joining me now from the city of convention is do the obvious political editor michelle of the highly shela not just anglo american has been addressing delegates there what do you make a what she said so far. though she just got to the touchy subject of having surrendered the finance ministry and certainly many delegates feel the pain here that the social democrats will now be able to take that ministry considered to be one of the key ministries here. she faced a lot of criticism after this coalition deal was done with the social democrats and she basically put it to delegates say well should we have let the whole thing fail over that one ministry after all we have the trade ministry here which peter altmire the current finance minister will take over and she also mapped out what she felt for the reasons why the c.d.u. had less support in those past elections which the city you won because it came became the largest party but it by no means can be described as a victory so she signalled some recognition that really there are many questions that if you have social season of insecurity that n