she lives on the ground for, sherida. she is quite simply incapable of doing her laundry at a remote location. since she moved in in 1973, she has always had laundry facilities on the service porch outside of her apartment, and as we tried to point out in the brief, even the notice of violations do not address any issues with sherida ireton's on ground service porch. if i read this correctly along with the pictures that were submitted by the permit holder, the issues here have to deal with the post's leading up to the top floor deck or service porch on the second unit, the deterioration and the rotting of the top floors service porch, and sherida, who would be most impacted by the elimination, her apartment is on the bottom floor. it is their position that her laundry facilities should not be interrupted temporarily even during the repair because there is no repair work to abate a notice of violation that would go to her facility. the upstairs are different. there definitely is repair work that they would need to move the

>> sherida, the most impacted lives on the first floor. commissioner fung: and is there a second ada? >> yes, sheriann. commissioner fung: and she lives on the second floor? >> yes. it was to preserve the existing moderate this in the days. commissioner garcia: in your opinion, if the egress was supposed to be a certain number of issues, -- inches, would the situation be acceptable print >> i believe it would be. if i may. inspector duffy would know this better than i, but i think it is important that the most severely impacted appellant is on the bottom floor, and i do not believe that the violation dealt with the bottom floor small porches. i think that all of the violations -- commissioner garcia: i do not think you are supposed to be addressing him directly, and your answer does not go with any questions and anyone was asking. commissioner peterson: you are not representing all 12 of them? >> no. >> that is not which true that i have not been communicating with them. all i am trying to do is get this notice of violation taken care of.