able to answer, please andriivna, no, not quite so, because 272 million is for the ministry of finance, as the chief administrator, the state treasury service receives from an increase in expenditures by 51.6 million hryvnias, this is a salary with accruals and with deductions, i.e. accruals by the state does, the deduction is deducted from the employee's salary, so 45,000 will definitely not be there, i will tell you in my next answer what the approximate amounts are. thank you, please, let's move on, dear colleagues, 239, tymoshenko, yuliya volodymyrivna, please, mykhailo mykhailovych tsimbalyuk, 239, mykhailo tsimbalyuk, homeland, dear colleagues, well today , after listening to the presentation on these draft laws of the ministers, and you know, the position is surprising, rather, the communication style itself. minister of finance with people's deputies. such an instructive tone, one gets the impression that he is speaking not as the minister of finance of the government appointed by the parliament, but as a mat

rukslan andriivna, it is necessary that, 214, 215, 216. 217, 218 dmytro oleksandrovich, please, ruslan oleksiiovychunately, the chairman of the committee did not answer with your permission to answer why we are increasing the financing of the ministry of finance by a quarter, more than a quarter of a billion hryvnias, it seems to me that the ministry of finance should save, they have such and such a task, they always do it, and until we constantly receive... comments from the ministry of finance against it, because it requires additional expenses, and here, well, the ministry of finance has set itself additional expenses, and it won't be too much, well, we tell you that we don't have... money and shells, we tell you that there is no money for mines, not enough to support our armed forces, this is an objective reality, you don't need to tell me that these are grants, and these are loans and the like, let's do it differently then, let's find a mechanism to channel it to the needs of the defense security sector, or business support or recovery, because i 'd also like to remind everyone in this room th

dear ruslan oleksiiovych, the procedure for a full discussion with specifics, which , if i'm not mistaken, are set out in article 157 of the regulations of the verkhovna rada of ukraine. the only a few points, i want to inform you, and as far as i know, you have already received a letter on this topic, that a representative of the main committee can also speak with a separate opinion, according to the full discussion procedure, article 30, and oleksiy goncharenko will do it on our behalf. member of the budget committee. second point, big request, too. to ask 9 minutes of questions to the minister of finance of ukraine, because there are 9 minutes of questions to the representative of the committee, but there are no nine minutes of questions to the minister of finance, and her last, very important, only six minutes for speeches people's deputies, please allow 15 minutes for the speeches of the people's deputies, so i summarize, 15 minutes for the speeches of the people's deputies, add 9 minutes for questions to the minister of finance and inform about the speech with a separate opinion. th

ruslan oleksiiovych, likewise, please, from eight to twelve, give me two minutes, please, two minutesto 12, dear colleagues, colleagues, and please tell us what we are considering in general, today thanks to colleagues from different factions, especially i would like to thank yuzhanna, information appeared that 207 billions in this bill are mortgaged, out of thin air. why am i talking about air? because 207 billion is the amount that we have to take from local authorities in the form of pdp. were you told about this at the servant of the people faction? if i may, i would like to have this confirmed by the chairperson of the committee, whether it is is true, whether it was stated by the minister, deputy minister ulyutin today at the committee. do we adopt the law, changes to the budget code, which are not backed by anything, that is, we again soften our defenders, or what do we do? we do, we will pass the law now, then there will be no changes until 10:037 and there will be no funding , whether tomorrow or today you will blackmail the hall, telling us that we passed 10:038 and after th

insist, 161 mykysha does not insist , 163, insists, i apologize, please, mykysha, thank you, ruslan oleksiiovych, roksalan andriivna, here is the 161st amendment, she says, well, this is a purely technical amendment, we are just introducing an additional paragraph that will help a, construction, new construction, reconstruction, restoration, capital repair of objects, research infrastructure , there taking into account the need to create conditions for access of scientists to advanced research infrastructures in the european union, i do not understand why this is primarily important for the same national research fund and for of other innovation funds, the technical possibility to do appropriate things, why not contribute it, i do not understand, tuna is not a resource, it does not require additional money. it does not require additional resources, it's just that in the text we actually allow it to be done in the future , why it was rejected, it is not clear to me, if possible, please give an explanation, thank you, briefly the position of the committee, please. the amendment is proposed to be r

ruslan oleksiiovych, if we return to the fact that the powers of the people's deputy of ukraine cannotwould also like to ask a question about business trips, ask a question about covering the work of the verkhovna rada, i'm just sure that you as a person consistent, you must take the same position in all issues, not only in the fact that , for example, today we are sitting in the hall with you in 30. people, where are all the others, then please ensure that all other people's deputies are at work places, you are the chairman of the verkhovna rada, this is your authority, i am sure that you will cope with it, you know how to do it, you know how to do it, it is provided for by the laws of ukraine, the constitution of ukraine, because it is simple that we do not transform our work for a farce, so in this regard i completely agree with you, thank you, for fulfilling the duties assigned to me, i invite... to return to my workplace and perform my necessary functional duties. thank you, we can continue, dmytro oleksandrovych, 902, 903, 900. about what, about a business trip? in terms of busin

does not insist , 44th tymoshenko does not insist, 45th razumkov, insist, please, razumkov, ruslan oleksiiovych, give me 45-49, 93, 94, 95 and 3 minutes, one more time, if possible, 45, 49th, 45, 49, 93, 94 and 9, eighth. edits five edits give me three minutes please three minutes, please, thank you, dear colleagues, i do not understand at all what is happening in the room now, because to call it the 24th budget review is profanity, i want people to know about it, i think about the chairman of the committee should confirm this, i think the chairman of the verkhovna rada should also say about it, since yesterday the parliament did not vote on law 1037, the revenues from which are included as revenues and expenditures of the budget for the 24th year, that is, today it is not possible to go into this law at all what law 1037 was about was to take away any resources from the local government not in order to increase the state budget, but in order to usurp power at the central level, to destroy the decentralization reform in this way... by cementing, well, the activities of monobolsho, let's call, i

amendments, and there will be a mokan, yes, please, vasyl ivanovich, please, 188, thank you, ruslan oleksiiovychal to give me two minutes and uh, 188, 190, 194 and 195 to be counted as passed, and then to put 194 and 195 to the vote, please. please ivanovich, come on, colleagues, today we are actually considering a very serious legislative initiative, it is actually a pity that there are several dozen people 's deputies in the hall who are essentially interested in the substantive passage of amendments, because according to this legislation, then this year and next year and it is not known how long ours will live local communities, ours will be financed. military and it really makes a big difference, so thank you to those who show resilience and stay on the job. the amendments are about the fact that we propose to expand the powers of local authorities to provide security and defense forces, because as of today, there are certain restrictions on what they can finance, what not. in our opinion, local authorities interact quite well with those military formations located in their territories, and

for 241, the decision has been made, from the procedure artur volodymyrovych, please, dear ruslan oleksiiovych, we just missed a part, we just went like this, i have a big request, let's go to the table and we will already go through the table, there if not i'm wrong, there is 73 corrections now, but we were just talking about let's go to 73, are you nina petrivna or who will be hancharenko, please, 73. thank you, dear friends, i would like to remind all of us what the state budget of ukraine is. the state budget of ukraine is a tool for fulfilling promises, programs, it is a tool for the development of the state, and it seems to me that now is the time to remember, in fact, with what promises, especially since if it were not for martial law, we would have these days you held parliamentary elections and we would all be summing up by now, and what has been done? well, friends, i have in front of me the program of the servant of the people, with which she went to the elections, i just want to understand where this program is reflected in the state budget, i do not see it, so let's introduce a me

dear ruslan oleksiiovych, please give the floor to kovtonovych. please, koltunovych, oleksandr serhiyovych. thank you, in continuation of the previous question about the subsidiary policy, well, if you take the figure and compare it with uah 40-49.9 billion that you allocate, including for firm acquisition. of liquid domestic fuel and liquefied gas, even if you take this dynamic and 32% , then with an increase in the electricity tariff by 84%, the increase in the amount of allocated subsidies is only plus 32, that is, in 2 of these 60 times, the pace does not correspond, yes there's definitely another specific vega there, but that's one important point , i'd like you to take it into account, and what i 'd also like to address in the context of next year's budget, we all know we're in a... critical situation in demography, we saw the statistics for six months, that the birth rate dropped by 28%, and this is compared to the pre-war, first half of the year, when there were only 38 births per 100 deaths, how will you stimulate the demographic situatio