stand with all our strength and determination against all those who try to divide germany tough and schloss night. one year on from the attack the moon still run deep and for many questions remain over whether more could have been done to prevent the events of that terrible night. for more now i'm joined by ide on earth as she is a social democrat member of germany's parliament a buddhist talk and a former government commissioner for migration refugees and integration thanks for being with us this morning there are those in many had hoped that the hunted attack would mark a turning point in germany's approach the far right by islands was a turning point. no i fear was not a permanent turning point we will always feast right wing extremists we will always have extremists in our country which should be a turning point is how we deal with this how a sergeant's deal with this and there are still so many questions even of a year later we still have all these questions that i don't have any answers you know like why wasn't police really able to be reached why couldn't there be help. why was a doo