power although i want to show my support but decide emerald supports another opportunities clean sf power has the chance actually be a pioneer for the bay area several participants here will be speaking and looking at alameda county and we really, really want to look at what is developed here to follow in the steps 6 making those jobs local and career pathway and helping the community in the disengage areas benefit we have a lot of opportunity in the bay area and on a regional level so once again also support the clean sf power program and look to see how it's amplified on a regional level thank you. >> thank you. >> (calling names) >> hello commissioner president caen and commissioners this action for the opportunity to speak i'm a resident of san francisco and rep 350 bay area compliment advocate nonprofit i courage you to read through the report it is somewhat lengthy but the executive summary is several packages but loonth the version that came out yesterday, i think that some of the problems that ms. hail was speaking about have been addressed i can speak in debt but some of th

probable causes us they receive preferential treatment but to make clear we support the clean power sf program and so i have copies of those amendments here and so i also want to end by thanking the power in my office for his help and puc staff for working with us with that, supervisor kim if no noticeable questions or comments i'll invite barbara hail from the sf puc to come up and speak to us been on behalf of the agency. >> thank you, supervisors barbara hail assistant with the public utilities commission i'm going to e abolishment supervisor wiener the sf puc and the entrepreneurs is the provider of the electric services to the city and county of san francisco and their hunters point shipyard phase one and treasure island we're the little power provider we serve one hundred and 50 megawatts and outside of san francisco so inside of san francisco those customers are for example, our wastewater and city hall this building and ferry this and the police and fire the public utilities outside of san francisco we serve the facilities like much of our water facilities some in milling ray a

what does this fit in, relative to clean power sf? because i think that this is a good step. but, i think that it is only that, and i would be willing to support something like this, provided that it is not something that would be in place of clean power sf. so i am wondering if you could address that where this fits into the community choice , and moving forward. >> sure, i will run through my comments and see if there is a place and i will try to address that. so, we did our rfp, and we had three proposers, they are all here, in this room today, to answer questions specific questions about their programs. and from the outset, the policy direction of the board, was to work with multiple page providers, to offer to raise in the competitive options for consumers. so, as a result, we have selected the three entities who proposed. and because of this september, san diego court of appeals case that supervisor farrell mentioned we have sort of changed gears from having a direct contracting arrangement with the three entities and instead, the resolutions before you today proposed t

when you build a new energy system in the city so the things that drive advocates through clean power sf is getting worse we can't afford another year of delay because things are much worse and no reason for the delay all the questions we've raised as qualifications or uncertainties or whatever will the proposal have been addressed there were never barriers in the first place but now addressed by the last could report so we'll e really he expect the commission as a whole to represent the citizens in our region not the mayor or pg&e they're not the ones that you know the constituency your supported to represent we don't see any reason not to move forward. >> thank you. >> next speaker. >> is jess arching man. >> good afternoon commissioner president caen and commissioners up thank you for the opportunity we're pleased with the annex report and at least to consider what the options are it's great to know we don't have to go with the shelf program we can see this program will create jobs and actually help the long term sf puc financially and we would a lot of loving to have the cac director

haven't laboratory them they seem to be in line what we asked for a the ability of the clean power sf should it come to be to buy power from that so thank you again and we hope the supervisors approve it. >> thank you, sir. >> mr. cleveland. >> good afternoon, supervisors as you know i represent the building inspections and private property owners and developers we understand why you're putting forth this legislation but we have some serious heart burn with the mandate and specifically you know we talked about mature consent we worked with sf puc and the sf puc staff and are shthsd ousted language he said those agreements will be by mature consent so beyond the city bids out it's serviced why not allow pg&e and the puc to bid for the contract, if you will, to supply the power we don't understand why you feel it is necessary for the city to simply mandate you'll take power from the city if we find it to do so we have serious problems with it supervisor and we have problems with the fact if you're going to go into a building that is a one hundred square feet we we have a city tenant tha

should move forward and the implementation of clean point of interest sf means creating a voice for san franciscans as myself and along without residents in this room not only creating the choice but i believe the most important thing climate change is very real and this is the efficient way to cut back our reliance on fossil fuel and climate distributors i strongly urge you to support clean power sf as an environment and san franciscan thank you. >> thank you any other speakers. >> seeing none, next item, please. >> item 8 is annual financial audit report. >> hi good afternoon deputy k f o we bring our final statements for fiscal year 2013-2014 for the 6 year in a row each the 3 enterprises has received an unmodified opinion of the financial statement signifying they're fairly and appropriating present and contain no mixed statements or inadequacy and fiscal year 2013-2014 was also issued earlier in comparison to the earlier years as compared to those tables sf puc was the first of the enterprise department in the city and county to issue it's financial statements and we expect to

earlier item on the internet report it their resolution was a strong statement to start clean power sf for many of the reasons stated earlier but also the ground water issue that is, i think that's something your movdz well with but we need that on or about is crucial and both of those issues have to do with global warming so you one thing open clean power sf that get touched on but not sufficiently noble is clean power sf great to deal with the climate crisis and great for jobs and great for building trades but it also the report made clear that caught after the cac did their report it makes it clear that the san francisco public utilities commission will make direct revenue from clean power sf staff can be added now they've shown us a better way to do it and cam malcolm has been saying for several months that could be done to not only important that for environmental reasons we get this off the ground it is important that the cac who represents the board of supervisors and the mayor's office on those issues but this is direct benefit that the san francisco public utilities commission

made possible of a gift of $600,000 from google and provided to the city of san francisco and with sf city we put up the wifi projects in the 32 different parks and open spaces throughout the city delivered to the city with a gift in kind with a five-year maintenance program and no strings attached and we are lucky to partner with google and sf city and all of the work that they are doing throughout san francisco and this is a great testament to the projects here that will deliver the real results to the residents of our city and that will make a difference to everyone living in our neighborhoods which this is all about. to the person, or to the family, that use our parks that sun bathe on the lawn when it is sunny in san francisco or at our ball fields and it helps them get on the phone and surf the internet or e-mail when they need to more important than that, is the tender loin rec center has free wi-fi to be able to enable the staff to conduct the operation and able to communicate in the department and sign up the children in the leaks on the internet that they did not have access

there are many parallels with sf and ferguson. ferguson fought for weeks to indict the officer who killed mike brown. one thing you can do here locally is demand the release of those names at the very least to show support and show you care about accountability. to deny those names is to increase mistrust in law enforcement. we call on police conscience to call to police. these acts of violence are unacceptable. we are here and i also would like to hear, i have heard there are concerns including the language on the fact that every 24 hours a person is killed. >> thank you. next speaker, please. >> public speaker: good evening, my name is jaron brown and i'm here with -- i want to thank supervisor avalos and many of you who are supporting equality for all resolution. there are times when san francisco is french when we take a radical stand. oh, my god! san francisco took a stand around minimum wage and nuclear arm. this is no the that moment. we have seen thousands and sent people to ferguson, we have seen the st. louis rams. today

passionate folks about the past 3 resolutions one on global technology sport and one for clean power sf and the puc's ground water program the resolutions are here i want to express we want action on those 3 items from the commission we working hard and cared about those issues we want to know that the commission hears us we strengthened our relationship with the commission and cac and staff the cac represents the report to the commission we have commissioner courtney at our meeting and want to see more p of that in january general manager kelly will be giving his update for the cac pr we'll have impactful meeting we've met ten times this year required to meet 9 and our subcommittees are required to meet 4 times each has met 4 to 6 times we've p had a busy year one of the other things on behalf of the entire cac todd has been one of our biggest allies and champions todd will be at our december meeting thank you for everything you've done and wish you well in your new job. >> good. >> yes. vice president. >> thank you for your work i've valued our work cac and want to respond in some way

is doing that so we'll hope when clean power sf comes on line it will be considered for preferential treatment we can't say that in the language we can with a caveat we can do what we want but the individual residents there should be some equality with them thank you. >> mr. brooks. >> good afternoon again supervisors eric brooks san francisco green local grassroots and representing the san francisco clean energy aligns with hanging and 350 sf first of all, to thank the authenticities for this legislation it the crucial that the san francisco rules committee sells this power at recites i respectfully strongly disagree with others who came forward claiming that is a mandate we've heard from the staff this is not a mandate this is just gives the sfpuc the stools to eye it's good judgment to make a deal for logical purposeers when it's good for them and if the sfpuc decides that pg&e is the better service provider so be it this self-mandate anything to get to clean power sf it is we've been working with you all and the city attorney trying to make sure we have the language for the clean

we see that the sf puc can do the purchasing instead of shell. all these issues were brought up by the commission, the sf puc and now they're resolved so we staff to work on the things in the background to clarify but we believe by the i understand of january the sf puc able to bring back kim malcolm and start working on developing a final plan to move this forward and with a lot of behind the meter assets -- >> thank you. any other speakers? >> good afternoon. bruce wolf, haight-ashbury neighborhood council and san francisco clean advocates. yeah, there will be jobs and time to move the program forward. let's not waste anymore time and if you encounter as you anticipate any obstacles or barriers about overcome them positively and rapidly. thank you. >> thank you. next speaker please. >> hello commissioners. jud holtman with 350 bay area, 350 san francisco. so i know we've all been working on this issue for at least a couple of years and we have heard a lot of questions over the last year with the program design with the issue of shell, the issue

all part of this health discussion we have it is b also about programs fred and i worked on and hope sf by giving people who are in the worse probably housing settings probably not taking care of themselves as well as they should and providing them with a basis of hope this is the context in which i wanted to present one of my highest priorities that's making sure that people have access to health to health insurance and quality health care but also to the very basic commitment to themselves and their families they should take care of themselves at the eater eater stages for me as a lifetime member of kaiser health, i love the fact that everybody knows about the theme of writing i've had to teach myself how to thrive because in my youth youths that was all about i ant sick and many i am carvings will take care of me nowadays it's about before you every walk in its what wear trying to teach our workforce i was r have a 29 thousand workforce are they all in shape no way we're trying to thrive even better so this announcement today is significant for those reasons it is about our most chal

have broad community support by organizations including 70 michelle obama ma the buena vista arts and sf beautiful and the cb d from integral market and yerba buena this is an exciting project that is the first of its kind in the world visualize the light rail vehicles thin light strange longer than market street if the embarcadero to van ness sending delicately delicate lights matching the 200 underground trains people will monitor the trains by the above ground lights colleagues this is the transportation spine of san francisco and one of the most important streets it is deserving of improved treatment compared to what it is today that's why we're moving forward with the better street market plan as the supply moves forward the light rail will build awareness for the 0 future improvements on market street 24 installation was conceived and advanced by the arts that is the same organization be responsible for the beautiful light bay lights on the bay bridge which the m t c approved or answered into an mou to make that installation on the bay bridge permanent this project will be opportun

then the fight was broken up by sf pd.rtly after another fight occurred in the parking lot just down columbus from the venue and then i heard some gunshots. the following night saturday atmosphere was a multiagency presence. i don't have a whole lot of details about what happened that night but the agencies that were there did force the closure of the club for the evening. i'm sure if those two things were related or not. questions >> i have a question. under atmosphere conditions isn't it true that they are not supposed to eject fighting parties at the same time? >> i don't know if that's a condition on the permit. i think that's a best practice. to clarify i'm unsure if they were ejected or they just kind of came out together. >>.you okay. tank you. >> just to clarify quickly your boat incidents happening at the same time and date [inaudible] or is that something else? when was the closure? >> well it's not really -- [inaudible] the closure i believe the multiagency group arrived at approximately 10 pm >> saturday night

. >> just this one might be to this gentleman we follow new york and other cities he lead walk sf kickoff finding saying 3 people are hit in san francisco a day but what does the data show how did he do at the end of this year and is a lot of our efforts working from that short amount of time we've been it from 2013-2014 and i thank people for kifk this mta as come aboard it is a contingent driven process. >> we don't have official statistics up to date mayor ed lee is not here yesterday we were at 17 district fatalities and this year that put us to have a safer 2013 than 2018 but last year, we had a spike at the end of the year and hopefully, we'll have fire fatalities than last year. >> as soon as we received the day there's on challenges with the data receiving and we met with the state department and their awe cul-de-sack aware of the challenges and the stating program is the california highway patrol can take up to 18 months to get the data a so in 2007 and 8 and 9 they had to cut back the staff and now there's a continued effort to restaff up the data collection team so we don't hav