if social science one progresses or does not progress -- i'm happy to talk about that as well.e intend to be public whenever we feel that would push the issue forward. atour guest is a professor m.i.t. and his article is in science magazine and you can also find him on the m.i.t. website. maggie miller is what the hell. on theou both for being communicators. all communicators are available as podcasts. ♪ >> the house will be in order. >> for 40 years, c-span has been providing america of -- with unfiltered coverage of the congress, the white house, the supreme court and public policy events from washington and around the country so you can make up your own mind. created by cable in 1979, c-span's brought to you by your local cable or satellite provider. c-span, your unfiltered view of government. >> fbi director christopher wray and kevin mcaleenan and other officials testify on countering global threats. here's a portion of that hearing that the house homeland security committee. it's just under an hour. >> thank you, mr. chairman.

if we get access to data and hear a denial in terms of not getting access to data as a social science one either progresses i'm happy to talk about that as well and we intend to be public whenever we feel that would push the issue forward. >> host: sinan aral is a professor at mit in his article is in science magazine and you can find him on the mit website, maggie muller is with the hill. thank you both for being on "the

however, there are initiatives like social science one which is an industry academic consortium collaboration that is attempting to secure access to this type of data, political communication data, , however they are having trouble actually getting access to the data. craig silliman at buzzfeed reported in the past two weeks that not only is facebook delaying releasing the data but the finders of social science one and the projects had been approved at social sites one, they are threatening to pull out by the end of september is facebook doesn't release the data that they promised to release. facebook has responded to that and what the it said is that they are having difficulty releasing it in a timely manner because of concerns about security and privacy of the individuals data that they intend to release. this essentially brings up what i've described as a transparency paradox. what that means is that these types of platforms are facing tremendous pressure to be more open and transparent about what's happening and how they're affecting our democracy and of the things in our society, but the

what i hear from facebook is the people who are responsible for giving data to social science one are working around the clock. they have a lot of people and resources dedicated to it, but they are having trouble doing it in a timely manner. that having been said, i will say i am aware of more people, for instance at google, who have differentialing privacy, for instance, than i was ever aware of going on at facebook. it could be they are a little behind the curve on that particular front. that having been said, i don't have any inside information about their preparations, and there has not been any public declarations about, here is our plan for protecting 2020. you note in your paper that legislators need to be careful when drafting legislation, as several committees are currently working on, in order not to limit the amount of analysis that could be done on the data from social media companies. what would you recommend that lawmakers keep in mind as they come back from recess this weekend to continue pursuing this topic? guest: i have one message for lawmakers as they continue to p

think that what i hear from a spark is that the people that are responsible for giving data to social science one are working around the clock and had people and computing resources dedicated to it but having trouble doing it in a timely manner. that having been said i will say i'm aware of more people, for instance, at google who have been researching differential privacy and then i was ever aware of research going on at facebook. it could be that they are behind the curve on that particular front. that having been said i don't have inside information about their preparations and there hasn't been public declarations about here is our plan for protecting 2020. >> you note in your paper that legislators need to be careful when drafting privacy legislation as several committees on capitol hill are currently working on in order not to limit the amount of analysis that could be done on the data from social media companies. what would you recommend that lawmakers keep in mind as they come back from recess and continue to pursue this topic? >> guest: one message as they pursue regulating social me

if we get access to data and hear a denial in terms of not getting access to data as a social science one either progresses i'm happy to talk about that as well and we intend to be public whenever we feel that would push the issue forward. >> host: sinan aral is a professor at mit in his article is in science magazine and you can find him on the mit website, maggie muller is with the hill. thank you both for being on "the communicators". all communicators are available as podcasts. >> the health impeachment panels starting to release transcripts from their investigation and today it was former u.s. of exeter to ukraine, you can find the entire released transcript online at c-span .org. "after words" house intelligence committee chair adam schiff spoke to reporters in the capital about the impeachment inquiry and he told reporters of those who failed to appear would be considered further evidence of the white house obstructing congress and its impeachment probe. >> good morning. today we had additional scheduled depositions with the top lawyer for the national security council as well

robert: i missed the first thing in my prepared talk, namely that of all of the social sciences economics and finance are the worst and incorporating narratives. this is part of the figure one in the book. really to listen to these brother people like you, it is really not talked about and there are some in its increasing our attention to narratives is increasing in all of the social sciences in the document it seems obvious to me, since i was an undergrad at the university at michigan, talk about that in the preface. i did is requesting talking about narratives that will when i hear about this in my own department. spirit how does this get incorporated today. even though it should be, you see has brought. the computational modeling. robert: the federal reserve or government regulations, things like that and if you like that is their job is done. they're not going to get out in front of an audience generally, but they do sometimes. not going to get up and see you know i heard from the taxi driver such and such a theory. people are staying this and they don't do research on it. they do hav

she now works at the doctor institute of social sciences a number where she's putting kitchen raise good use. the topic enables yeah. instead of throwing trash at me it's used to produce gas and when you know demand there are benefits just as well the gas can be used to cook a lot so there's a lot of the generated from the stratosphere and the water house can also be recycled nothing is wasted by a body. when there were 5. shell who can do has been working at the institute for the past 6 years thanks to the bio guess plant has processed about a 1000 tons of food waste and generated by a gas equivalent to 2080 cylinders like this one. the money basically goes from a 37 years ago we had a huge problem because we were clueless as to how to dispose of that huge amount of food waste that was generated by the committee because no one wants to take it we used to read the leftover food in a hole in the crowd but people complained that it just made up we did not know what to do that is when some born not brought us. off by a gas line. the institute's bar gets blown it was the 1st project. which i

she now works at the daughter institute of social sciences a number where she's putting kitchen ways where you could use. the topic in a big yeah. instead of throwing trash i mean it's used to produce gas and when you know the manure benefits dries while the gas can be used to cook the one either so there's a lot of the generated from the stratosphere and the water you can also be the site of the nothing is based. you know we don't back. and there if. you can do has been working at the institute for the past 6 years thanks to her efforts to buy a guest plant has processed about a 1000 tons of food waste and generated by a gas equivalent to 2000 and b.g. cylinders like this one. basically just 7 years ago we had a huge problem because we were clueless as to how to dispose of that huge amount of food waste that was generated by the kennedy because no one wants to take it we used to buddy the leftover food in a hole in the ground it but people complained that it just made up we did not know what to do that is when some born not brought us. off by a gas line. the institute's bar gets blo

the whole of social sciences. ... >> we will also release a report on the project to pursue other initiatives as well. we have been networking with a peace building community and a put together an impressive team to organize a center for the study on destiny of traumama to translate the magazine into arabic to expand our influence into the muslim majority world and using the newsletter to take the same approach looking into western europe and canada as well in social media companies looking for their support to make sure that users are provided access for go light upon light will cover cover extremist related activity even the grassroots research in journalism and podcast and online videos and media to have content to enhance resilience with a world that has the collective non- polarizing consciousness. we have been advocating for a megovernmental focus focusing specifically on the intervention space that has public criticism of cbe and to provide an a alternative for go this as a tool to the toolbox like those with targeted interventionop to put together a proposal for next year that would l

she now works at the dot on security of social sciences in numbers where she's putting kitchen ways to where you could use. the traffic unable to get gas bearable instead of throwing trash at me it's used to produce gas and when you know the money or benefits just as well the gas can be used to cook a lot so there is a lot of the generated from the stratosphere and the water house can also be recycled nothing is wasted by a body. when there if there is a. shell who can do has been working at the institute for the past 6 years thanks to the efforts to buy a guess plant has processed about a 1000 tons of food waste and generated by a gas equivalent to 2080 cylinders like this one. the money basically just another 37 years ago we had a huge problem because we were clueless as to how to dispose of that huge amount of food west that were generated by the energy because no one wants to take it we used to buddy the leftover food in a hole in the crowd but people complained that it was made up we did not know what to do that is when some bore not brought us with this solution offered by a gas

he teaches the children social sciences. imo both. i love to go to school because i get to meet my friends there and i love spending time with them. also the teachers at the school teachers something new every day so i really like going to school. there is no medical. method then my man can get to lead my free time i like to play cricket. i also like to read. books. but man i like to write camels. and get most sometimes i also take the buffaloes out to graze on their mobile or they'd come to the mother to. say there was a time when i think pollution is the biggest problem in the world at the moment. i'm all right. pollution is farming our farmland warning for grooming. plants the crops are unable to grow properly. planned marble dioxide is increasing that men because we don't have enough plants to take it up well i think i'm. going to thank you. local television there i like how my parents and grandparents used to live there they stayed healthy they didn't get sick often they ate desi game and they drink buffalo and camel milk. camel

he teaches the children social sciences. i know both. i love to go to school because i get to meet my friends there and i love spending time with them. also the teachers at the school teach us something new every day so i really like going to school. that there is no medical. matter for them and making good to let my free time i like to play cricket. i also like to read books i read. i moved on and i like to write camels. and camel sometimes i also take the buffaloes out to graze on the moat they'd come in the mother to. them as i'm someone i think pollution is the biggest problem in the world at the moment. the. pollution is harming our farmland. ruining. our plants the crops are unable to grow properly. and landmark dioxide is increasing that c men because we don't have enough plants to take it up there isn't. going to thing. local television there i like how my parents and grandparents used to live they stayed healthy they didn't get sick often they ate desi game and they drink buffalo and camel milk. camel camel milk doesn't cost dia

medicine can help and we do have to have the terror of this modern medicine and medicine is a social science by the way and we have to see the holistic picture of climate change and what comes from and doctors have a responsibility to look at beyond what they do in their daily practice they have to look at to the conditions we live in and that is very important but our environment has been deteriorating for decades for example i'm sure my grandparents and my parents lived a healthier life than i'm leading now and that to continue but somehow the body seems to have adapted to these changes do you see that happening now the body will not adapt i mean we can protect ourselves if we have the means to do that and you'll grant parents their vote about $1000000000.00 people on earth know we are 7 so we would be $10000000000.00 people on earth so the problems are increasing and it's speeding up and we have to cope. with that and this takes more measures than what has been done 100 years ago now you have the love health summit which took this is a couple of weeks in but then climate change and its im

labyrinth they span a spectrum of techniques from computer science and engineering science to social science other forms of research so it's truly a mix methods approach honestly over the last 3 years we've been doing research on n.s.o. group or selling to you know countries with horrible track records of human rights abuses and walk of government accountability like the gulf countries like mexico rwanda targets are emerging who were tracked by death squads coming from rwanda it's like a rogues' gallery of autocrats. and so is an autocrat to dream the company keeps developing and refining its techniques from the carefully worded text messages with links that were sent to a cd back in 2018 to the much more deceptive missed call via whatsapp that was used against should branch to charlie while it is so says it conducts really good ethics checks on his client states the evidence is clear pegasus is be used against activists and journalists significantly increasing the risks associated with doing their work there's absolutely things that people can especially journalists to try and protect their

attacked by white men shouting and homophobic slurs it later turned out the incident was staged social science professor aging very low post believes that the issue of race has been politicized it's a rising immigration in europe. their main note was to highlight a question of racism injury initial sorry to now a dog doesn't excuse their disability no. learning or mainly. due soon worked on here to broaden the question ward is going on how actually if we need to start a relationship which is not race just been highlighted unbelieve decides to do a we have migration into europe it didn't seem nice due process of this only in. europe us part of one race i would say that our growth is the key concept john that's down politics today in different nations in europe. after months of political turmoil spain finally looks set to get a government with a coalition deal between the socialists and the far left but they must party close to being inked it comes just days after the country's general election delivered a highly fragmented parliament the socialists led by acting prime minister pedro sanchez and

white men shouting racial and homophobic slurs they turned out the incident was actually staged social science professor aging galloper believes that the issue of race has been politicized you tube rising immigration in europe domain name was to highlight the question of racism in finnish or sorry to now a dog doesn't excuse their disabilities are an echo not lying or mainly. due soon bottom here to broaden the question was what is going on how actually if we need to start in relation to the question of race just been highlighted on politicise today we have migration into europe it didn't feel each due process of this only. europe aspirant or one race i would say that. key concept john this down politics today in different nations in europe. only fornia has decided to spend billions of taxpayer dollars on a new high speed rail link the trains will run at almost 300 kilometers an hour critics though have pointed out some major flaws. if you're driving from los angeles to fit to bill by the time you get there you're pretty much half way to vegas so why would you stop and leave your car somewhere

attacked by white men shouting racial and homophobic slurs they turned out that incident was staged social science professor adrian grillo po believes that the issue of race has been politicized because of rising immigration in europe. domain name was to highlight a question of racism in finnish or sorry to now a dog doesn't excuse their disabilities oh look i'm not lying or mainly. due soon what i'm here to broaden the question was what is going on how actually in relation to the question of race just been highlighted on politicise today we have migration into europe it didn't feel each browser's of this only. europe aspirant or one race i would say that race is the key concept john that's down politics today in different nations in. a teenager who was injured in january by a rubber bullet fired by french riot police has suffered a setback in his quest for justice quick warning him a fine is images now disturbing incident occurred during a yellow vest demonstration the teenager's jaw was broken in claims that he was just passing by the rally and not intending to join it. however strasburg prosecu

at the same time when you look at other social science data, what you see, we're more isolated. we're more lonely. we are less likely to be members of any association. we're less likely to be members of a religious tradition. we're less likely to see ourselves as embedded in neighborhoods and communities. we are increasingly less likely to be paired. increasingly less likely to have children. if you're born of you're more likely to have a sibling than anywhere in the world. reports of loneliness are highest in history. and what we've gone it see, the lower -- rates, and suicide due to ipo addiction, and maybe of the things that matters most to human beings, ready or not we're part of something larger, whether we belong and remembered. by those, we're failing by the civilization and the argument of my book. the more it's you can is seeding. the more it's failing. and we'll read a text. what part does bigotry and racist attitudes play in dismantling liberal discourse. >> i think one of the great achievements of liberalism has been advancing the understandings of all human beings a

a white man shouting racial and homophobic slurs later turned out that incident to be staged social science professor agent grillo published that the issue of race has been politicized due to rising immigration in europe domain name was to highlight the question of racism. initial sorry to now a dog doesn't excuse their disabilities are. lying or mainly. due soon bottom here to broaden the question was what is going on how actually if we need to start in relation to the question of race just been highlighted on politicise today we have migration into europe it didn't seem nice the process of this signing in. europe us part of one race i would say that is the key concept john that's down politics today in different nations in europe. a teenager who was injured in january by a rubber bullet fired by french riot police has suffered a setback in his quest for justice a quick warning you may find these images coming up now upsetting. incident occurred during a yellow vest demonstration the teenager's jaw was broken he claims that he was just passing by the rally without actually intending to joi

white men shouting racial and homophobic slurs that later turned out the incident had been staged social science professor adrian believes the issue of race has been politicized due to rising immigration in europe their main idea was to highlight a question of racism in finnish society now i doubt doesn't excuse their disability and the kind of learning or mainly i. do see important here to broaden the question was what is going on how actually if we need to start it in relation to the question of race just being highlighted completely since today we have migration into europe it didn't seem nice there bros is all. this shiny. euro a start of one race i would say that race is sticky concept john this down politics today in different nations in europe. a teenager who was injured in january by a rubber bullet fired by french riot police has suffered a setback in his quest for justice a quick warning you may find the following images upsetting the incident occurred during a yellow bus demonstration the teenager's jaw was intact broken he claims he was just passing by the rally without intending to

our attention to narratives is the creasing in all of the social sciences as i document. it seemed obvious to me since i wasn't undergrad undergrad at the university of michigan. a talk about that. and history course he was talking about narratives. i thought well i don't hear hear about this in my own department. bangmac so how is this incorporated today. you see it's really not even though it should be. >> the team to trace the causes of things to the federal reserve or government regulations. things like that and they feel that that is her job and it is done. not going to get up in front of an audience generally. delta sometimes and they're not going to get up and see, you know i heard from the taxi driver, such and such a theory. and people are staying this. in the don't do research on this. but we do have the confidence indexes and it came in and liked 1930s with george callas. let's create a measure of confidence from a survey. if those guys had always been sacred tiered people in the econ department. we don't really believe in that. university of michigan does a co

economics is a social science. we should have a different perspective.we attempt to tackle poverty through economic theories — that simple problems beget simple solutions. the field of anti—poverty policy hais littered with the detritus of instant miracles that prove less than miraculous. isn't your approach also guilty of that, too? all these different little examples, experiments that might have worked in one place, everyone thinks "well, that is going to be a solution," then discover it doesn't apply elsewhere. well, that is the question, isn't it? we're not claiming to have any silver bullets but we're looking, if you will, for the silver pellets — you know, many little things that might work. we never — one experiment is not going to tell you, once you have done one experiment somewhere, that you have to scale up that particular approach everywhere in the world without modification or without further research. the way that it typically works is think of each of these projects as one little dot, one little data point, that helps us understand one asp

each pupil has sufficient textbooks or instruction materials in mathematics, science, history, social science and english language arts, including the english language component. each pupil has sufficient instructional materials on foreign language and health classes. that the high school have science laboratory equipment available related to the science classes. and that completes the resolution. any questions that i can answer? >> president cook: just one second. so we don't have any public comment on this? and looks like we have commissioner collins and commissioner lopez. >> so i guess i had a question, the survey, who is completing the surveys at the sites? >> usually it's someone, either the principal or the a.p. or someone in high school that might be a department lead or someone that the school site leader designates to inventory the materials. >> i guess i want to highlight, my kids -- we're moving online. a lot of content -- i think it's good because we used to have to carry 50 pounds of books in our backpacks, so moving things online is good. i'd be interested in hearing from the h

radicalization proved elusive because it imagines a mental defect but it's outside the scope of social science so there is no diagnosis available we just know that when we see it and typically looking at the radicalization model the government uses they identify first amendment protected activities police, associations and political activity are all indicators of the dangerousness down the radicalization pathway. it is a way they couldn't wait until somebody blew something up and the radicalization model provided a blueprint so according to the fbi with the radicalization document with the conversion to g hot it suggested converting to islam is the first step on this pathway and then adopting joining the muslim social group or getting involved in political activity are all indicators of increasing dangers so it wasn't that surprising we saw so much surveillance with muslim communities for no particular reason other than they were muslim american communities. >> i hope nobody here is engage in any political activity. >> in there already in the university of the notes of radicalization. to strik

that takes account of the science, of the social science of the developmental stages that the young people are at. >> my mom is a former second-grade teacher. she retired teaching almost 25 years in the chicago public schools. she can be hard on kids. that is true on a lot of teachers. especially elementary and high school. in some ways, i think they develop higher expectations of them. in the criminal law world, one idea is that the purpose of criminal law is to impose just a minimum set of standards that everybody has to follow. minimum. don't kill. don't sexually assault. don't steal. that is basic. that is part of your responsibility as a citizen. if you do not obey those minimum standards, then you should be punished. >> there are consequences. and there should be consequences i think every society has come up with rules of that nature. there should be consequences that are known by everyone and applied fairly and evenly. they are not always applied fairly and evenly. i think that the disregard and mistrust of the legal system is another factor to take into serious account. teachers w

that all takes account of the social science of the developmental stages she retired from teaching almost 25 years in the chicago public schools and she can be hard on kids. i find that is true of a lot of teachers especially elementary and high school. they develop higher expectatio expectations. but another part is just rules. in the criminal law world, one idea is that the purpose is to impose a minimum set of standards that everybody has to follow. we don't care who you are. what don't kill, don't sexually assaulted, don't steal. and bear the idea is that's part of your responsibility as a citizen. and if you don't, then you should be punished. there are consequences. >> and there should be consequences. i think every society has come up with rules of that nature and there should be consequences that are known by everyone and that are applied fairly and evenly. they are not always applied fairly and evenly. i think that the disregard and distrust of the legal system is a factor to take into account. a teacher that is tough like your mother is usually very well regarded by the students

that takes account of the science of the social science of the developmental stages that the young people are at. >> my mom is the former second-grade teacher. she retired from teaching almost 25 years in chicago public schools. she can be hard on kids. i find this true of a lot of teachers and especially elementary and high school. and in some ways, i say they develop higher expectations of them. but another part is just about rules. so in the criminal law, one idea is that the purpose of criminal law is to impose just a minimum set of standards that everybody has to follow. we don't care who you are. some minimally. don't kill. bill sexually assault, don't steal, and there the ideas that are basic. that is part of your responsibility as a citizen. and if you don't, obey the minimal standards then you should be punished. >> there are consequences. as should be consequences. in the law i say, every society has come up rules of that nature. and it should be consequences that are known by everyone. and that are applied fairly and evenly. in the not always applied fairly and evenly. i say th

reduction, intervention, counter messaging, restorative justice and rehabilitation, the whole social science or social service spectrum. finally then, going forward, now we have to advance and expand the parallel networks. we've only been up and running just publicly like upon light ecosystem for six months. we'll expanded within each of the ecosystems essential components. we will be building more research, we only have heavily embedded and oncotic with networks such as at the fodder, proud boys where ctrl-alt-del hate will be disseminated. we've already contacted several of hubs of those committees to do so. our grassroots efforts have established sufficient sizes. we were released a report on the project and pursue other initiatives as well. we will be looking to form more partnerships between the networking with the peace building community and albert have put together an impressive team that will organize the center for the study of trauma in her radicalization that we have collaborated with ideas beyond borders to translate the "ahul taqwa" magazine into arabic and to expand influence

something like 40 or 50 pages and i really gave a full social science it dissertation and schema sizingeather there is a correlation between the loophole of deception and relationship the united states has with the proxy armies and the cost of those relationships. it's not as boring as a sound sstop laughing. very serious. >> i love it. okay this comes fromay peter. the second one. do you prepare prepare for your in re is buried deep repair and with your questions in advance. >> who this really varies. i'm a big preparer. i saw you preparing for your this and it warmed my heart because study is the big preparer. >> i am. >> is right. that he has something to be proud of. just about any profession. i do a lot of prepping and preparing when i do broadcast interviews. that is a veryth different discipline if you are doing a live interview versus if you are doing a taped interview and do things like an hour with angelina jolie or something. to be a a special, you have one set of priorities. doing a if you contentious cable news interview, with a politician, is the whole mother arc that you

and something like 150 pages, is the full, social science dissertation and ischemic ties in, weatherere is a correlation between the loophole of deception relationships in the united states and with proxy armies and the cost of those relationships. has brought as boring as sounds stop laughing. [applause] is very serious. >> i love it. okay this comes from peter. how do you prepare for interviews. do you prepare and see with your questions in advance. >> this really varies. i'm a big prepare, so you preparing for this. it warms my heart because it is a big prepare. >> i am, terrible. >> is great. that is something to be found in my thinking just about any profession. i do a lot of scripting and preparing when i am doing broadcast interviews. that is a very different discipline if you doing a live interview versus if you are doing a taped interview and things like an hour with angelina jolie or something. this could be a special that you have one set of priorities. that also if you are doing contentious, cable news interview with a politician, it's a whole brother kind of art that you

the social science data, pharmacological data, testing data. it can all be done. i am a veteran of the hiv initiative in the bush administration as you are. iran the president's advisory council on hiv-aids. it is an incredibly exciting time if you are a veteran of those policy fights to see the opportunity that presents itself. to the president's credit, he saw it as well and said let's go for it and raises it repeatedly, he raises it in our hand comment how excited he is about this, how this is somebody who lived in new york city during the height of the hiv epidemic and many people around him did not live through the height of the aids crisis so the opportunity is there. it is a lot of -- we have deployed a lot of expertise, look at bob readfeel that the center for disease control, the team at hhs. we've got a lot of great people working on this and it can be done if congress appropriates the money. that is another thing we would like to see. it can be done cost-effectively and would be a huge win for public health and for the american people would transfer the

there are a lot of reasons why but this is an opportunity for the anthropologists and social sciences to do some research to show these things don't increase crime. they don't put public safety at risk and they come some people say these are too costly with no real benefit or no return on my investment or that's simply not true. this is work that my folks at hopkins published earlier this week as well looking at what the cost benefits of the service programs were in alt-a more and north lb albio. in philadelphia there's a return on investment is $234 billion per year. that's a lot of money to be used for good purposes. this is the kind of work we need money leads to power an edge we can show people the benefit to their wallet that will drive them to what you want them to do. i'm just going to note that how many are you zero are aware that las vegas has syringe vending machines? they do and that's a great thing to explore. challenges. there are always going to be community and political resistance as well as legal barriers and we also many of our services -- we were talking about the f

the lag associated with top-down social science often means the implementation of data driven interventions that are no longer appropriate in a climate that has already shifted. we first start the growth of the parallel network, and we measure engagements effectively, only once the network coalesces, and can be juxtaposed with contraction or expansion of the extremist network we seek to alter. the partnerships and consultancy is key. there's currently too much competition and not enough cveaboration in the pbe space. country of performers, victims of extremism, they all do their own things independently, but their engagement with the activity in the ecosystem allows their individual efforts to magnify. it becomes less about the individual and more about the movement. think of the way charismatic preachers and propagandists operate under the extremist brand but still become individual icons, archetypal representatives that embody the mission of their causes and organizations. "ctrl+alt+del-hate" will help us build out effective alternatives and positive messaging. that will lead to broader m

the lag associated with topdown social science often means the implementation of data-driven interventions that are no longer appropriate in a climate that has already shifted. we first start the growth of the parallel network. then measure engagements effectively only once the network coalesces and can measured against the contraction or expansion of the extremists we seek to alter. partnerships is key. there's currently too much competition and not enough collaboration in the pve/cve space. victims of extremism and shape shifters all do things independently but their engagement with the activity in the light upon light ecosystem allows their efforts to magnify. it becomes less about the individual and more about the movement. think about the way charismatic preachers and propagandists operate under extremist brands but still become individual icons, representatives that embody the mission of their respective causes and organizations. the control alt delete hate magazine helps us build out positive messaging. that messaging will lead to broader messaging and public awareness and save hate

that's for doing social sciences. ven want to do a two-year college -- the socialization that happens is really real. the idea that all of a sudden you go to harvard and you are socializing and you're networked where a majority of the jobs in the future will be based on who you know is part of it, is not small. and what you do by you're creating that, elevating that solution, you're exacerbating the problem. i think the biggest challenge is that we want to recognize that education is a public good. we want to recognize that it's a public good because it encourages you to actually be part of a solid middle class, and that solid middle class actually allows the growth that we experience in the '50s, '60s, '70s, '80s and '90s in this country that allowed for us to take advantage of the new technologies that we have today. if we separate our communities the way, you know, was suggested, we are instead moving forward, we're actually moving backwards while the rest of the world is ensuring that they have a highly educated cl