>> governor shapiro: it will not be me. >> governor shapiro: she will win. >> jon: either tired of the of your lovely state of pennsylvania? >> governor shapiro: yes and no. it is close. for those of you out here worrying about this, the last two presidential races in pennsylvania came down to a less than a point. so of course, the polls are going to be close. now our folks tired of maybe some of the commercials and things on tv? yeah, but i think folks also understand that they have an extraordinary power here. and with that power comes a real responsibility. i think may be -- >> jon: dude, you can't just add here" "spider-man." you can't just -- with power comes responsibility? >> governor shapiro: i want to take a leap here from "spider-man to ben franklin. follow me on this. follow me on this! ben franklin, famously, one of the signatories to the constitution, signed the constitution, walks out of independence hall, is greeted by a woman on those cobblestone streets of philadelphia. she looks him in the eye and says, "mr. franklin, what do we have here? a monarchy or a republican?"

>> governor shapiro: i can't speak to other states. >> jon: i'm surprised by that. >> governor shapiro: we set these artificial barriers to entry, where folks are not given a shot. i think people should have the freedom to chart their own course and the opportunity to succeed. when you say to someone, hey, we don't value your military service, we don't value your service and the union just because you didn't go to college, that says to a whole swath of the public, we are not into you. we are not there for you matthew. kamala harris, she is showing up in those communities that i spent a lot of time and come and she announced that the federal government would be doing away with a college degree requirement, opening up the doors of opportunity. >> jon: as it should be. i did not know that was a requirement. >> governor shapiro: i think i think democrats should never write off these rural communities. we have to show up, speak to people, make sure that we can deliver for them. >> jon: i'm surprised sometimes because i do hear that a lot, about, oh, people don't talk to those communities, b

shapiro, thank you for sharing your thoughts tonight. america, our country fought a protracted global war on terror for two decades. as you mentioned today, we have ethical problems of war, political problems, opposition, support for it. but one day seems to lay sacred in our country, the day of remembrance on 9/11. whether you are for or against the war, that is a day where we remember thousands of civilians, firefighters, and police lost their lives. given that today is october 7, what do you think the ethical consequences are of politicizing today is a day of antiwar protests, and now to be a remembrance for people who lost their lives? >> frankie, i think we celebrate 9/11 wrong. the idea 9/11 ought to be a sad day in which we were member some people hide in a tower, as a congresswoman from minnesota might say. i think that is a grave error. it should be a reminder of the enemies u.s. faced on 9/11 and continue to face today. we have forgotten those lessons which is why we are doomed to repeat similar instances. i don't believe act o

governor shapiro, welcome to "meet the press." >> good morning.is so great to have you. let's start off our latest nbc news poll shows more voters are concerned that vice president harris will continue joe biden's approach than donald trump will continue his approach from his first term. my colleague peter alexander asked the vice president if she would have done anything differently than president biden. take a look at that exchange. >> going forward there is no question that i bring my own experiences and my own life experiences. >> is there a policy that stands out to you in particular, either -- >> sure. my approach to what we need to do around medicare covering home health care borne out of my experience of taking care of my mother. my priority on housing. one, because i know what it means. affordable housing and the ability to buy a home. >> governor, given how unpopular polls show president biden is, has vice president harris done enough to distance herself from president biden? >> you know, kristen, i think what is clear, this is a race no

we will talk with governor josh shapiro.e take you to where owls and politicians meet. >> we are at the center in north philly, this is the home to the temple owl's basketball team. it's also the home to many major events this political season. back in august, after she was named the democratic nominee, vice president kamala harris chose this site to announce her running mate. minnesota governor tim walz. on monday, former president barack obama campaigned here for harris alongside bruce springsteen. >> hello, philadelphia. >> bret: former president donald trump also held an event here this election cycle. >> hello, pennsylvania. it's good to be with you. next week the campaign events all come to a close and that's the start of the temple owl's basketball season. they will be back here at the leah chorus center for a full season. we have got the political arena covered. "special report" will continue after this. ♪ the biggest companies deliver an exceptional customer experience. what makes it possible? 5g solutions from t-mo

they want to deplatform benny johnson and ben shapiro.r, youtube is owned guy google, the number one donor to democratic party out of silicon valley. the argument would be shapiro or johnson, they are spreading misinformation saying covid may have come from a lab or hunterbiden's lapto contains russian disinformation. >> john: they said ben johns on said there is election interference, a lot of people believe that. all democrats cheated by nominating vice president harris, his opinion is they cheated. they sushgum vented the primary process by elevating her to the position. those are probably opinions held by a lot of people. >> joe: that is the whole point, it is opinion. kamala harris did not get one vote before she was handed the nomination, can you call that rigged? some people say you can. we can't have opinions like that when half the country does have an opinion like that? me media matters is a tax-free organization. they use funds to pressure major companies to pull advertising from outlets they target. here is "new york times" pr

shapiro is one of the party's national stars. thanks for being here. >> great to be with you ari. >> great to have you. we will get in to domestic policy and politics, all of that. first i would get your thoughts on the volatile situation in the middle east, the iranian attack on israel and how it will play in to the debate tonight. we heard a little from the vice president. what do you expect? >> this is obviously an unprecedented attack on isel, and presumably based on the comments made it will be met with a swift response. don't forget iran is the largest exporter of terrorism around the world includings it proxy, hezbollah, who has been attacking israel from the north for the better part of the last year. this is a serious and a dangerous and a volatile situation. we need to make sure that iran pays a price for their unprecedented attack. turning to the domestic policies in the debate. we looked how jd vance sounded in his past debate. abortion was a big issue then. let's take a look how he sounded in that debate. >> i recogn

governor shapiro, are you surprised the presidential race? the polls are so close in pennsylvania, vice president harris is underperforming. it seems right now the state's democratic us senate nominee, incumbent bob casey the look anderson, every race in pennsylvania as close the last two presidential racers were settled by a point or less. so when you show a poll that shows it as a one-point rates are an even race. we've come to expect that but listen we got two minutes left in the game and we got a better team on the floor. certainly a better floor captain and i'd rather be us than them. we got to close strong kamala harris is doing that. she's spending a ton of time in pennsylvania and i think that's working to her benefit. >> there is clearly a double-standard. the former president rarely give us specifics on anything. he repeats himself over and over, repeating things that he has said before without the suffix, there's a criticism of vice president harris that she has not given enough specifics do you and there's certainly some issues th

to lower housing costs, kamala will cut red tape and work with governors like josh shapiro, as well as the private sector, to build three million new homes. and she will give first-time homebuyers up to $25,000 to help with a down payment. plans, concrete plans. and for a lot of folks, that could be the difference between watching their dreams pass them by, and finally owning a place of their own. to lower health care costs, kamala already worked with joe biden to take on the drug companies and bring down the cost of insulin, and hearing aids, and more than 50 prescription drugs. and as president, she will never stop working to limit out of pocket costs and protect your care. that is who kamala is. she's got a track record of doing it. and here's a big one. instead of giving more tax breaks to billionaires and raising prices on working families, kamala will give a tax cut to 100 million middle class and working people here in america. so, if you are a new parent, you can qualify for a $6,000 tax credit during the first year of your child's life. because, i don't have to tell a lot of y

borja: muchas gracias, chao, doctor shapiro.a ahÍ lo ven, tiene problemas para quitÁrsela, y ojo, no es la Única, alertan sobre el peligro de usar estos productos que son tÓxicos y difÍcil de eliminar. que nadie practiquÉ esto en casa. cambiamos el tema, hoy con mucho orgullo te decimos que nuestro idioma espaÑol es universal, el instituto cervantes dice que esta lengua ha superado los 600 millones de hablantes en todo mÁs la mÚsica y el a llegar a cada, un informe salado en la universidad de alcalÁ espaÑa, asegura que mÉxico es el paÍs nÚmero 1 con mÁs de 102 millones de hispanohablantes. en el nÚmero 2, estados unidos, de 50 y 7 millones de personas, y muy cerca con 52 colombia, comprende 8 millones espaÑa, y con 47 millones argentina. bien por el espaÑol. los dodgers de los Ángeles le pasan por encima a nueva york. ponen en su vitrina su octavo tÍtulo de la serie mundial de bÉisbol. tenemos reacciones, y te decimos cuÁndo pueden celebrar con sus fanÁticos. en california, te diremos cÓmo un policÍa tu gerente de envíos se fue

to lower housing costs, kamala will cut red tape and work with governors like josh shapiro, as well ashe private sector, to build three million new homes.

is going to have a control over his ground game, and there was an interview that he did with ben shapirohapiro asked donald trump, you know, i've heard positive and negative things about your ground game. can you go into it? donald trump didn't even understand the question. he didn't give them any type of answer at all, and that really is the substance around my elon musk is so involved. if i am elon and my candidate doesn't know what they are doing when it comes to running a campaign, doesn't know what ground game even is and how it works, then i might take that on, and i think that's of elon has done, both financially and operationally. >> what is your sort of theory of the case for the best way to combat sort of the algorithm energy -- some of it is pro trump. a lot of it is anti-harris. what is your best idea, your best thinking, your theory of the case for the strongest way to close and win in 19 days? >> so you have to go where you put donald trump in a catch-22 position. let's talk about deportation. both the vice president and donald trump agree that criminals that are legally sh

hablamos de esto, el doctor ilan shapiro, director mÉdico de altamed, como siempre es un gusto tenerteÍses mÁs observaba que al momento que vacunamos a los familiares y a los niÑos, la tosferina lo que hace que los pulmones y las cÉlulas simplemente no funcionen bien, se puede acumular mucho moco y prÁcticamente empiecen a toser tanto habla de que la gente, . carolina: a quÉ se debe el aumento y segÚn el cdc, dicen que los menores hispanos son mÁs propensos. >> la realidad es que al momento tenemos la familia que no estÁ llegando muchas veces se nos olvida vacunar al abuelo, abuela, la tÍa que nos viene ayudando con muchas veces ellos son lo que estÁn pasando prÁcticamente la bacteria los niÑos aquellos, por eso cuenta simple vacuna que se la puede poner, pueda ser una gran diferencia todos estos cuidadores, porque creamos una barrera entre nosotros y estas bacterias, por otro lado tenemos que recordar que prÁcticamente de 2020 a 2022 estamos realmente muy protegidos, estamos muy cuidadosos, si nos tenÍamos mal, y ahorita estamos viendo justamente estos niveles que estamos viendo antes

head of the washington office of the european council on international relations relations jeremy shapirong short of full nato membership will be able to stop the kremlin's military aggression. its allies in germany on october 12. an official familiar with the progress of zelensky's talks in washington said there are preliminary signs that biden may agree to advance ukraine's nato membership bid before he steps down. and the artillery preparation for that meeting on october 12, when biden will meet with... starmer and macron, has already begun. ukraine must be accepted into nato, accepted into nato within the borders that the kiev regime controls, that is, precisely this notorious west german model. and let's listen to what the new secretary general, the former prime minister of the netherlands, said today. the minister of foreign affairs of the russian federation is that the state that we now have under the name of ukraine, it must fundamentally change its approaches, its approaches to denazification, demilitarization, this must happen in order for the cleansing to occur, we must deal wi

josh shapiro pennsylvania and wisconsin's tony evers. earlier harris spoke with reporters and was asked a former president trump is so unfit for office as she says wise as ray so close. >> it's an election for president of united states. it's also see a cakewalk for anyone. there's very important issues at play and i'm clear and i think the people you hear in the background are clear that donald trump is unfit for the office spee nenshi give a similar answer to bret baier couple of nights ago. harris sistering to convince moderate suburban voters to support her and shore up, will head back to pick out someone else talk in the state. back to. >> let's go back to romulus michigan. thank you. here's a former president talking to the media. watches. >>> nevada we are doing very well so i guess you see that. that's why you're here and will have a little fun today. reading a speech at the end and it's been very good. >> he was not a good. that's my reaction. >> [inaudible question by the media] what event of a cancelled? i haven't cancelled. s

you have governor shapiro suggesting that law enforcement should actually take a look into it. this is all about? is it even legal do you think? >> it is a real question whether it is legal or not. we do have generous campaign- finance rules, and to the extent to which this is unreported money he is giving out of his own pocket. not through any kind of pacs. not there any kind of organization. certainly not reported through the campaign. it raises real question. also the question of whether he is bribing voters to support his candidate. i will say something very briefly about those ads. that and invoking doug's religion is anti-semitism plain and simple. not because he is pro israel. many non-jewish people are pro- israel, but in order to plant an anti-semitic seed. that is reprehensible. >> it is and i'm glad you brought that up. you have covered republicans engaging in anti-semitic tropes for years falsely claiming jewish billionaires are trying to buy our election. here you have elon musk doing this disgusting ad implying that somehow doug emhoff because he is jewish will be

this is shapiro, pennsylvania, leaders who know how to get stuff done. help but think, you know, the hurricane helped trump. he went there. didn't cause a commotion. he is raising money for the people in north carolina. he is going to carry north carolina. >> jesse: you know how much i love anecdotal evidence, dana. you don't even need to look at the polls, tells you something. >> dana: you mean the ads? i don't think that's anecdotal. that's obvious. that's just a fact. they have a problem and they are trying to fix it. the real problem that they have, trump is either an unstable threat to democracy or he is somebody that the independents can work with. it can't be both. so you can't have a closing argument that confuses people, to the extent that there are undecideds left, going to make up their minds going in, that doesn't give them something to work with, plus they say they don't really know him enough. then you have some democrats now who are saying they have buyer's remorse and kamala harris because you had a week in scranton joe, but dangerous cal

but that said, i think there's the josh shapiro factor here.eally important state for her. everyday he knows that. essentially if you're sitting in pennsylvania and josh shapiro is popular there, which he is, you have to say to yourself, we lost out to michigan because she is concerned about the muslim noted michigan and that's why she didn't go with josh shapiro. that's my assessment. as a result, somebody who likely could've delivered pennsylvania for her was taken off the table. in the meantime, she then continues to go on this campaign that is completely insubstantial. if you are a comparatively low information voter, somebody doesn't pay deep attention to the news, your impression of her -- i'm sorry -- is just 70 that talks about constellations and things that might've been, and then laughs uncontrollably whenever she doesn't have an answer. again, i don't think americans can envision her as a person with her finger on the button. >> kayleigh: another reason he wasn't chosen, if you believe reporting, is he was asking too many questions a

shapiro says that at that time, trump i went over 43 in his court cases in pennsylvania.rian todd reporting. brian, thanks very much. and to our viewers thanks for watching erin burnett outfront starts right now dueling rallies in nevada as harris season it's onru

we understand this election will likely come down to tens of thousands of votes. >> governor shapiro is raising concerns with the new effort by trump supported billionaire businessman e long must to give away a million dollars away to people who support a potent trout pro trump pack up intimacy of trump talks about that when he takes his stage here. i got to mention a huge crowd here in lancaster. an indication there's a lot of exciting for trump and then battleground state it's the photo op for mcdonald's earlier today you will see everywhere in the next 24 hours. >> yes you will. by the will take my fries without politics please, just the salt. that's all i need just saying though, it was fun though. >> everyone is going to have an opinion. you're right about that absolutely. arthel: it is what it is been a big crowd behind you by that is good there in lancaster, pennsylvania. and by the way former president speaking to reporters right now at the pennsylvania town hall. let's listen in. books look forward to the result they also look for it, i've got 52 days in a row without a day

another network that says i wonder how kamala harris feels now maybe she should have picked josh shapiro for this very moment. i want to ask about the other major news out of the middle east. iran largest ever attack firing 200 missiles on civilians in an iron dome that intercepted many of them. this was the largest attack iran has ever launched on his releasable gimmick soil. this was the first and weather would support israel a strike on iranian soil. tim walz just completely deflected and called donald trump a bad guy someone who can be a leader in this moment. here is how j.d. vance responded to the moment. watch this. >> you yourself said iran is as close to a nuclear weapon today as ever been. governor weld to blame donald trump who has been the vice president for three years is your running mate, not mine. >> this was a pain constantly came back where j.d. vance says don't look at us, your running mate has been in power for the last three and a half years. what you think about that and also your quick thoughts on the developments of yesterday as well questioning. >> first off the

he wants you to register. >> right. >> governor shapiro came out and said wait a second.h it. i'm not too sure that doesn't need to be investigated. is there a problem with this? >> no, i don't think there is. this is not cash for votes, which is illegal. it's called bribery. now, some are accusing musk of incentivizing people to register to vote and that's sort of walks a fine line. although in his defense. >> the benefits likely go to people who have already registered to vote. i don't think it's illegal. is it much different, brian, than kamala harris last week offering black men millions in forgivable loans which are gifts, that's racially discriminatory, of course. and likely unconstitutional. but, more than that, it's just blatant pandering for votes. dangling promises of cash that you will never be able to deliver on. so, you know, this is politics, and there's, unfortunately, a long tradition of sort of dancing along the fine line. >> brian: gregg, if you look at some of the quotes, democrats can't figure out how they lost elon musk and freaking out by his power.

, were ben shapiro said, i've heard different things about your ground game. can you speak to it? donald trump avoided the question completely, or maybe he didn't understand it from mark. >> i appreciate your time. thank you. >> always, erin, thanks for having me on all right. >> and as we were just finishing their kamala harris did get off her plan in green bay, as i said, we're going to be taking those remarks live momentarily. there she is getting off her air force two and it's gonna harry enten now he joins me now from the magic wall and obviously she's now in wisconsin is just going to speak and she'll be in michigan tomorrow, harry. so is trump. but let's just take a step back here from, as you see it, can she get to to 270 without those states? it'll be very tough, erin. >> so let's sort of look, we're going to look at the road to 270 electoral votes will give donald trump the state of georgia georgia, where he's leading the polls, will give him north carolina where he has perhaps a slight advantage in the polls. and will give him the state of arizona w

alex, this race is razor close and josh shapiro knows that. campaigning across the state vigorously for the vice president in recent weeks. look, he thinks it will absolutely come down to the wire. we will see which way the keystone state will swing. >> what about elon musk? he has been there a lot. what about him and his investment in the state? ♪ >> reporter: interestingly, yesterday josh shapiro did not want to make much comment about what elon musk is doing in the state politically. now elon musk did make a call to the governor a couple weeks ago when he was at the steelers game in pittsburgh. he talked to the governor about making economic investments in the state, completely not tied to the presidential campaign at all. i asked the governor, you know, do you think that elon is serious about making those economic investments here? he thinks he is. alex, he said that was irrespective of politics. they disagree greatly, obviously, on the candidates they are supporting this fall. >> okay, allan smith, thank you so much for joining us. >>> in

joining us now, the pennsylvania governor, josh shapiro. governor, thanks so much for joining us. what do you think your friend, your colleague, governor walz, needs to accomplish on the debate stage stage tonight, what does a successful night look like? >> look, i think tim just seems to be himself just to go out there and talk about his love for this country. talk about his record of accomplishment and most importantly, talk about kamala harris's vision for this nation. i trust he'll do a great job and on the other side, i mean, you've got j.d vance, a guy who frankly wolf isn't being honest with himself every day. and so it's real hard to be honest with the american people real hard to be authentic and genuine when you're struggling internally as j.d. vance clearly is so i expect tim walz to do quite well tonight and he's going to be an outstanding vice president. >> people who have spoken to governor walz have told cnn he's nervous about facing senator vance. how high is the pressure? and governor walz to perform well tonight? >> look, i think all these moments are high pressu

governor shapiro, thank you. as always thank you. >> kaitlan more analysis from harris's speech in the nation's capital here tonight, how she took directly trump on on january 6, but also from that same spot as the stop the steal rally will bring you more comments from that plus, did i steve bannon is out of prison. >> he is now back on his microphone spreading new election conspiracies one week before election day. more ahead unpredictable country is on the edge of their seats unprecedented. >> this race could not be any closer an election like no other. and it all comes down to this. >> we could now i'm making major projection of election night in america from the first votes to the critical counts. >> a lot of us thought that it would come down to this. >> the way only cnn can bring you to you special coverage begins tuesday, november 5. it four on cnn, and streaming on max a widely filter. >> it's well-designed, efficient i appreciate that lee filters technology keeps debris out of your gutters for good they

shapiro says that at that time, trump i went over 43 in his court cases in pennsylvania. wolf, brian todd reporting. brian, thanks very much. and to our viewers thanks for watching erin burnett outfront starts right now dueling rallies in nevada as harris season it's on trump's latest promised to women and former president obama slamming donald trump as he makes the case for voters of color to support the vp plus a new report revealing trump has really 2 billion in debt, a number that has ballooned since he left the white house and his growing by millions every month. let's go outfront >> i'm erica hill in for erin burnett outfront tonight, breaking news. both candidates holding rallies, right now in the key battleground, state of nevada, kamala harris about to take the stage in reno. trump is in henderson right now. this election, of course, is, as you know, a dead heat and new cnn polling tonight from georgia shows that is the case there. as you can see, no clear leader, 47 to 48%, those numbers actually reversed in new cnn polling from north carolina and both these sta

governor shapiro, thank you. as always >> kaitlan more analysis from harris's speech in the nation's capital here tonight, how she took directly trump on on january 6, but also from that same spot as the stop the steal rally will bring you more comments from that. >> plus, did i, steve bannon is out of prison. he is now back on his microphone phone spreading new election conspiracies one week before election day more ahead wracking the whole country is on the edge of their seats on precedent, this race could not be any closer an election like no other. and it all comes down to we can now make a major projection of election night in america from the first votes to the critical counts. >> a lot of us thought that have come down to this the way only cnn you can bring it to you election night in america, special coverage begins tuesday, november 5 at four on cnn and streaming on max when you see what it's really like, when our skin touches wall, you see why we need downey free and gentle with no perfumes are dyes. it

ilia shapiro joins us with a preview of the cases to watch next.: the supreme court is set to return to the bench for what is shaping up to be another consequential term. on the docket a host of high-profile cases including regulation of ghost guns and transgender care for minors, all this as the left continues its political assault on the court's conservative justices with democrats getting behind a plan that could have major implications for judicial independence. let's bring in ilia shapiro, director of constitutional studies at the manhattan institute. welcome. so last couple years have been really consequential, historic for the supreme court. is this year going to measure up or will we have a little more time? >> so far we don't see the blockbuster cases we've been used to. affirmative-action, guns, in the case you just referenced, same-sex marriage. all these hot button issues. nothing on the docket so far. the highest profile case is tennessee's ban on gender care for minors. that's a big case whether that violates equal protection under th

on the stuff and huge companies with those checks in their state police whose opinions, opinions, shapiro. the 2nd you know, it is that the boy lived in years with no way most eating. curtis the late. hi everybody. so i am good and lead to again to us and that's come you it in . so it's a large light bulbs with the supplies scully was found. this goes off of them big so in the mid to indeed century, in a small above and english don't do of can yonah is discovered and always got it. as it turned out, it belong to one of the see boys wedge of band against the british and the 19th century. the even managed to find out his fate. the boy's name was automate, and he was executed after this oppression of the rebellion. and his head was brought back to britain by british officer. this was a common practice among the english at the time towards indians who opened the of what was understood the all right guys, i think we might have found.

to lower housing costs, kamala will cut red tape and work with governors like josh shapiro, as well ashe private sector, to build three million new homes. and she will give first-time homebuyers up to $25,000 to help with a down payment. plans, concrete plans. and for a lot of folks, that could be the difference between watching their dreams pass them by, and finally owning a place of their own. to lower health care costs, kamala already worked with joe biden to take on the drug companies and bring down the cost of insulin, and hearing aids, and more than 50 prescription drugs. and as president, she will never stop working to limit out of pocket costs and protect your care. that is who kamala is. she's got a track record of doing it. and here's a big one. instead of giving more tax breaks to billionaires and raising prices on working families, kamala will give a tax cut to 100 million middle class and working people here in america. so, if you are a new parent, you can qualify for a $6,000 tax credit during the first year of your child's life. because, i don't have to tell a lot of you

shapiro said the call was about musk investing in the state and growing jobs there.able, musk started the conversation with the governor which is perhaps the most important swing state in this election. also gave an interview with tucker carlson on x and has been offering $47 payments to people registering to vote and getting involved in the rescue efforts from hurricane helene and politicizing that. ahead of the robotaxi event, something musk and the public need to believe in to justify the massive valuation. earlier this year, the wall street journal had an interesting story about this. musk's political behavior created a negative sentiment around him at the time tesla has been struggling to grow vehicle deliveries. an nbc poll last month saying 6% of democrats have a favorable view of musk. 79% had negative feelings. as you imagine, it is the opposite with republicans. 62% have positive feelings about musk, but really the pressure is on here despite the political activity for musk to show off a really impressive event tonight. >> obviously, a lot weighing on this

i was in michigan with alissa slotkin on saturday and in philadelphia with bob casey and josh shapiro on sunday. everyone in those states knows this is as close if not closer than 2020. we have a lot of work to do. and you're right, there are some of these people not consuming even "call her daddy" or howard stern. it's in that clip. one singular 60-second clip from these interviews gets pumped into the tiktok or instagram or youtube algorithm and gets shown to voters who are not looking for it. no candidates have had to work harder than these candidates are to break through in this race. you nay not get a "call her daddy" listener every person with that interview, but those clips are going viral and people are seeing them. that's why tim miller is like be everywhere all at once, do our podcast, do tim's podcast, do "60 minutes," do it all. >> can i ask a follow-up on that, dan? trump isn't do it all. there was some follow up, but in terms of the blanket strategy that's not what trump is pursuing. i wonder if you have a thought what might be behind that. >> well, there are two reasons

shapiro, thank you for sharing your thoughts tonight.rica, our country fought a protracted global war on terror for two decades. as you mentioned today, we have ethical problems of war, political problems, opposition, support for it. but one day seems to lay sacred in our country, the day of remembrance on 9/11. whether you are for or against the war, that is a day where we remember thousands of civilians, firefighters, and police lost their lives. given that today is october 7, what do you think the ethical consequences are of politicizing today is a day of antiwar protests, and now to be a remembrance for people who lost their lives? >> frankie, i think we celebrate 9/11 wrong. the idea 9/11 ought to be a sad day in which we were member some people hide in a tower, as a congresswoman from minnesota might say. i think that is a grave error. it should be a reminder of the enemies u.s. faced on 9/11 and continue to face today. we have forgotten those lessons which is why we are doomed to repeat similar instances. i don't believe act of te

the governor of pennsylvania josh shapiro was asked how here's presidency will be different than thency. >> the governor was asked by kristen welker several times in the interview and he did not have a convincing answer about how harris is different from biden and he kept saying she's much different than donald trump, watcher. >> how would her administration look different? >> or been really encouraged by the amount of energy kamala harris, vice president harris has put into focusing on how she will cut taxes for small businesses. >> can you name one policy difference? >> listen, again, the contrast i am focused on is between her and donald trump and on that, it is clearly different. >> the point is people don't want a second biden presidency when it comes to the economy, josh shapiro is a popular democrat and he could not convince voters that harris would not be biden 2.0. stuart: trump is getting through to all kinds of voters first at mcdonald's, then the steelers jets football game in a barbershop in the bronx simply put on the basis of this performance trump is a better campaign

shapiro, thank you for sharing your thoughts tonight.ought a protracted global war on terror for two decades. as you mentioned today, we have ethical problems of war, political problems, opposition, support for it. but one day seems to lay sacred in our country, the day of remembrance on 9/11. whether you are for or against the war, that is a day where we remember thousands of civilians, firefighters, and police lost their lives. given that today is october 7, what do you think the ethical consequences are of politicizing today is a day of antiwar protests, and now to be a remembrance for people who lost their lives? >> frankie, i think we celebrate 9/11 wrong. the idea 9/11 ought to be a sad day in which we were member some people hide in a tower, as a congresswoman from minnesota might say. i think that is a grave error. it should be a reminder of the enemies u.s. faced on 9/11 and continue to face today. we have forgotten those lessons which is why we are doomed to repeat similar instances. i don't believe act of terror are equivalent

specifically governor shapiro, his team is putting together the top fight i myself have also previouslye security of the voter registration data system and making sure the system was more secure. i also investigated county machines all over the state to make sure they were more secure. i believe pennsylvania is ready to have the most secure election in our state's history but we know no matter what happens the lawsuits are coming, particularly if president trump is defeated in pennsylvania. he defines being a sore loser. he will file the lawsuits and only cares about himself. the shapiro administration and certainly myself, if and when i am elected to attorney general will defend every measure voters cast a vote legally making sure they get counted. >> pennsylvania state representative eugene depasquale, thank you for being with us. show coming up tonight, msnbc delmas present my generation, the new four part series from nbc news studio. it takes an in-depth look at the four distinct generations and how members of each have been shaped by the cultural and political events of their time.

she loses pennsylvania, among the many things that will be discussed is, should she have pick josh shapiro would have, could have, should have for every campaign after this will be quite something. i think this is essentially a race about, if you are the harris campaign, it was less about who was your vice president and more about, and continues to be more about, can we make this race a referendum on donald trump? not on jd vance, but make this all about donald trump. walz does that in his own rallies and events. it has to be the campaign itself making trump the center. david: when the vice president picked as her candidate the governor of minnesota, she chose not to pick the governor of pennsylvania. do you think that made a big difference in terms of how the election will go? amy: no. if she loses pennsylvania by half a point, people will say of course she did, she could have had josh shapiro. he does have the ability to outperform the national ticket. he did in 2016 when he was running statewide. he did in 20 20 when he was running statewide. he does have an appeal that goes beyond what

and this idea that she made a mistake in not pick governor shapiro, i just have to disagree with that. she picked governor walz. i think governor walz is -- is a terrific candidate. and i think what she needs be doing in this -- in this campaign is continuing to go out there and do what she's done all week this week going out and talking to people on the various shows and podcasts and everything. and telling -- showing them who she is and what she's for. and what i found interesting is of all the interviews the howard stern interview was terrific. but i think the interview with steven colbert was good. and i was thinking of your column, david, that in watching her in this interview with a comedian, i felt like -- you actually got to see the real kamala harris, personality-wise but also what she stands for, what she believes the, in -- in a manner that is more comfortable than when she's sitting before 60 minutes. geoff: jonathan add to up your column. [laughter] you wrote that she had an incredible first act. but the question now is can he construct a second and third act? david: i lo

now when you have those three blue state governors including my state shapiro who we love because he is a great leader. he was the final two. i will tell you when he says deeds and words. that's important. anyone can say in a campaign i will do this and this. it is what you've done. >> harris: what has she done. >> exactly. >> harris: she doesn't do any of that because she isn't joe biden. last word, tammy. >> you have kamala harris still having to straddle that. she is -- i give her the props for being a powerful woman. she wasn't sitting around reading romance november else the last 3 1/2 years. she was participating in this administration. this is what americans are voting on. what did they get with donald trump and what did they get with kamala harris? for kamala harris it is cereal for dinner at night. not your table. we want our table back with what we want on it. >> harris: kamala harris's campaign and she said for this entire series up until two weeks ago, the last woman in the room and made those decisions that left the economy where it is. not she is saying she is not joe b

. >> shapiro was speaking on cnn last night. we begin in north carolina with mike memoli. jonathan allen in washington. mike, one harris aide tells nbc that biden's comment is not helpful, whatever he meant. how is the campaign trying to get the focus on harris' successful rally? >> reporter: there's no doubt that the president's comment last night has proved to be quite a distraction. the campaign really is trying to keep pushing forward. we heard the vice president, we heard tim walz try to address this this morning, saying that the president was quick to clarify his remarks. but it doesn't reflect how they view the voters who they are appealing to in the closing stretch of the campaign. they are trying to keep the energy going. what we have seen at this rally behind me, you see governor cooper, the outgoing governor of north carolina speaking before him josh stein. one of the biggest crowd reactions here today was when somebody had a puerto rican flag and was walking it across. they played puerto rican music. that's an issue. they want the vice president to continue to

the democrats, josh shapiro are upset with elon musk because he is a trump supporter.f you look at what is happening with elon musk and you look at what's happening in virginia, the democrats are running sc scared. >> john: we will see if the doj comes after elon musk or not. deep pockets. he could afford some attorneys. leo terrel for us. thank you. >> sandra: school choice front and center in the upcoming election with growing support for challenging public schools dominance on our children's education. william la jeunesse is live in l.a. for us. how has polling change on this issue? >> polling shows 71% of parents now support school choice. up seven points from the last election. it's on the ballot in three states and now 14% of catholic school students use choice programs to help pay their tuition. for many parents this is not a sleeper issue, it's a difference maker because they would rely on these public launchers savings accounts or tax credits to help pay for private school religious or not. 1 million are now enrolled in these choice programs. trump supports it

>> i will leave it to governor shapiro and the legal authorities to speak to this. just not going to speak to it on here and we need to leave it to fec. >> can you talk broadly about what trump has said about making elon musk at the head of the government efficiency commission. does a white house event is a conflict of interest given the fact that his companies have so many contracts with government agencies and potentially given the power to regulate the agencies that hold sway over his own question marks because sunset is a campaign item there what they are planning to do next or what it will look like under their platform for his campaign, i will respond from here. >> any reaction from the president or the white house on elon musk's role at this moment at the clinical discussion? >> no comment on that at this moment. >> on the apparent leak of classified information, how concerned is the president in the message it says to the allies about the way the u.s. handle some of the most sensitive top-secret information. >> what i can say is we take this very seriously a

many democrats were hoping that josh shapiro got on the ticket. walz got on it.ke conversation with top democrats, they need him to come through and his appeal to western p.a. >> cecilia: you were talking to the walz-harris campaign, who do they feel like they need to win over? >> major was talking about blogs. you're going to see more blobs over the next month in michigan and wisconsin because walz is a midwesterner and he's been in michigan for the last several days doing debate prep there. that's no accident. we have been seeing him at football games. he was at the minnesota-michigan game. seeing him at farms and fall fests. i saw him buying a pumpkin the other day. he's out there in his plaid and his flannel making the case "i'm one of you" because those are pivotal states. as john delano was pointing out, half of pennsylvania kind of falls into that midwestern bucket. that's who they are hoping he appeals to tonght. we were talking about some of the darkness. what walz has brought to the ticket, democrats argue, is this notion of joy. he talked about republi

trump on the campaign trail and according to nbc news, musk also called pennsylvania governor job shapiroe was at the steelers game at pittsburgh on sunday. shapiro told nbc news the call was about musk investing in the state, not about politics, but it is notable muvsk initiated te conversation with the governor, perhaps the most important state in this election. he also gave an interview with tucker carlson on x and you can probably guess how that one went and he's been offering $47 pages to people registering to vote all ahead of the robotaxi event and something musk and tesla need to justify its massive valuation and "the wall street journal" had a story earlier this year and musk's political behavior have created a negative sentiment around him at a time when tesla is struggling to grow its vehicle delivery and an nbc poll from last month, only 6% of democrat his a favorable view of musk. 79% of them had negative feelings and as you can imagine, guys, nearly the opposite of republicans. 62% have a positive feeling about musk, guys? >> phil, let me turn back to you. you mentioned that

trump was on a muppet named ben shapiro's podcast yesterday to tell shapiro's listeners he isn't erraticthe erratic ones are joe and kamala. >> kamala harris has not invoked the 25th amendment. does she have responsibility to invoke the 25th amendment, oust him from office, take responsibility for the administration at this point? >> actually, now that you're mentioning it, i think they should do a double 25th amendment. get them both out. who's third in line? because it's just terrible. >> the speaker, mike johnson. >> this is the worst administration. what? no, this has got to be the worst administration ever. they they both don't know what the hell they're doing. >> jimmy: is he calling in from bed? [ laughter ] that's some low energy. hit the diet coke button quick! and he doesn't know the speaker of the house is third in line to the presidency. but he knows a ton about windmills! >> i flew over some of those beautiful windmills. they're all over the place. the gorgeous, beautiful pennsylvania countryside, they got these big, ugly suckers hanging down, they're rusting and rotting. ha