the most coherent critics have been leading jewish intellectuals, such as anthony lerman, rylan clarknt, kenneth stern, an american academic, who drafted the original document which has morphed into this thing, because it's —— it represses freedom of speech. why do people adopt it? if you go to a local authority, and go, we've got this thing where it it will get rid of anti—semitism, everybody goes, oh, we hate anti—semitism, the document is presented with no discussion and no debate and everybody puts their hands up. it is a fake and we are being snowed with this thing. what labour has done is to really coherently take on board everything that's good about it, everything. i mean, you can look at it line by line. what they've done where its dubious, where it in dangerous freedom of speech, they have expanded it. they have discussed it. is it anti—semitic to say that israel is a raters state? maybe it is sometimes, but often it is not —— is sometimes, but often it is not —— isa is sometimes, but often it is not —— is a racist state. most jewish organisations and pretty much every stran