mr. sanchez so are you done? >> i'm done thank you. >> thank you mr. sanchez. >> thank you scott sanchez mr. foreman a little bit of braungd the bay shore in the zoning district, llc the previous 2012 permit was submitted in may of 2012 the neighborhood productive was conducted and the appellant filed a discretionary review permit on that application it's my understanding think the dr requester the materials he stated his opposition to the roof-deck and proposed elimination i quote the elimination felt roof-deck is for cold temperatures and because of noise and partying and fire pits that could further block light the planning commission concerned those arguments and took discretionary review they asked for the property line be