to the jury's eyes, scott pattison was still very much smitten. she said, no, and i watched scott's reaction, he was devastated. dennis murphy: but as for those petechiae bruises the prosecution thought so critical to its case, for the jury, not so much. the petechiae just didn't do it for me either way. granted, it was there. very hard for us to see. dennis murphy: as the jurors debated, the absence of evidence placing scott in the workout room with his wife kept them locked in a near-even balance. there was no smoking gun, no witness that saw this happen. it depended on us making what we thought was the right decision. dennis murphy: eight hours of deliberations, however, swayed one side to agree with the other. word came down that a verdict had been reached. lisa's sister, christine, held hands with family in the first row, praying. and i just kept envisioning the word guilty in my mind. it's got to be guilty. dennis murphy: guilty as charged. lisa's family couldn't hold back the tears. we just couldn't stop. we were just weeping of relief. denn