you know, melania trump, serlina for her office's official response to rudy giuliani's claims that she believes the president's denial about an alleged affair with porn star stormy daniels. the spokesperson for the first lady said i don't believe mrs. trump has ever discussed her thoughts on anything with mr. giuliani. how do you interpret that? >> as a millennial, we call that shade. and i would say that that statement is pretty clear, that melania does not want rudy giuliani to speculate on her behalf and put words into her mouth. and i think that rudy was very interesting this week. he went to israel. he is the president's lawyer on russia and he was talking about all kinds of things. not just melania and what she was thinking and saying to him. but also about north korea and other matters. think that melania certainly is trying to i think communicate the message that she doesn't agree with rudy giuliani on the fact that the president did not have an affair with stormy daniels. otherwise she would have said that explicitly in that statement and she didn't. >> joe, do you think that