my skype from singapore is shannon shaw, senior india economist at capital economics. welcome to counting, the cost. prime minister moody, last year was quick to call for a lockdown less so the 2nd time around. and yet much of the heavy lifting of getting on top of this crisis has been left to state governments. what do you think of his leadership? well, i think the, i think the economic toll from last year it suddenly played a role in terms of, in terms of how the government approached the surgeon far as cases this year there were, i think another key difference was, is a little bit more knowledge about the virus, so it was probably felt that state governments could react to borrow situation with more localized lot downs and that would require more sort of leadership from the, from the state level rather than from the relevant from the central government. so i think all of that has probably meant 2 things. one is that restrictions how much more localized and targeted the downside, a guess you could argue is that they took longer to be impose than may have been ideal,