shelby and her friends were using an app called meet me. it's a social media site gaining a lot of popularity. it used to be call my yearbook but changed its name. it's kind of like facebook or myspace but with a twist. it uses people who are online and shows people nearby and how close. you only have to be 13 to sign up. >> probably 100 kids on here that all have one thing on their mind. >> reporter: produces through the profiles and you know what he means a meet me spokesperson said it's tough to tell who's telling the truth, but they do try to prevent adults using meet me. shelby and her friends were picked up by the 20-year-old man who drove them to this glendale apartment. >> he sat in the hot tub and did nothing. >> reporter: that's when shelby answered a call from her dad. within minutes he was on his way and flagged down glen dale police officers to come. >> i said i need you. >> reporter: before they arrived, the man took off. >> my dad pulled up and he had cops with him. >> reporter: we're not naming the suspect because he hasn't

the republicans as you can see from senator shelby and also from the democrats. probably even more importantly from the democrats one of the obama administration took over that they also strongly supported what we were doing. >> former senator from kentucky had this to say to you during the confirmation process. [video clip]. the bailout law allowed $50 million for your office. you will have a very ample amount of resources. but i have serious concerns with your nomination. the nominee maybe a dedicated public servant, he appears to be a skilled prosecutor and a man of integrity. i wonder why taxpayers should have to pay $50 million to a watchdog who will have nothing to watch. ultimately, i believe mr. barofsky with his impressive legal skills can serve the public far better in new york where he can continue to prosecute fraud. >> where was senatorburning coming from. >> he was opposed to t.a.r.p. in the first place. that's understandable concept. there's a lot of people out there feel more government agencies is not the solution. i will say eventually, i brough

also, shelby steele on how group and identity politics is shaping this presidential election. turning back to the president's so-called new economic patriotism, the polls and what we can expect over the final 40 days now until election day. clinton adviser, fox news political analyst, doug schoen. also, ed rollins, former reagan political director, it's good to have you with us weather thank you very much for having me. lou: let me start with this new theme. we can all agree that the president has a thing called forward i want to understand, if you will, the motto or mitt romney. this is a man ready to sell himself. you don't get to be president simply because you have a combination of democratic election. he has 30 days at this point in time. i would not mention the present. everyone knows this president has failed and nobody's going to google for this president thinking that he has been a great president. lou: i have never seen so many people, including democrats, so willing to offer a candidate, in this case, governor romney, about how to quickly turn your campaign around i

the republicans, as you can see from senator shelby but also from the democrats. probably even more importantly from the democrats once the obama administration took over that they also strongly support of what we were doing and helped keep the pressure on treasury. >> senator jim bunning -- former senator of kentucky had this to say to you during the confirmation process. guest: >> the bailout law allows $50 million for your office. so, you will have a very ample amount of resources. but i have serious concerns with your nomination. the nominee may be a dedicated public servants, he appears to be a skilled prosecutor and a man of integrity. but i wonder why taxpayers should have to pay $50 million to a watchdog will have nothing to watch. ultimately, i believe mr. barofsky, which is impressive legal skills can serve the public are better in the southern district of new york where he can continue to prosecute mortgage fraud. >> where it was senator bunning coming from? >> i think he was very much a prose -- opposed to tarp of the first place, the whole legislation

shelby in arkansas, please.lby. >> caller: yes. >> shelby. >> caller: an arkansas boo-yah and we're going to elect jim cramer for president if he'd ever run for president. but my question would be hek. >> i think heckmann is turning into a world class amelioration of pollution company for fracking and for drilling. the stock had a monster move from three to almost five, and i think at this point, you've got to let it cool off. it remains a speculative stock that i like and want to buy. let's go to steve in new york. steve? >> caller: hey, jim. thanks for taking my call. hcn. >> i was telling people that that secondary is going to be good because they're buying sunrise senior living. i think hcn is still a good buy. matt in michigan. >> caller: yes. simon property. >> another one did a deal and i think that's expanding. hgn, those are for me. and that, ladies and gentlemen is the conclusion of the "lightning round"! [ male announcer ] if you believe the mayan calendar, on december 21st polar shifts will reverse t

i had heard of marcus shelby and had been in join his work but never had the opportunity to meet him.e were brought together by the equal justice society specifically for this project. we were charged with beginning work. marquez and i spent a lot of time addressing our own position on the death penalty, our experiences with people who had been incarcerated, family members, friends of friends. pulling our information. beyond that, we did our own research. to create a picture that resonated with humanity. it is the shape of a house. in this context, it is also small and acts like a cell. i thought that was an interesting play on how these people make these adjustments, half to create home. what is home for these people? the home is their cell. people talk a lot about noise -- very noisy in prisons. that is interesting to me. looking at the communication level, the rise of frustration of being caged, wondering, where does redemption fit into the equation here? [singing] i think both of us really believe the death penalty is wrong, and is flawed for many reasons. the list is as long as m

we are joined by one of the country's leading social thinkers and authors, shelby steele.d about hillary's plans, what about pills? most to play, and he has an idea how. the "a-team" next. it he was never supposed to have a fair fight. the nfl with all the economic power. it turns out professional football's more entertaining when everyone plays by the rules. we will show you how much money all those screwed up caused by the replacement raffs put in the the replacement raffs put in the pockets of the real refs. [ male announcer ] you are a business pro. governor of getting it done. you know how to dance... with a deadline. and you...rent from national. because only national lets you choose any car in the aisle... and go. you can even take a full-size or above, and still pay the mid-size price. this is awesome. [ male announcer ] yes, it is, business pro. yes, it is. go national. go like a pro. ♪ lou: the naacp goes before the u.n. human rights commission demanding an investigation into what it charges are racially discriminatory election laws in this country. while the nat

scott will be shelby, lisa shin, pierre and natalie brown. >> good morning task force. my name is lois scott, and i live by cathedral, i live on cathedral hill by st. mary's cathedral about two and a half blocks from the proposed hospital site. i'm on the board of the cathedral hill neighbors who were dispointed that our neighborhood who was going to be reunited in your quest and necessity to have the numbers come out was still split. i guess we joined russia hill as one of those neighborhoods that will be permanently split. we're some what of an emerging neighborhood association, that we've only been in existence about half a dozen years, not as long as some of the other neighborhoods in san francisco. we have a huge, huge issue coming up on the construction of the cathedral hill campus of the hospital. 555 beds, a huge impact on our neighborhood. that particular block we urgently request you put that back in district five. it has no population and as a future hospital it will have no population. it is so much more related to the western addition than the marina in dis

i had heard of marcus shelby and had been in join his work but never had the opportunity to meet him. we were brought together by the equal justice society specifically for this project. we were charged with beginning work. marquez and i spent a lot of time addressing our own

in an effort to justify shelby and the money he is spending to stand up to israel -- >> listen. >> the democrats and republicans are committed to israel future and security. i'm one of them. >> understand. no republican took those words out of the democratic platform. so i'm just making a point. >> you're saying those two bulletins coming out means our relationship with israel changed? >> no, i'm just asking the question why it was changed. >> is that fair? >> bret: we asked senator durbin to come back on tonight or provide us a statement to read on air. his staff told us, "he's not going to be available." we will bring you a statement if one comes during this show. let's break that down. exactly what happened. senior national correspondent john roberts is on the convention floor. where it all went down a short time ago. good evening, john. >> good evening, bret. you were talking about that potentially coming to a roll call vote. the congressional producer was on the floor when all of this was going on and said they were just about to start up the computers and then antonio villaraigos

>> the woman you're seeing here, shelby figueroa, according to deputies, 18 years old, was driving down highway in her own car, very slowly. according to sheriff deputies she was drying two miles per hour down the middle of the highway. so -- >> pretty slow. >> they arrested her. put her in cuffs. put her in the back of this transport vehicle. they went to go deal with her vehicle, she slipped out of the handcuffs, got into the driver's side of this transport vehicle and took off. she went from driving 2 miles per hour, to leading police on a chase of nearly 100 miles per hour. >> what's this girl's story? >> according to court documents figueroa did have cocaine and alcohol in her system. and this wasn't her only offense for driving under the influence. >> why did her face get allñr mangled? >> as the chase continued for nearly 20 miles, police eventually put down spike strips, blew out one tire, they were able to ram her car, she spun out and it flipped. she was injured when the car flipped. you can see from her mug shot the damage to her face. and according to sheriff's deputies, fac

. >> cenk: man, i was taken aback by senator shelby's response. that's a senator.nice thing about the president wow. we seem to have a theme there. plays basketball. family man and a snapgy dresser. >> caller: and there are so many things you would they could say. he gave me the tax cuts i need. he's a non-violent muslim. he's half white. at least something from these guys. >> the funniest part about saying he's a snapgy dresser left to his own devices if his stylist is not dressing him or his wife he's a terrible dresser. wearing mom jeans. >> cenk: i don't pull the pants up but i'm a horrible dresser. it's interesting. not only is he not muslim. he's also not non-violent. >> they ought to be a big fan of him. >> cenk: that's an interesting point. >> he has high favorability ratings. usually around 60%. people like obama. even his own worst enemies say he's mesmerizing. if you went to the democratic convention and asked people to say something nice about president bush, it would been worse. >> cenk: we play this game amongst ourselves back then. he did his best wi

>> shelby zorotney is an anchor for nbc in steubenville, ohio.he's covering the sentencing that day, and her cameraman captures the scene. the first to respond to the incident is sheriff fred abdullah. >> we didn't hit him, we didn't strike him, nothing like that. i knew and i could just imagine the pain that he was going through, the hurt. >> i have done a lot of sentencing hearings, and i have had family members be terribly upset and terribly angry, but i had never seen a physical altercation between a victim's family member and the defendant. i was terrified for him that he might get hurt as the officers tried to subdue him. and my honest thought was that he might try to kill the defendant. >> others in the courtroom fear the same thing. >> i thought that this was going to be a disaster, and it was. i saw mr. swett's hand moving to try to get to the sheriff's weapon. the sheriff was able to restrain him, and he did not get his hand on the sheriff's weapon, which was holstered. >> clifford can't defend himself. he's handcuffed and remains silen

. -- no right shelby abridged because of athletic status all legitimate enterprise coming therefore separate from their school. tell me on what basis you object to that and you can build the n.c.a.a. on the back of that lease whose rights are uniquely abridged and is festering along with the other problems in higher education because the place that is supposed to have brave thought does everything by assumption and that is the very thing that it lacks. confront the basic definitions. that is where government and reform starts. thank you. >> ok, i think there is a misconception out there that there is some of some secret stuff going on. and there may be. most of it goes on in private universities because we cannot see what they do. but for any of the big public universities involved, everything they do is available under public information and the newspapers are good at that. stuff i don't have, they can get and give it to me. the n.c.a.a. it provides an extraordinary amount of information to the universities that are a part of their enterprise. it may be that the presidents don't pay attenti

. >> well, we interviewed a source, shelby steele of the hoover institution, and he makes the point thatf a secret weapon, a secret sauce. and what was that? the promise of racial redemption. there's a deep desire in america to get beyond our racial history. so it's almost like by voting for obama, we all get to feel really good about ourselves, and obama benefited from that politically. >> do you think the american people, though, are that shallow, that we would vote for someone to feel good about ourselves? i mean, this is the future of the country. >> but randi, that's not shallow at all. it's the deepest american aspiration to live up to our country's high ideals, and our country is based on the idea that we're all created equal, we're moral equals in the eyes of god. so, the idea of trying to find a president who embodies that aspiration, far from being shallow, actually reflects the best of the american character. >> dinesh d'souza, nice to chat with you. a lot more i wish we could chat about, but we don't have the time this morning. but thank you very much. >> my pleasure. >>> for

what the shelby coalition advocated with gigabit connected the. if you put a gig to every elementary and high-school, you every community and have an open intersection requirement. the obama administration went along with that. they shifted its priorities and agreed number of grants went to middle laugh fiber and for structure. i've been one a week ago in west virginia. wv net -- they are using for schools and other public sector institutions. if public fiber have a system open to any, can facilitate initial deployments and competitive overbuilding. it is also disrupted because currently the dominant isp's have a stranglehold on the special access market. the competitive carriers like t mobile and wireless carriers cannot get back call for their cell phone networks. without purchasing it from the dominant incumbents. primarily, same with businesses. a chain of banks cannot connect all the branches and atms without going hand on need to the incumbents to get access to their fiber. we had more open access public fiber running ever wear , we would be

the fiberglass facilities are in shelby and lexington which are outside of charlotte and greensboro respectively, and their role, growing role has been really good for not only the company but for north carolina, and in 2010, p.p.g. expanded its presence and brought online an additional furnace and created another 1,800 jobs. in sum, across north carolina, you have over 2,000 good-paying jobs, and then those jobs create a ripple effect. you want to look more broadly then at north carolina so they are manufacturing, but they also have very significant wind energy potential in the state itself. offshore wind resources are abundant, the american wind energy association estimates that wind energy could provide enough electricity to power some 800,000 homes. and that's not all. onshore wind resources could also provide a substantial amount of power for the state. so you look at these numbers, this is an important industry in north carolina. it's certainly made a difference, but if we don't extend the wind production tax credit, this strong growth and the potential development -- the strong growth in

shelby county did not ask for pre clearance. sh she basically said this is not fair. they are criticizing the use of section 5 in this case. this is the most likely case to be taking. there is also a couple of cases that are coming up. i mentioned the texas voter identification case. the redistricting has been working on a a year and more of things. this is a lesson in how challenging it is. south carolina enacted one at the same time. this is incredibly costly and time-consuming to do this. the court has suggested that kennedy made an earlier decision i think they tip their hands a little bit in the unanimous decision that came out this week called a tenant versus jefferson county. it was a redistricting question. they were reorganizing their counties based on the census. it got shot down. there were slight variations to the number in the people. the court said we are going to give them some difference. these are perfectly reasonable to do. they have this over involvement of judges in the process. but for those coming up a probably not early enough to affect the nove

shelby of utah to be united states district judge for the district of utah. the presiding officer: is there any fiewrt debate? hearing none, all those in favor say aye. those opposed no. the ayes appear to have it. the ayes do have it. the nominations are confirmed. mr. reid: i suggest the absence of a quorum. the presiding officer: the clerk will call the roll. quorum call: mr. reid: i ask unanimous consent the call of the quorum be terminated. the presiding officer: without objection. mr. reid: i ask unanimous consent the senate proceed to calendar number 44, s. 1956. the presiding officer: the clerk will report. the clerk: calendar numbered 484, s. 1956, a bill to prohibit operators of civil aircraft of the united states from participating in the european union's emissions trading scheme and for other purposes. the presiding officer: is there objection to proceeding to the measure? without objection. mr. reid: mr. president i ask unanimous consent that the committee reported amendment be considered the cardin and merkley amendments at the desk be agreed to

the main case is the shelby county, alabama case. and it has been also covered since 1965 and shelby county did not ask for a pre-clearance. they just challenged it facially. you are requiring us to do these things and not requiring other states to do it. it is not fair. full disclosure, we made this file criticizing the use of section 5 in this case. but i think this is nonetheless the most likely case to be taken partly because it has the muteness issue. i mentioned to the texas voter i.d. case. they have a pre-clearance issue with the odor id and with redistricting that have been working on -- with voter i.d. and with redistricting the have been worked on. south carolina and enacted a voter ideologue the same time. they're still in the middle of litigation. -- a voter i.d. law at the same time. they are still in the middle of litigation. in the texas context, there is concern about the unequal ways that states are being treated. and a tip their hand a little bit in a unanimous per carry a decision that came out this week called te

without i would like to turn it over to ranking member shelby for his statement. >> thank you mr. chairman. good morning. today is -- is the chairman has pointed out we will hear from richard cordray the director of the bureau of consumer financial protection. the majority holding the cfpb accountable. nevertheless mr. cordray appears before us as always completely immune from congressional oversight except of course where permitted asking questions like today. such questions are especially important now because the bureau's activities. in its first year like leah overshadowed his activities in the years to come. of particular interest here to me is how the bureau has exercised its authority thus far. for example, recently that bureau issued a proposed rule on mortgage disclosures. buried deep within its 1100 pages, that bureau expressed concern over a particular disclosure required by dodd-frank. the bureau said that it found that the new disclosure and i quote, would be difficult to calculate and explain to consumers, would not likely be helpful to consumers and may distract con

shelby county, alabama, there's a petition of the supreme court, in our view not clear the court should. the court has affirmed this provision four times. there is a very substantial record. 16,000 pages before congress when it reauthorized the voting rights act, this provision in 2006. but, here is the key, again, justice kennedy is the swing vote here. there's always been a gap in coverage as it turns out, the state of texas wasn't covered by the initial 1965 act. ift was added in 1975. it's always been the case. the question is, are we going to defer to the judgment of congress that this act is still necessary? is congress' judgment reasonable? >> respond to jeff's argument. the way, the strangeness of the voting rights act is the strangeness of american politics, the strangeness of slavery, the civil war reconstruction and everything else. specific geographic regions where we have a process for and the argument that jeff is making, hey, look at the region's we don't have the special process for. they are doing the same stuff. what is the justification? >> there's a history in the ju

oh dear. [ wah wah ] >> kelby at current said -- kelby, shelby, whatever. >> stephanie: i love you inndom facebook quote of the day. every time mitt opens his mouth a swing state gets its wings. >> stephanie: oh, wait a minute. who's that that just slipped in. >> stephy. >> stephanie: what's all of the heavy breathing i hear? ♪ the humpty dance ♪ ♪ do the hump ♪ >> hump days with hal sparks. >> yes, yes! >> somebody had time to stop at starbucks. >> coffee bean, thank you very much. it is the west coast. >> stephanie: somebody's recovering from their birthday yesterday. happy birthday. >> thanks. yeah, we were actually shooting. ♪ you say it's your birthday ♪ ♪ it's my birthday, too ♪ >> stephanie: my little libra soul mate. there will be group spanking for us at sexy liberal. >> how is that different than the last time we were in seattle for sexy liberal? >> stephanie: it wasn't my birthday last time. >> i should have gotten spankings. >> stephanie: if you loved me, you would get that robo spank machine we had at the old studio. >> i'm not familiar. >> stephanie: sure you are. >> lik

-- [applause] you can be certain that i'm not going to accept that for my daughter's rebecca and shelbyine years old. that is not going to be their future and i know you won't accept it either, right? [applause] absolutely. now thank you. now throughout this election cycle, we have heard it all from the other side, haven't we? from my colleagues with todd akin's infamous words about legitimate rape to your own governor's advice to women being forced to undergo unnecessary and invasive ultrasounds to just close your eyes. i mean, you just can't make this stuff up. get is a stark reminder to all of us that there are still powerful forces who want to turn back the clock for women in this country and in this day. we are not going back, are we? they can only succeed if we let them and we won't let them take us backwards. that is what the next 51 days is about. we must be moving forward. [applause] so now, now it's my honor to introduce a truly incredible woman, dr. jill biden. [cheers and applause] they have some very nice words here that they have put on the paper for me which i'm not going

. -- no right shelby abridged because of athletic status all legitimate enterprise coming therefore separate from their school. tell me on what basis you object to that and you can build the n.c.a.a. on the back of that lease whose rights are uniquely abridged and is festering along with the other problems in higher education because the place that is supposed to have brave thought does everything by assumption and that is the very thing that it lacks. confront the basic definitions. that is where government and reform starts. thank you. >> ok, i think there is a misconception out there that there is some of some secret stuff going on. and there may be. most of it goes on in private universities because we cannot see what they do. but for any of the big public universities involved, everything they do is available under public information and the newspapers are good at that. stuff i don't have, they can get and give it to me. the n.c.a.a. it provides an extraordinary amount of information to the universities that are a part of their enterprise. it may be that the presidents don't pay attenti

shelby county, alabama is another jurisdiction covered since 1965 and shelby county did not ask for pre clearance. they basically said you are requiring us or not requiring other states. is not fair. full disclosure, we filed naked briefs on behalf of ourselves and former officials criticizing the use of section 5 but nonetheless the most likely case to be taken because of the movement issue and there are a couple cases coming up. i mentioned the texas voter id case. they have a pre clearance issue with voter id and redistricting that has been working on a year and more and the law was passed in 2011 and the pre clearance and that is a lesson how challenging it is. south carolina -- they were in the middle of litigation. this is a costly and time-consuming process to do this. the court has suggested in the past that justice kennedy in an earlier decision in the texas context there are some real concerns about the unequal weight states are being treated and may be tipped their hand and made a unanimous decision just this week called tenet versus jefferson. that was in west for junior hou

he's not trying to help the people, ease shelby specially the poor why is he running? for rich people. the israel guy is going to tell him go to iron and he is going to go to iran. he doesn't have any backbone. he goes which ever the way the wind blows. hey he's going to go to war with iran. he whatever the donors tell him. what do you think? >> guest: thank you for your questions. firsten 0 the media. i have departmented a healthy respect for the media. our system of government couldn't work without them. i think we are lucky to have them. on governor romney, all i can say he's been a successful person in whatever he's done. he's had a successful business career, he was -- i think he was a good governor of mississippi in many ways. i live in massachusetts. but my own point of view, he's had a tough presidential campaign. he has 47% mark was damaging to him. he doesn't have traction. he hasn't been able to develop and articulate a compelling view how he would lead the nation on different destruction than president obama. he has the opportunity to do that. maybe he can

. -- no right shelby abridged because of athletic status all legitimate enterprise coming therefore separate from their school. tell me on what basis you object to that and you can build the n.c.a.a. on the back of that lease whose rights are uniquely abridged and is festering along with the other problems in higher education because the place that is supposed to have brave thought does everything by assumption and that is the very thing that it lacks. confront the basic definitions. that is where government and reform starts. thank you. >> ok, i think there is a misconception out there that there is some of some secret stuff going on. and there may be. most of it goes on in private universities because we cannot see what they do. but for any of the big public universities involved, everything they do is available under public information and the newspapers are good at that. stuff i don't have, they can get and give it to me. the n.c.a.a. it provides an extraordinary amount of information to the universities that are a part of their enterprise. it may be that the presidents don't pay attenti

i worked with dick shelby to reform our intelligence structure. rob portman and i worked to reform the internal revenue service. i've worked with george bush and john mccain to normalize relations with vietnam. it was a wonderful bipartisan accomplishment that i am proud of. it is not just identifying republicans. the rules have to change, and i promise you, i believe i can persuade americans to amend the constitution, to allow the congress to ban both outside money and limit the amount of money in campaigns because it is corrupting our political decision-making. we need to change the rules of the filibuster and reduce the number of committees, to reform the congressional pension. there are many changes that need to occur, not just identifying somebody that i can work with, but who am i going to fight. i will be fighting with mitch mcconnell and harry reid on a regular basis. >> thank you. you have 30 seconds for a bottle. -- rebuttal. >> throughout my adult life i have been fortunate to serve on a number of boards, commissions. i was a school boa

in shelby county judge williams late out some pretty powerful empirical evidence as to the formula used and the criteria used and how there is no fit anymore and that was not convincing to the circuit and i was wondering if there's any broad rustication that it will be more convincing to the supreme court? >> it will be more convincing. >> it is a cousin of managed question about the missing evidence when it comes to affirmative-action and they have seen section 5 a lot. justice kennedy has written a lot about it and they have very strong views to begin with. it is mostly confirmed for many justices that the list of jurisdictions in section 5 was created in another era and when congress authorized the voting rights act of section 5 for 25 years it didn't illicit -- seems like the old list. there may be a misfit as well there. i don't think for those justices and likely four who strongly believe in the section 5 procedures i don't think this will change their minds but it may well combine -- confirm the view of the rest of the court. >> section 5 and the voting rights act is such an impo

and shelby county, i thought they laid out some powerful empirical evidence as to the formula that was used in the criteria used dating back to 1973, another is no fit there anymore. that was not convincing to the d.c. circuit. i was wondering if it would be more convincing to the supreme court? >> yes. it will be more convincing. about the misfit evidence when it comes to affirmative action. justice kennedy has written a lot about it. they have very strong views. i agree, it would be more persuasive. but it will mostly be confirmatory for many of the justices that this list of the jurisdictions subject to section 5, it was created in another era. oddly, the list seems an awful lot like the old list. there may be a misfit as well there. for those justices, and there are likely at least four who believe in the section 5 procedures, i do not think this will change their minds. but it may confirm the views of the rest of the board. >> the voting rights act, section 5 -- it has such an important impact. i think that is the main reason congress has never quibbled with the formula. they stop

with that, i'm going to invite senator shelby. >> thank you. mr.rdray, you used the word "complexity," and we'll get into some of this now. the dodd-frank creditors that they disclot, quote, "total mortgage percentage," and they are using its, quote, "exception and modification authority under section 105a and dodd-frank section 1032a." section 1032a does not have this, and i'm sure you know this, contain the exception and modification language that appears in section 105a and f. do you believe that there is an exception in modification authority in section 1032a? >> it's a very good question, senator, and it's one that some of our lawyers have poured over, and there's lawyers outside who poured over it as well, and we do have exception authority under several different provisions of the statutes we administration -- >> no, the question was do you have it under section 1032 # a? >> including 1032a. >> yes, and where is it in 1032a? >> in 1032a -- >> i want my staff here to be listening to this. >> that's fine. 1032, a, reading from the statute as i

all covers since 1965 in shelby county didn't even ask for preclearance of any changes.they just facially sad you are requiring us to do these things and not requiring other states. full disclosure we filed an amicus brief on behalf of ourselves in a group of former doj officials, criticizing the use of section five in this case. but i think this is nonetheless the most likely case to be taken most likely because it has the issue. there's also a couple cases. they have a preclearance issue with reject just gained that has been working on a year and more games -- a voter i.d. law passed in 2011 were they still enacted it because of this preclearance with a less than how challenging it is. south carolina enacted at the same time it also still litigation. it's costly and time-consuming process to do this. the court suggested in the past with justice kennedy in an earlier decision in the texas contacts that there are some concerns about the states being treated and i think they also may be tipped her hand a little bit in a unanimous per curiam situation that came out just th