city's mayor would ban smoking in public parks and beachs and plasa the. the law already prohibits people from smoking in bars and restaurants. is this going too far? joining us is audrey silkg smoking saves lives and how cuargue with this new law. >> i am so glad you put that way. using second-hand smoke is an excuse. it is affecting my right to choice to smoke a legal product it is not government's role to get involved in my choice such as that. i was a police officer. i took a job that was risky, why can't i choose to smoke. i don't argue there are exaggerated risk. but they are risk. why am i -- no offensive council woman you are not in charge of my life. >> we have a constitutional right to smoke but government has a right to regulate public health. i want new york city to be healthier. 7500 die of smoke more than as and suicide . 57 percent of nonsmokers are walking out with toxics. i want to be healthy in new york. >> audrey, the council woman said it is dangerous. >> it is not. one study they are relying on. that's not how science works. you have studies before it is validated. the author himself said six feet away from the smoke it is zero. so they are choosing to