there is a former kgb agent, sergei shirnov, who worked for the kgb until the early 1990s. made a home in france. he says that he attended the elite paris school, the ena, at the same time as you. he said, quote, "i had a lot of contact with karin. "she was my classmate. "she was pro—putin long before she became foreign minister, "and i got the impression — and i wrote this on "her intelligence card — that she could be a good "candidate to be recruited by our services". that's a former kgb agent. did the kgb ever formally approach you? no. nobody ever, from any russian embassy, has formally approached me — in contrast to some western countries, who were very eager to approach me. no, well, i don't mean formally — did they approach you in any way? no, i was never approached, neither formally nor informally, and this person, mr sergei shirnov, who you just quoted, let us also get here into chronological order, because there's a little bit of disorder. we attended the ecole nationale d'administration in paris in 1992 — that was the year when the soviet union was breaking apart