i'm sonya deermair, speaking for sierra club bay area and california. we find it appalling that san francisco is opposing the state water board's proposal to leave some water in the twalamy river. we are also appalled that the commission has not seen fit to make this an agenda item for public discussion. san francisco is allying itself with greedy agricultural interests and central valley republicans and the trump administration, which is staging a full-scale attack on california's right to determine its water future. they are spewing extreme rhetoric, demanding the right to continue draining our rivers to the bottom, to the bed, and killing fish. the sfpuc is fueling the flames with misinformation campaigns. the palliative measures that you are suggesting instead of flows, are akin to the idea that you can have a swimming pool with a leak and the water level is dropping and you're talking about adding a diving board, some waterslides, maybe lifeguards, and then maybe people will come back to swim. it's absurd. water quality control plan is a watershed