i strongly support ruth ferguson's application. and i will hope that you will strong low recommend her for seat 9 over mr. pill pelf my written testimony shows, [inaudible] also oppose the appointing mr. pilpel to the [inaudible] for good reason. including and incident in which he had been rifling through [inaudible] after hours. mr. pilpel is not serve on the task force for a total of 12 years. he currently in 7 to 8 year period of not having been appointed to the task force. the board of supervisors before that, have rejected him for 2 other 4 year appointments. so he has not served 12 years, i'm sorry. he has not served for going on 15 years for good 13 is the board of supervisors have consistent low found him to be deceptive for any city policy body or advisory body. he was not appointed to 2 different committees. not appointed the task force and i urge you to reject his application today. and send a recommendation to appoint ruth ferguson. and the gentlemen applying for seat 3. >> thank you. >> speaker time, >> thank you. >> t