that forces him to be a resident and the address he uses is in sonoma, specifical specifically sebastiapool. perhaps we can continue this and take it up in the new year. thanks probably the most fair thing to do. that way mr. elberling can respond to the accusations submitted to us today it. >> councillor breed: thank you. before i call on supervisor peskin, supervisor safai you would like to respond? >> councillor safai: it's valid. the clerk receives that information and is required to review that information to determine if the information provided, the address, was a san francisco address. it's not in the purview of the rules committee to determine that. we take that information on face value as it's submitted to the clerk. so i would ask the clerk maybe to respond to that. >> councillor breed: madam clerk? >> clerk: thank you, madam president to supervisor safai, the application has -- well, it is a san francisco address, as i look upon it on its face. >> councillor safai: thank you. >> councillor breed: supervisor peskin. >> councillor peskin: mr mr. elberling responded to that basele