park the stair penthouse now it is not been acknowledged by any of the speakers that the stair penthouse is within the space of otherwise that is occupied by a 4 story the stair penthouse is modest in size i believe has been reduced as much as it can be and sloped so it's not that boxy structure that appeared in one of the dr requesters drawings the stairwell penthouse is not extraordinary it is a common place structure throughout the city and you know there are people that dislike them but you know a deck in san francisco is considered common place and in fact can be a permit can be obtained over the counter you have to have a stairway to reach the deck so christian can explain but you know if we're going to have decks we need a way to reach the deck as for the final speaker there was one at 140 randell mentions there are impacts to the vegetable garner but the speaker lives 3 doors away no impacts to her house i'm not sure those two are consistent in my evident i didn't hear if the dr requesters or speakers in their support that mentioned extraordinary impacts that's what we are here t

broadway rake filed a permit that include exterior modeling and property the roof deck and the stair penthouse the project sponsor removed the deck and penthouse if the scope of work it was done by hand and the department staff don't change the scope of applications they can make notes about code references but if those have to be done that i the project sponsor they could also dispassive it the penthouse were removed if the scope and sometime between 1985 and 1990 the stair penthouse and the roof deck were constructed illegal without rectify they were apparently built to the professionally architecture and engineering plans we've done some exploratory disruption to check the if i may the main thing commissioners what are before you are two site permits they're here no planning review the technicalities of the soil and co-hemorrhages maybe aren't properly discussed in this venue if you want to discuss we have a our engineer here but those are planning approval if the commission moves to beginning the beginning dbi brown will check the aspects submitted by the project sponsor and his engineers

of the verbatim rear edition be south set back by the rear property line 5 feet and the that stair penthouse includes the slope to minimize the building the rdt took a further have you and the second and third floors be set back from the west side property line in response to project sponsor set back the rear edition 6 inches from the property line subsequent r0i78d design team review meetings they've determined the project is suitable and creates no circumstances that concludes my presentation. >> first dr requester. >> i have some overhead i'm barbara thank you for hearing my dr mime husband eye will next door to the project we've praise inform taught we're not surprised the small house next door is being enlarged hopefully not to big when it was presented to our neighborhood it of the is a a concern about such a large house besides what an individual may want are the prices in the first meeting we were told it could have been bigger we live in a 1909 victorian house next to the project and you know it's obviously it's a story up with a pitched roof it as 16 hundred square feet and we're n

antoninis. >> commissioner moore. >> i'd like to architects to consider if you're not having stairs up to your penthouse you'll be arriving at the north side with the stair opening but you'll have a stair to step into to come into the roof facing the option direction and the stairs will be a 14r57bd form that opens in the center of the roof would you then be able to get a hatch based on the description what we can do we have done that on quite a few of the projects and have shares that dbi because of the cluster of space has hatches. >> if i'm understanding correctly right now we have a wrap around stair rather than wrap up that around continue the leg to the northeast so on the third floor we have an 8 foot floor plate we have let's see. >> we have over 4 feet of rice we have to make i'm going to basically cut off my hallway. >> can you relocate a stair i don't have is paper i don't know what those are can you find a way ramp the stair in the northern direction e.r. bending it in a double way to the east to get up to the roof that supports the project. >> i believe i don't have the headroom. >> could y

off-street hoa's parking has been reduced and the removal of the penthouse has occurred although the stair penthouse are - their exempt if the height limit in addition the set back previously a set back from the front building currently the fourth level has been acceptance e set back from 18.4 it's been reduced to 23 hundred square feet the upper unit from 26 to 22 hundred 20 square feet since the november 20th hearing we've received 3 letters of support from neighbors one of which was adjacent to the neighbor to the west the neighbors who commented found the proposal good the existing one was an eye sore there's one letter i received today in opposition of the project i have a copy for anyone who wishes to see them in order to proceed the commission must decide what to take discretionary review and new two family dwell structure you pursuant to the planning code that concludes my presentation. and i'm happy to answer any questions you may have. >> thank you, mr. allen is there a project sponsor or he separate. >> there is opportunity for the the project sponsor, however this matter has been heard t

broadway rake filed a permit that include exterior modeling and property the roof deck and the stair penthouse the project sponsor remo

have been in the neighborhood i'm here to speak on behavior of charley and barbie appreciate the stair penthouse hope they'll do something more than american people ordinarily house i live across the street but i really want to say i feel the impact on the back of charley and barbara's quavered is going to be significant the sun is a limited i know if they consider the 5 foot set back and develop a balcony a large opening doors they'll find that much more fundamental i've lived in the neighbor for thirty years and never seen neighbors on the decks i hope the developers will looked at this opposing to a roof deck and reduce the impacts on the backyard and neighbors basically that's what i wanted to say. >> thank you. is there any additional public comment. >> okay. seeing none project sponsor you have 10 minutes. >> good afternoon commissioner president wu and commissioners i'm david silverman working with the sponsors justin and julie onion they're proposed renovation they need more space for their family this is an owner occupied dwelling despite the allocations made by the speakers this is a m