shaw? >> were there any other subnative points that you want to make, mr. shaw? >> again, 699-13, indicating that investigative records have to be kept confidential applies only to ethics laws, not public records access laws. >> miss herrick for her part, all be ignores campaign and government code 4.105 d. states that the ethics commiting shall investigate complaints under the section that alleged violations of local campaign finance lobbies and financial interest and government ethics laws, which commissioner hur pointed out. however, section 4.105 a, states. any person can file a complaint with the ethics commission alleging that a city officer or employee has engaged in improper activity by, again, violating campaign finance lobbying, conflicts of interest, or government ethics laws, regulations. the difference between them is that the complaints can be filed under 4.105 a. alleging many different violations

shaw. i mean the basis for miss herrick's analysis is 1040 b2. she is not claiming that there is an act of congress that forbids this. she is claiming that the necessity for perceiving confidentiality out weighs disclosure. >> commissioner hur, let me respond to that question and that is, sunshine ordinance, if you have ever read it specifically bars every agency in san francisco from exerting the official information privilege under that balancing test. >> didn't you just tell me that state law trumps the city charter and all city ordinances? >> i mean, what you just were arguing one minute ago. and ber raiding my legal knowledge on the basis of that is how you accurately interpret the law. but you can proceed on whatever additional subtanive additional arguments that you have. >> the sunshine ordinance is quite clear. you cannot use that balancing test, any balancing test with 1040 or 6254.7 and,.13. you can't use balancing tests, not in san francisco. >> i believe somewhere along the lin

it was a little unfair of nancy shaw to tell rebecca that late.the godmother, so she was supposed to be looking out for her. [captioned by the funding for this program [with captioning] was provided by: additional funding is provided by: and:

shaw, especially will have his chance. any other questions for mr. gidner? >> i am trying to think whether this would be something that would be ammenable, to research, because it is our responsibility, and i just don't know whether the law is going to give us a crystal answer than that. >> certainly, i can see the legal problem with having it separate agency make a determination that we somehow passed through as binding. now, could another city, county agency, make a recommendation that we would then have to readjudicate? that sounds like something that would likely be possible and would the premature of a completely, an agency that is totally separated from ours, provide assurances to the public that it was ajudicated correctly, perhaps. fortunately or unfortunately, we would be required to make our own determination, i don't think that we could rubber stamp it whether it was one or another. i don't know how ultimately helpful it is. that said, i certainly have no objection if we could find such an entity to look at it. i mean, i don't necessarily have an

shaw has made. we are not able to provide any information as we have stated to the task force and therefore, the information as we state it and as she has state it, in law, is that we cannot disclose any information. we have none to disclose. and yes, i have heard the task force ask us redact, it we have not redacted anything. if something is even requested of us from the judge, there are a lot of things that go in place that are handled by our city attorneys where it is confidencal and where it is closed and so forth and on. so we have been very forth right in our responses to the task force committee, to patrick monet shaw and to you as the ethics committee. and we have nothing that we can disclose. it is all a part of our file. >> how much correspondence is there between the city controller's office and the ethics commission regarding this complaint? >> i can't respond to that. >> you can't tell me that the volume? >> the volume, so my question would be what difference does that make? with all du

. >> kirk: david shaw trying to work this running game and try, especially on third down keep it near the middle of the field. >> brent: second down and eight. >> kirk: they got confusion here. >> brent: they finally get -- now the line judge will step in here. time-out called by shaw. >> referee: time-out stanford. >> kirk: hear some coaches say i ing -- >> brent: i want to go back to the headline of the night. the number one team has just lost, kansas state. was beaten by baylor. and oregon in danger of losing and if that happens, it will be notre dame jumping to number one in the rankings. maldonado had this field goal that hit the uprights. >> kirk: this what is makes the bcs so interesting is every region has something at stake. every region is watching right now because they are concerned about their own team. >> brent: you have to go back to 2007. play action. hogan. fumble! loose ball, battle for the football. the officials signaling that stanford may have recovered and it will be third down here. a great save by stanford. herbie -- >> kirk: 65, the linemen came in there, oreg

>> shaw. >> no, we think so. at the end of the day, they are selling commodity products, but there's nothing wrong with that. you just have to be run well. if you look at since then, they haven't been run well. we think that's an issue. also, having a strong sales force, strong personality in terms of convincing your own employees, this terms of convincing customers, we think those are things that are no longer there. we think, frankly, have made life difficult for hp. >> herb, you disagree. you think the company's problems were bigger than any ceo, right? >> absolutely. i'd go so far as so -- to say that under mark hurd, the company was an illusion. he was trying to please wall street. look at the revenue growth. most of it was through acquisitions. remember eds? then you have a situation where he was slicing and dicing. an important metric that wall street watched wasn't gross margin, which wasn't doing much. what wall street watched was the operating margin. the operating margin was going up, but it was going

. >> commissioners, good evening, my name is shaw, head of shaw security, attitude check is one of many ways that you can address this, simply they say how are you, they respond back, i'm going great, or they get attitude from them, those are the kind of tools as security doormen we have to make sure we're getting the right kind of clientele in, so it's a colloqialism. >> and during the week, patrol and perimeter as needed, what does that mean? >> as needed is in preference to entertainment, if tles ao no entertainment happening on a thursday night, if they're just serving dinner, they won't have security present. >> got you, okay, thank you. >> can i ask a question about the floor plan, so it looks like what you provided here, it's not laid out as a restaurant, can you describe -- i don't see tables and chairs and that type of thing. >> tables and chairs aren't on the sketch of the floor plan. >> i guess how you -- it's going to be a flexible space because you want entertainment, how is that going to work. >> if you look at the floor plan, you'll see there's areas in both of those side

outside when shaw came out and attacked him. >> he came outside to my truck threw bullets through myruck and i am lucky to be alive. >> they claim they had an argument about drugs purchase the shooting. shaw is now being held on assault charges but could be charged with attempted murder. >>> and cat williams is accused of leading police on a chase. williams allegedly drove a three wheeled motorcycle before officers called off the chase. williams was asked to leave a high at after -- high yacht after a disturbance. he was accused of hitting a man in the head with a bottle. >>> a bizarre video of two suspects, two men demanding the couple's cell phone at gunpoint. they had video of those two suspects driving erratically. the men followed the couple as they drove away and one stopped and one of the suspects actually got into the couple's car. >> the husband and suspect got into a struggle and the us a ban was able to push the man out of the car and told the wife to hit the gas. that is when the suspect started firing shots at the car. nobody was hurt. later police arrested the suspects

shaw i will give you a minute, and i am not sure what you have. >> i just want to note, mr. gibner indicated that miss herrick was stepping into the shoes of the executive director, right? >> can you get to your point, please? >> you are going to let the acting in the shoes executive director, determine herself the contents of those files? why can't you carve out the time and you examine them? so that it is not a member of the staff filling in for something the ethics commission apparently doesn't want to do itself? >> you would rather have us review the documents? is that your position? >> absolutely. >> you could use a hearing officer. >> sir, not i am going to hear from you. >> i am not going to hear from you, please, shut down. >> i want to object to one thing only. >> if i let you speak everybody has to speak. and we are not going to go forward with this. >> on that part of the voters we said that 6724 is part of the law of this county and you cannot just throw it out... >> can i make myself clear? >> no. >> i want an ethics commiting commissioner not a deposit city att

hostility at buck shaw stadium. the quakes with an elbow to the head. where is the defense here?e strolls in for l.a. nobody picks him up. it would have tied it up. it waits on bush and scores. how about the cart wheel into the forward role and guns blazing. l.a. would go up 3-0 at the half. alan gordon and shoots and scores. one more goal and the quakes could advance. he shot it high from point blank range. he does not want to get up after that. so the season is over because the l.a. galaxy advance 3-2 on the aggregate scoring system. that's about the worst way ever to decide a playoff series. it is over. the warriors admit they lacked energy and intensity in a loss to sacramento. they came out with purpose and curry was on fire tonight against cleavland. world series hero and sandoval at courtside. neighbors with curry i hear. he didn't score, but he had five assists. irving, remember the number one pick in the draft was wheeling and dealing. he had 28. curry answering. he had 15 in the first quarter and finished with 21. thompson early foul trouble. a nice dish to leigh. i thi

hostility at buck shaw stadium. the quakes with an elbow to the head. where is the defense here?r l.a. nobody picks him up. it would have tied it up. it waits on bush and scores. how about the cart wheel into the forward role and guns blazing. l.a. would go up 3-0 at the half. alan gordon and shoots and scores. one more goal and the quakes could advance. he shot it high from point blank range. he does not want to get up after that. so the season is over because the l.a. galaxy advance 3-2 on the aggregate scoring system. that's about the worst way ever to decide a playoff series. it is over. the warriors admit they lacked energy and intensity in a loss to sacramento. they came out with purpose and curry was on fire tonight against cleavland. world series hero and sandoval at courtside. neighbors with curry i hear. he didn't score, but he had five assists. irving, remember the number one pick in the draft was wheeling and dealing. he had 28. curry answering. he had 15 in the first quarter and finished with 21. thompson early foul trouble. a nice dish to leigh. i think this is a sh

shaw middle school at garnet patterson is one of 20 schools slated to close under the plan. students like marvin kirkland would be transferred. meaning six through 12th graders would co-exist on the same campus. marvin's mom doesn't think that's a good idea. >> all the kids are, you know, they are too young to be around teenagers. >> reporter: would you worry about your son? >> i would. i would worry about him. i want him growing up too fast. >> reporter: underenrollment made the closes necessary. schools like shaw don't have enough students to justify the expense of operating and maintaining the building. the chancellor says she would rather consolidate students in one school and use the savings on programs that target children who are falling behind academically. the closure plan must be appr e approved by mayor vincent gray. before that happens, parents will get a chance to voice their concerns. marvin hopes parent wills fight to keep his school open. >> it's fun. i love it here. >> reporter: you don't want to go? >> i don't want to go. >> reporter: parents will be allowe

shaw's 21-4 since taking over for harbaugh.d plays for the pac-12 championship on friday against ucla at the pond. now the winner goes to the rose bowl. game experts did not picture this when they started playing football and the season began. >> i never -- i know nobody was giving us a let down for the pac-12 media day at the beginning of the season and i told them it was the same thing, when toby left, it was the same thing when harbaugh left, it was the same thing when andrew left. and i guess people out there just don't get it. they don't understand what type of guys we have on this team, what kind of coaches we have. no, we're not going away. we are not a one-person team, we never have been. so people can say what they want but we know this team will be around for a while. >> former giants outfielder melky cabrera will get a share of the pie, despite missing the final 50 games because he tested positive for testosterone. a baseball rule on eligibility automatically allowed cabrera to cash in for $377,000, that is a post se

. >> stanford head football coach david shaw today reached the top honor. he was named the top 12 pac ten coach of the year, guiding the cardinals to a ten and two record. he becomes the fourth football coach to win consecutive coach of the year awards this season. >>> after a 5,000 miles from colorado. a crane lifted the 65-foot angle man spruce into the came capital. the tree will be decorated with five. >> 49ers play their final season at contacting stick, just ahead, how your ahead, you may not be able to tell by looking outside, but it is shaping up to be a wet week. meteorologist mary rowswood tells us about when to expect those storms? >> and if you're on the go, you can still watch ktvu newscast on live on your computer, smartphone, or tablet, get the app or go to ktvu.com. [ laughter ] [ girl ] wow, you guys have it easy. i wish i had u-verse when i was your age. in my day, we didn't have these fancy wireless receivers. blah blah blah. if i had a sleepover, i couldn't just move the tv into the playroom. no. we had to watch movies in the den because