leading up to the murder of samuel pattie. one of our competitors was murdered because he taught our compared to it was the victim of an islamist terror attack. well it's been a bit of a tangled web since that beheading of samuel patty, a number of individuals, have been hauled in front of the police. some have been charged, some have been let free others have in fact receive sentences and condemned for their part in the surrounding storm regarding that, including one mother who was sentenced for apparently celebrating his death in a facebook post. and a man from algeria who is condemned for glorifying terrorism. then by referring to samuel patty's death, there's also been this huge fallout. president machen was clear following the death of summer party that france wouldn't roll back from showing controversial images when it comes to talking about freedom of speech that sparked huge protests in some muslim majority countries. people calling for a boycott of french goods and there's been anger in many muslim nations as well at

and that's because they're said to have been the teenagers who pointed out to samuel patti's murderer, who he was there for allowing that beheading to take place. the 4th teenager who has also been indicted is said to have been the daughter of brian chin. now, this is the man who is widely regarded as being behind the media frenzy surrounding that lesson. when samuel patti showed controversial cartoons of the muslim prophet that sparked anger in the local community, she has been indicted for slander. now all of 4 individuals have since been released, but they are being monitored by traditional controls. here in france, let's take a reminder of what happened. leading up to the murder of samuel patty on one of our competitors was murdered because he taught our compared to it was the victim of an islamist terror attack. was a number of individuals have been hauled in front of the police. some have been charged, some have been let free others have in fact receive sentences and condemned for their part in the surrounding storm regarding that, including one mother who was sentenced for appa

leading up to the murder of samuel patti. one of our competitors was murdered because he taught our compassion. it was the victim of an islamist terror attack. a number of individuals have been hauled in front of the police. some have been charged, some have been let free. others have in fact receive sentences and condemned for their part in the surrounding storm regarding that, including one mother who was sentenced for apparently celebrating his death in a facebook post. and a man from algeria who is condemned for glorifying terrorism. again, by referring to samuel patty's death, there's also been this huge fallout. president was clear following the death of senator patty, that france wouldn't roll back from showing controversial images when it comes to talking about freedom of speech that sparked huge protests in some muslim majority, countries needs a mental health treatment. rob was and he is a case and therefore he really needs to have mental checks that have the national that were present. my corn has being infuriated

again by referring to samuel patty's death. there's also been this huge fallout. resident mcewan was clear following the death of senator patty, that france wouldn't roll back from showing controversial images when it comes to talking about freedom of speech that sparked huge protests in some muslim majority, countries. needs a mental health treatment. rob was the cause, he is a case and therefore he really needs to have mental checks. many of them have that are natural, but the damage that the were present back on has being infuriated by some english language media saying that they have twisted his words over the last 2 months or so suggesting that he was attacking islam in some way rather than islam ism, and there's been a huge amount of fake news, too surrounding the new which is to crack down on separatism here in france. but the reality is that many muslims here in france feel that they are being singled out. they are being targeted, not just by this law, but by the for light force happened since summit, patti's murder, and it's likely that this is an issue t

including the beheading of teacher, samuel patty, just days after he showed controversial cartoons of the prophet mohammad to some of his students images from the funeral of some of the t.v. last month. his murder was one of several brutal attacks in france, prompting president vowed to protect the country's values and freedom of expression and crackdown on what he called islamist separatism. that led to anti french protests in many muslim countries and communities. and it reignited a debate in france about reconciling secularism with religious sensitivities while still fighting terrorism. the game of terrorism is to try to present french secularism as an attack on religion and as something that would aim to condemn believers and make them inferior in relation to all french citizens. and also on the way there is already a conflict of loyalties because there's a reluctance to attack what is cultural, religious, the religion of the parents, the problem in france, and even in countries where there is high immigration, is that children are torn between the culture of the host country and

mohammed in class, a survey has found that in the wake of last month's murder of french teacher, samuel patty had displayed images of the founder of islam to students. one norwegian teacher says that there are now very real dangers to those working in the profession. after the murder of sam. well, i decided not to show them at all because i felt it's wonderful. i felt my profession was attacked at the moment and the freedom of speech over expression was attacked, of course. and i wanted to find other ways to express myself and to achieve the same goal with my teaching. because the characters get your drawings are not the goal. they're just a part of criticism against a religion. and there's other texts we can use as well. according to the poll, almost 2 thirds of teachers, fish showing me images, and then france, panties, brutal murders, proving extremely divisive. president mccrone insists the cartoons are about freedom of speech, but muslims are outraged. on the last one of our competitors was murdered because he taught our competitor, it was the victim of an islamist terror attack. the nor

just to me all we had nice we had paris as well but the opposite is true some of the hedging of samuel patty and. in tears saying that more fronts increased its terror level we know but do you think this is not just a french problem this is actually an e.u. wide problem definitely it is that it's a larger problem because. we never saw me the attacks that you preempted it. thanks tool efficient police operation thanks to last. identification of potential terrorists well you cannot react each and every attack but. apparently. to a text simply act on what you have seen in france where i. may compare it now to do to the ongoing massacre that is aren't happening in the end it is it's a different quality we had in transit was the reason there is attacks but as far as we know right now in this again. people act it's rather isolated level my. feeling if i may seem from what is here. winning right now here in indiana it's it seems to be more closely to it seems to be illogical to it's not just one person and maybe his brother and brother in laws are acting here and there it's a bit more and i would m

year old afghan boy was charged over remarks e allegedly made about the killing of school teacher samuel pattie he was beheaded on 18 year old muslim in october after allegedly showing cartoons of the prophet mohammed in a class on free speech the teenager who commented on his death has been released but will remain under supervision he's also been banned from school and from communicating with other students or teachers well there have been an increasing number of inquiries opened into young people as some as some as young as 8 years old many are under suspicion for breaking a minute's silence held in memory of samuel passy and allegedly saying that his death was deserved more than 60 similar investigations have been put to christine of new voters young people aged 12 to 16 used extremely repugnant language is the islamic state group which is very worrying but we asked the question should children be held accountable and punished for what they say. i don't think that the fact that they are minors should blind us to the extent of this trouble there is a huge amount of sympathy for islamic terro

as young as 8 many under suspicion for it for interrupting a minute's silence held in memory of samuel patty and the alleged they say his death was deserved in the wake of the tragedy more than 60 similar investigations have been opened in supporting terror. nouvelles young people aged 12 to 16 used extremely repugnant language is the islamic state group which is very worrying but we discussed with guess the spread of radicalization among young people. i don't think that the fact that they are minors should blind us to the extent of this problem there is a huge amount of sympathy for islamic terrorism among young people not necessarily mine as well though perhaps including by those of muslim extraction if you put them in jail it's not going to help them because they're going to be rabid be going to be radicalized in the in the jails and they gonna get even worse we have huge amounts of immigrants in france and i'm afraid to say that the existence of these immigrant communities is a breeding ground for islamic fundamentalism and fundamentalism is a breeding ground for terrorism which it has n

france not just to me all we had nice we had paris as well but the absolutely gruesome beheading of samuel patty and. in tears saying that more fronts increased its terror level we know but do you think this is not just a french problem this is actually an e.u. wide problem definitely it is that it's a large problem because. we know where some of the attacks that you preempt it. thanks to all efficient police cooperation thanks to last. identification of potential terrorists well you cannot react each and every attack but. case apparently. to detect simply act on what you have seen in france where or when you made compare it now to due to the ongoing massacre that is aren't happening in the end it is it's of a different quality we had in transit what the reason there is attacks but as far as we know all right now from police in this again. people act it's rather isolated level my. feeling it almost seems from what is her. winning right now here in indiana it's it seems to be more closely to it it seems to be a larger group it's not just one person and maybe his brother and brother in law lives e

meanwhile, france is still feeling the shock waves of samuel patti's mada 6 weeks ago on the street. one of our competitors was murdered because he taught our competitor, it was the victim of an islamist terror attack. while the norwegian teacher we spoke to believes the staff. * should be free to decide for themselves how to explain religion to their students. there's the law on that is the law on that one hand and freedom of speech on the other hand. and we can maneuver in between the limits of those. and i don't want to have anyone telling me which texts to choose in my teaching. i think it's really important that teacher, it's all around the world, is allowed to to, to make those choices by themselves. we have the curriculum and we have these limits. and i think for us, it's really, really important too to make choices about these things ourselves. the thing is that the each and curriculum has a very important main topic. that's democracy and citizenship. and we are teaching in with the law. on one hand, the laws against hate speech and the n.r.a. and we have the human rights on

france not just a knee all we had nice we had paris as well as the absolutely gruesome beheading of samuel patty and. do you think that more fronts increased its terror level we know but do you think this is not just a french problem this is actually an e.u. wide problem. with it is that it's a larger broader because. we know was looming attacks that you preempted. tool efficient police. thanks to last really. identification of potential terrorists or you cannot preamp each and every attack but to. index case carry the do. to detect simply have them. go overseas saying also in recent days we're going to show hope help us later about this heightened tension and a lot of hostility from the muslim world towards my new or mock role when he came out and defended sort of the freedom of speech he defended the caricature as a prophet mohammed what i want to ask you is do you think in visit this wider fallout something that potentially we obviously don't know this is speculation but a kind of a wave of terror that could extend beyond france's borders. what you have seen in france where when you may compa

many are under suspicion for interrupting a minute's silence that was held in memory of teacher samuel patty for allegedly saying his death was deserved in the wake of the tragedy over 60 similar investigations have been opened into supporting terror the questioning often involves young people aged 12 to 16 who have used extremely repugnant language inspired by the group which is very worrying ok let's get the views now of sharm lu he's a paris based lawyer and author john walker lindh is joining us again he's a french lecturer in history you both very welcome thanks for your time this evening if i can start with you what are your thoughts on this i mean these children have said some very very shocking things but is it right to put children as young as 8 years old under supervision by prosecutors. for having me are let me let me 1st start by you remind the reminding you of. the french law under french law the facts are that if you make enough apologies are. to do it curious crime is an act it's a crime it's punishable by it but. only law and you can be prosecuted for that if you ever comment