the fate of one's relationship to one's children -- i think that is what you were getting at, siobhan. similarity.werful here, on one hand, we might and harrietcelia jacobs as two very powerful narratives, both of which speak to the pervasiveness, the that is duress disproportionately visited on slave women. these are two powerful examples. but as we've seen all semester, our work is partly not to reduce all slave women, all black women to one experience, and we can appreciate the comparison the ways in which time and place and circumstances are essential to explaining how it is that , liberationedom comes by way of hiding by way of fugitive status by way of riding , in ating, and for celia sense, liberty comes through force, that club, that violent confrontation. two responses to what one might say at the core is a shared experience, and at the same time, and experience framed differently and has, as we know, vastly different outcomes. so, we are going to shift now. part of the way we have been talking about celia's case, particularly in how we compare her experience to harriet jacob