. >> commissioner shaddix. >> here. >> williams >> here >> we have our lands acknowledgment. [ramaytush ohlone acknowledgment] >> thank you. next any members of public that may be upon libbing in public comment call in number is 415-655-0001. the is 26642564571. the web expassword is 1016. and please press if you want to raise your hand on an item press star 3 when prompted by the moderator. and public comment will be taken in person first and we will take online comment. >> then also, for today's proceedings, the there will be presentations by the department. the department and the appellate have 7 minutes to present their case. there is public comment for 3 minutes each and there will be reabout theal time for 3 minutes. >> next we have item b approval of minutes. >> discussion and action to adopt the minutes held on september 18, 2024. is there a motion to approve the minutes? >> motion to approve. >> second. >> so there is a motion and a second, is there public comment on the minutes. >> all commissioner in favor. >> aye. >> opposed? >> thank you. the minutes are approved