stanton votes aye. ms. dean votes aye. ms. powell votes aye. ms. escobar votes aye. mr. collins votes no. mr. sensenbrenner votes no. mr. shabbot votes no. mr. gomer votes no. mr. jordan votes no. mr. buck votes no. mr. radcliff votes no. ms. robe votes no. mr. gaetz votes no. mr. johnson of louisiana votes no. mr. biggs votes no. mr. mcclintock votes no. ms. lesco votes no. mr. cline mr. no. mr. armstrong votes no. mr. stubie votes no. >> every member voted who wishes to vote? >> chairman, may i ask how i'm recorded? >> how is the gentleman recorded? >> mr. gomer, you're reported as no. >> i wanted to make sure. >> clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 23 ayes and 17 noes. >> the articles are agreed to. impeaching president donald j. president trump for obstructing congress. the clerk will call the roll. >> mr. nadler votes aye. ms. jackson lee votes aye. mr. cohen votes aye. mr. johnson of georgia votes aye. mr. deutsche votes aye. ms. bass votes aye. mr. richmond votes yes. mr. jeffries votes aye. m mr. swalwell votes aye. mr. lu. mr. craskin votes aye. ms. ja

stanton votes aye. mr. dean votes aye. miss my personal powell votes aye. ms. escobar votes aye. -- mr. collins votes no. mr. sensenbrenner votes no. mr. showbiz -- mr. shaaban is votes no. votes no. mr. jordan votes no. mr. buck votes no. mr. riegler's -- mr. reckless votes no. ms. robie votes no. mr. gates votes no. mr. johnson of louisiana votes no. mr. biggs votes no. mr. mcclintock votes no. miss lesko votes no. mr. rest and dollar -- russians all are votes no. r votes no.hale mr. armstrong votes no. mr. steube votes no. >> has every member who has wished to vote voted? how is the gentleman recorded? >> mr. gomer to his -- gohmert is recorded as no. mr. chairman, there are 23 ayes and 17 knows. -- no's. >> impeaching president trump for obstruction of congress. the clerk will call the roll. >> mr. nablus votes -- mr. nadler votes aye. ms. jackson lee votes aye. mr. cohen votes aye. mr. johnson of georgia votes aye . .r. deutsch votes aye ms. bass votes i -- votes aye. mr. richmond votes yes. mr. jeffries votes aye. mr. cicilline votes aye. mr. swalwell vot

stanton votes ay. ms. dean votes ay. ms. mccarthur powell votes ay. .s. escobar votes ay collins votes no. mr. sensenbrenner votes no. mr. gomer votes no. votes no. mr. jordan votes no. mr. buck votes no. mr. radcliffe votes no. ms. robie votes no. mr. gates votes no. mr. johnson of louisiana votes no. mr. biggs votes no. mr. mcclintock votes no. ms. lesko votes no. mr. klein votes no. mr. armstrong votes no. mr. steube votes no. chair nadler: is that every member of the committee who wishes to votes voted? clerical report. >> there are 23 ay's, 17 no's. the article -- chairman nadler the article is agreed to. members will have two days to submit views. the resolution will be reported as a single amendment to the nature of a substitute. without objection. >> mr. chairman. i give notice of intent to follow dissenting views. chair nadler: notice is served without objection. the committee is adjourned . [indistinct conversations] [indistinct conversations]

greg stanton, democrat of arizona, was arizona's deputy attorney general before coming to congress. and greg steube was an army jack officer. host: tracy, hello. caller: yes, i think it is a waste of money doing this. they tried to find his collusion with russia, and they did not find nothing. they want his tax records. i want to see all the other people in congress like the democrats, pelosi, and all the ones that have been there for a long time, their tax records. after you retire from congress, you get like a $174,000 pension. host: specifically why is this a waste of time? caller: i mean the democrats are like bashing trump.

elizabeth cady stanton's cousin was garrison, the antislavery philanthropist and activist.er husband was a very active career abolitionist. susan b anthony -- they actually met at an antislavery convention, these women. the story of collaboration between those movements and the emergence of the women's movement from antislavery, it is one of those really inspiring moments in the history of american activism of coalitional thinking and this multi-issue interest in freedom and justice. but as we go through the decades the book covers, it turns into one of the most appalling failures of that kind of work when, for instance, you have a figure like frederick douglass, who at the seneca falls convention of 1848, which is normally people think of that is the beginning of the women's movement, ends up being the suffrage movement, the women at that convention were ready and poised to abandon suffrage as a goal. they thought it was too out there and would make their goal ridiculous. they wanted to be able to be public authorities, they wanted equal pay for equal work, they wanted edu

stanton? >> aye. >> mr. stanton votes aye. miss dean? >> aye. >> miss dean votes aye. miss mccarsel powell? >> aye. >> miss escobar? >> aye. >> mr. collins? >> no. >> mr. collins votes no. >> mr. sensenbrenner? >> no. >> mr. sensenbrenner votes no. mr. shabbat? >> no. >> mr. shabbat votes no. mr. gomert? >> my vote is no. >> mr. gohmert votes no. mr. jordan? >> no. >> mr. jordan votes no. mr. buck? >> no. >> mr. buck votes no. mr. radcliffe? >> no. >> mr. radcliffe votes no. miss robi? >> no. >> miss roby votes no. mr. gaetz? >> no. >> mr. gaetz votes no. mr. johnson? >> no. >> mr. johnson of louisiana votes no. mr. biggs? >> no. >> mr. biggs votes no. mr. mcclintock? >> no. >> missle lesklein? >> no. >> mr. klein votes no. mr. armstrong? >> no. >> mr. armstrong votes no. mr. stuby? >> no. >> mr. stuby votes no. >> has every member voted who wishes to vote? >> chairman, may i ask how i'm recorded? >> how is the gentlemen record? >> mr. gohmert, you are recorded at "no". >> i wanted to make sure. >> the clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 23, a ayes and 17 no.

mister stanton i mister stanton but i this teen i this teen votes. aye. this week are this because of how of its eye. the sesc of our eye the best of our votes. aye. mister collins knows. mister collins, but snow. mister sensenbrenner. mister sensenbrenner votes, no. mister shavit. mister shavitz those snow. mr. gummer know. mister gohmert that snow joining. mister jordan that snow. mr. buck. mr. buck phillips now mr. reckless. mr. recess. it's now. this has. miss robey votes now. mister gates, surrogates folks now, mr. johnson of louisiana. mr. johnson of louisiana vote now. mister know. mister biggs votes, no mister mclintock's knows. mister mcclintock's that snow. this let's go now this lets go vote. no. mister mr. s and 5 hits now. mister klein knows. mister klein votes now. mister armstrong. armsrongs of snow. this terse to mister stevie votes now. every member of thcommittee who wishes to vote voters. >>the clerk will report. >>mister chairman there are 23 eyes and 17 knows the article is agreed to. >>the resution as amended is ordered deported favo

i mr stanton votes i miss teen i miss stevens i miss my car so how will i miss my car so powell that i miss escobar by this escobar but i mr collins mr collins but it's no mr sensenbrenner mr sensenbrenner it's no mr shabbat mr savage votes no mr gohmert mr gohmert votes no mr jordan mr jordan votes no mr buck mr radcliffe mr radcliffe it's no miss robey miss ruby votes no mr gates no mr gates bosso mr johnson of louisiana mr johnson of louisiana votes no mr banks. mr mcclintock oh mr mcclintock that's no miss lesko it's less give it's now mr weston dollar. mr klein mr klein votes no mr armstrong no mr armstrong that's no mr stevie mr steve events now mr chairman how my record mr biggs you are not recorded so no mr biggs that's now is every member of those who wish to vote could put. mr chairman there are $24.00 eyes and 50 no's motion table is carried missions term parliament transfer mimic a parliamentary class that is recognized it would not recognize a parliamentary inquiry at this time as the cost is regulus the 30 minutes morning chairman adler ranking member collins members of

stanton? >> no. >> mr. stanton votes no. >> ms. dean? >> no. >> ms. dean votes no. >> reporter: as the party in power, democrats blocked every effort today to pare down their charges. >> this is a travesty and sham from day one. >> no president has ever, ever, ever obstructed congress in the manner that we have seen from president trump. >> reporter: this fight over two articles of impeachment -- >> there is overwhelming evidence. >> reporter: -- highlights the almost surreal divide over basic facts. >> this is not a rifle shot impeachment with facts and evidence. this is bird shot. >> come on! get real. be serious. we know exactly what happened here. 17 witnesses. it's uncontradicted. >> they all confirm that donald trump pressured a foreign government to target an american citizen for political gain. >> reporter: president trump is accused of abuse of power and obstruction of congress. he calls it "impeachment lite." >> the president is wrong. >> reporter: madam speaker, you yourself accused him of bribery. why did you decide not to make bribery one

halek did not like lincoln, and he certainly did not like stanton. do what you are going to do, talk to me, i will take care of it. >> in context, grant is replacing halek. he is pushing him to the side. halek becomes a glorified chief of staff, a secretary, a conduit for orders from washington. there is that resentment. halek had come from the west to save the union, and he had not done it. grant comes from the west to save the union. halek is saying watch out for this snake pit. that is part of what is going on. john: that is exactly right. one thing i may disagree with slightly, halek really does not -- he does believe what is being said, but he likes the idea that he no longer has to make decisions. now he can say general grant told me to tell you to shape up. >> on my 7000 mile car trip, i stopped in starkville, mississippi, to visit good friends at the university. they took me with great pride to your center. i just have to say how marvelous it was to get this glimpse of grant. i recommend everyone to go. i think having it deep in the heart of

i mr stanton the time misty and i miss stevens i miss my car so powell i guess because of how over time miss escobar i miss ask of a time mr collins. mr collins votes no mr sensenbrenner mr savage. mr sensenbrenner votes now mr savage mr shabbath it's now mr gohmert mr gohmert but it's now mr jordan mr jordan that's now mr bach mr radcliffe mr rackley 1st now mr robey mr b. that's now mr gates no this is so they can have a press conference it means half seriously chance on the robot you know nobody asked for the straight i don't mean just spent the rope was in progress mr johnson of louisiana oh mr johnson the easy end of votes no mr banks mr big bets now mr mcclintock mr mcclintock that's now miss lescott miss let's give us now mr rationale or no mr rush entire votes now mr klein mr klein that's now mr armstrong mr armstrong that's now mr stevie mr stevie votes now is everyone voted the wish to vote cook will report. much mr chairman there are 24 eyes and 16 nose motion to. read to recess and to call the chair is a long way to spend to receive yes and how long to be out and we will sus

room, the president had a -- held a press conference including harold denton and lieutenant governor stantonnd it's on his part commending the population in the area for their careful thinking and caution in the case of the accident and praising dick thornburg, the governor. after the president left and the population or the populous knew there was not going to be an explosion, people who did leave returned to their homes, but mothers and children that had been away from their homes for a little while returned and things began to really be calm and the news reports were no longer accident meltdown, but thornburg did a great job. he was in crisis, a builder of confidence where his capacity for handling this really serious event had been so successful and approach combratd. >> once it was determined that wasn't a leak, that does did not solve the problem and it took years for engineers to determine how to fix it, but fixing and going on did take ten years and cost a billion dollars. after things calmed in harrisburg, it then behooved washington to find out what was going to go on or had gone o

elizabeth katie stanton has died but there's one woman, still surviving from the seneca falls convention, she is 102 years old, named rotta palmer, lived all her life in geneva, new york, in only two houses. but she went with her father to the seneca falls convention. he drove her in a carriage and they drove back home. and when she is 102, she is taken in a car to the polls to vote. >> as much as it pains me to jump of the gettysburg address but tell us boston the new colossus, the statue and the plaque which you say has to be understood together. >> yes. the statue of lisch was a gift to the statue of liberty was a gift to this country from france, and a gift from a particular slice of the french nation. when you wring your hands over american politics, look at france sometime and -- [laughter] -- they really have always had a tougher time than we have, but there have been reaction areas, there's been a left that's so much further left than ours, but there has always been in france from the 18th century on, a kind of centrist liberal strain which has honestly admired american republica

stanton. i yield back. >> thank youi very much. mr., i yield back to you. >> for our purposes, mr. deutsch. >> move to strike "the last word." >> gentleman istr recognized. >> thank you, mr. chairman. mr. chairman, the -- our colleague from louisiana is exactly right. it gets. confusing. it does. there is a lot that we've been talking about, which is why it's so important to always return to the facts. and i just wanted to set a couple of facts straight. we heard that we were somehow sent here, members of congress are somehow sent here to defend the president or to defend the president's policies. or -- or to defend an overturning of the status quo. i didn't really understand the suggestion because the fact is, and i think everyone on the -- everyone on our committee, everyone in america knows and needs to be reminded we're sent here to defend the constitution. and the constitutionde provides three co-equal branches of government. and when the president of the united states chooses to refuse to engage with the co-equal branch of govern

i'm a senior project architect with stanton architecture. i'm here to present some slides about the project and answer any questions that you may have. the project is located on sutter between stockton and powell street downtowns. it's a block from union square and nearby hotels such as the hampton, the marriott, and the sir francis drake. this makes it the prime location for our project, which we're proposing to demolish an existing two-story residential and office and construct a hotel with 165 guest rooms. the building programming will include a hotel lobby with bar and retail at the ground level and publicly accessible open space on the rooftop. levels 2 through 12 will have 15 guest rooms per room, with windows oriented to sutter street and toward the side property lines. the rooms themselves are small, a little less than 250 square foot each other average, but since the project is a select service hotel product in an active area, we don't anticipate the guests to spend a significant amount of time in their rooms. we're currently workin

this is at fort stanton on the southeast side. the majority of the magazines were made out of earth, reinforced with wood. in this particular instance they had german engineers come into construct this magazine. this picture was taken by me last winter. it is in immaculate condition. 150 years later. they had basic species inside, inside, these were built to last. everyone will like these images here. they not only protected the land side of the city but the river as well. they were fearful the confederate army could send shell thend shall -- city. model works in 18 three, this is one of our nps sites. this is battery rogers on the alexandria side. you have a 200 pound rifle and a 15 inch rodman gun. the rodman guns could fire a 400 pound round and penetrate. that is why these were put out. to give you an idea of how big those are, there is be right there. these guns were mounted and remounted in 1980. they were sitting on the ground. move, theso heavy to army just left them there. we came in and remounted them. let's talk about t

stanton, aye. miss dean, aye. miss mucarsel-powell, aye. miss escobar, aye. mr. collins, no. mr. sensenbrenner, no. mr. chabot, no. mr. gomer, my vote is no. mr. jordan, no. mr. buck, no. mr. ratcliffe, no. miss roby, no. mr. gaetz, no. mr. johnson of louisiana, no. mr. biggs, no. mr. mcclintock, no. miss lesko, no. mr. reschenthaler, no. mr. cline, no. mr. armstrong, no. mr. steube, no. >> has every member voted who wishes to vote? >> chairman, may i ask how i'm recorded? >> how is the gentleman recorded? >> mr. gomer you are recorded as no. >> i want to make sure. >> clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 23 ayy he is and 17 nos. >> the article is agreed to. article two. clerk call the roll, obstructing justice. >> mr. nadler, no. miss -- -- -- aye, lofgren, aye, mr. cohen, aye. mr. johnson of georgia, aye. mr. deutsch, aye. miss bass, aye. mr. richmond, yes. mr. jeffries, aye. mr. cicilline, aye. mr. swalwell, aye. mr. lieu. mr. raskin, aye. miss jia paul, aye. miss demings, aye. mr. correa, yes. miss scanlon, aye. miss garcia, aye. mr. neguse, aye. miss mcbath, aye. mr

that was founded by anthony and stanton. they did not support the 15th amendment and focused their work from that point onward to fighting for a constitutional amendment that would give women the right to vote. here we have a petition from the american woman suffrage association, which was founded by lucy stone, her husband, and other suffragists. they did support the 15th amendment. however, they focused their efforts on winning women the right to vote at the state and local level. they weren't necessarily opposed to a constitutional amendment giving women the right to vote. however, they didn't really feel that it was -- they weren't very optimistic at the success of a constitutional amendment at this point in time. so one of the really fascinating things about the women's suffrage movement is that after women lost the vote in new jersey in 1807, the first states to give women the right to vote beginning in 1869 were in the west. wyoming territory was the first state -- territory at that point in time -- to give women the

stanton.h reference has been played to the transcript and i use air quotes, because it's not an official transcript. i want to remind everyone, that this was a document provided to us by the white house with el ellipses in the document and we don't know exactly what's wa stated because it is not an official document. much has been made also about this idea of the use of, do us a favor. as though the united states of america and foreign policy experts and state department experts were clamoring to get information on barisma, or information on hunter biden or joe biden. we heard from mr. goldman last week, and i asked him specifically if his committees had investigated that claim, that there was some legitimate concern by the government about corruption regarding barisma, and he said they thoroughly investigated it and found absolutely no evidence. mr. trump is welcome to be here. he was welcome to be here. he was welcome to participate. his lawyers. so that if he has any information that would

stanton votes aye. ms. dean votes aye. ms. escobar votes aye. mr. collins votes no. mr. sensenbrenner votes no. mr. gomer votes no.. mr. jordan votes no.. mr. buck. mr. ratcliffe notes no. ms. roby votes no. mr. gates votes no. >> mr. johnson of louisiana votes no. mr. biggs. mr. mcclintock votes no.. mr. cline votes no. mr. armstrong votes no. mr. steube votes no. >> mr. chairman, how am i recorded? >> mr. bigs, you are not recorded. i said no. >> mr. biggs votes no. >> has every member voted who wishes to vote? the clerk will report. mr. chairman, there are 24 ayes and 14 nos. >> may i make a parliamentary inquiry. >> i will not recognize a parliamentary inquiry at this time. >> good morning, chairman nadler and members of the committee and staff. my name is steve castor, i serve with ther, oversight committee the republican staff with mr. jordan. i'm also for purposes of this investigation, i'm a shared staffer with the judiciary committee and mr. collins, and the house permanent select committee on intelligence and mr. nunes. it sure is a. >> to

all things considered, it is a positive and mostly drew stanton us kuo for apple because of the tradeeal. >> we knew they weren't going to pass on the extra $150 to the consumer. they were likely going to eat the cost. were they pressuring the suppliers to avoid the impact on some of their own financials. how was apple maneuvering around this? >> historically in terms of tariffs, it applies to the apple watch, ipods and homepods as well. they have raised the prices on some of them. there is a more expensive tie tan yum tier and gives back on the margin side for them. then you have the air pods pro, which is $90 more expensive. they are expanding the lines, wanting to get improved margins from the supplier side but actually keeping the prices mostly the same for the consumer. i feel like if they have raised prices on the consumer side, what the customers are paying for, that would be a bigger hit than from margins being hit from the friffs in the first place sticking to those prices is important. >> mark, we do know this is temporary, and we would be waiting for an indefinite delay in

stanton? >> no. >> mr. stanton votes no. >> no. >> miss mccarsel powell? >> no. >> miss mccarsel powell votes no. >> miss escobar votes no. >> mr. collins votes aye. >> mr. sensenbrenner votes aye. >> mr. chabot? >> mr. chabot votes aye. >> mr. gohmert votes aye. >> mr. buck? mr. buck votes aye. >> mr. ratcliffe votes yes. >> miss roby votes aye. >> mr. gates? >> mr. gates votes aye. >> mr. johnson of louisiana? >> aye. >> mr. johnson of louisiana votes aye. >> mr. biggs? >> mr. biggs votes aye. >> mr. mcclintock votes aye. >> miss lesko votes aye. >> mr. klein votes aye. >> mr. armstrong votes yes. >> mr. stuby votes yes. >> has every member voted who wishes to vote? the clerk will report. mr. chairman there are 17 ayes and, nos. >> what purpose does mr. jordan seek? >> i have an amendment at the desk. >> i have a point of order. >> the clerk will report the amendment. >> amendment to the amendment in the nature of a substitute hres 755 offered by mr. jordan of ohio, page 4, strike line 23 and all that follows through page 5 line 5, page 8 strike lines 10

stanton? >> no. >> mr. stanton votes no. ms. dean? >> no. >> miss dean votes no. miss mucarsel-power votes no. mr. sensabaugh votes aye. mr. chapot votes aye. mr. gohmert votes yes. mr. buck votes aye. mr. ratcliffe? yes. ms. roby votes aye. mr. gaetz votes aye. mr. johnson of louisiana votes aye. mr. biggs votes aye. mr. mcclintock votes aye. ms. lesko votes aye. mr. reschenthaler votes aye. mr. cline votes aye. ms. armstrong votes yes. >> any members wish to vote who haven't voted? the clerkve will report. >> mr. richmond, you are not recorded. >> no. >> mr. richmond votes no. >> ared there any other member who haven't voted who wish to vote? the clerk will report.

stanton. there has been much reference made to the transcript and i use air quotes because it's not an official transcript process. i want to remind everyone this was a document provided to us by the white house with elipses in the document and we don't know what was stated because it's not an official document. much has been made about the idea of the use of "do us a favor" as though the united states of america and foreign policy experts and state department experts were clamoring to get information on burisma or information on hunter biden or joe biden. we heard from mr. goldman last week -- and i asked him specifically -- if his committees had investigated that claim, that there was some legitimate concern by the government about corruption regarding burisma. and he said they thoroughly investigated it and found absolutely no evidence. mr. trump is welcome to be here. he was welcome to be here. he was welcome to participate, his lawyers, so that if he has any information that would exonera

stanton. >> aye, mr. stanton votes ay. >> ms. dean. >> aye. >> ms. escobar. >> aye. >> mr. collins? >> nope. >> mr. collins votes note. >> mr. stenson berner votes no. >> mr. sabot votes no. >> mr. jordan votes no. >> mr. buck? >> mr. radcliffe? mr. radcliffe votes no. >> ms. roby votes no. >> mr. gates votes no. mr. johnson of louisiana. >> no. >> mr. johnson of louisiana votes no. mr. bigs. >> mr. mcclintok votes no. >> ms. lesco votes no. >> mr. kline. >> no. >> mr. kline votes no. mr. armstrong. >> no. >> mr. armstrong votes no. >> mr. stuby votes no. >> how am i recorded? >> mr. bigs you are not recorded. >> i said no. >> mr. bigs votes no. >> every member vote who had wishes to vote? the clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, 24 aye and 15 no. >> parliamentary inquiry? >> mr. caster is recognized. i will not recognize parliamentary inquiry at this time. >> good morning, chairman nadler, ranking member collinss and members of the staff. my name is steve caster. i'm a congressional staff member. i served with the oversight committee on the republican staff with mr. jordan. i'm also

stanton? mr. stanton votes no. ms. powell? ms. powell votes no. ms. escobar? ms. escobar votes no. mr. collins? mr. collins votes aye. mr. chabot? mr. chabot votes aye. mr. gohmert ? mr. gohmert votes aye. mr. ratcliffe? >> yes. >> mr. ratcliffe votes yes. mr. gates? mr. gates votes aye. mr. johnson of louisiana? mr. johnson of louisiana votes aye. mr. biggs? mr. biggs votes aye. mr. mcclintock? ms. lesgo? mr. klein? >> aye. >> mr. klein votes aye. mr. armstrong? >> yes. >> mr. armstrong votes yes. mr. stubey? >> yes. >> is everyone voted who wishes to vote? >> mr. correa, you are not recorded. mr. correa votes no. >> anyone else who wishes to vote who hasn't voted? the clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 17 ayes and 23 noes. >> the amendment is not agreed to. any further amendments in the ame amendment in the nature of a substitute? >> mr. chairman, i have an amendment at the desk. >> amendment at the desk. the clerk will report. >> amendment to the amendment in the nature of a substitute to h 755. >> gentle lady reserves a point of order. >> page five beginning on line

stanton? >> no. >> mr. stanton votes no. ms. steen votes no. ms. powell votes no. ms. escobar votes no. mr. collins? >> aye. >> mr. collins votes aye. mr. sensen burner votes aye. mr. chabot votes

. >> stanton? >> aye. >> dean? >> aye. >> powell? >> aye. >> escobar? >> aye. >> collins? >> no. >> sensenbrenner? >> no. >> shavit? >> no. >> gohmert? >> my vote is no. >> jordan? >> no. >> buck? >> no. >> radcliffe? >> no. >> robi? >> no. >> gates? >> no. >> johnson of l la? >> no. >> biggs? >> no. >> mcclintock? >> no. >> lesko? >> no. >> rushen thalor? >> no. >> klein? >> no. >> armstrong? >> no. >> stuby? >> no. >> is every member voted who wishes to vote? >> chairman, may i ask if i'm recorded? >> how's the gentleman recorded? >> gohmert, no. >> i want to make sure. >> the clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 23 ayes and 17 noes. >> the article is agreed to. the question now is on article ii of resolution. impeaching president donald j. trump for obstructing congress. the clerk will call the roll. >> nadler? >> aye. >> lofgren? >> aye. >> jackson-lee? >> aye. >> cohen? >> aye. >> johnon of georgia? >> aye. >> deutsch? >> aye. >> bass? >> aye. >> richmond? >> yes. >> jeffreys? >> aye. >> sicilyny? >> aye. >> swalwell? >> aye. >> liu? rasken? >> aye. >> chiapa

stanton? >> no. >> mr.. stanton votes no. ms. steen? >> no. >> ms. steen votes no. ms. escobar? >> no. >> ms.ba escobar votes no. mr. collins? >> aye. >> mr. collins votes aye. mr. shabbot? mr. shabbot votes aye. mr. gohmert ? mr. gohmert aye. mr. jordan votes yes. platfo mr. buck? mr. buck votes aye. mr. ratcliffe? mr. clratcliffe votes yes. mr. gates? mr. gates votes aye. mr. johnson of louisiana? mr. johnson of louisiana votes aye. mr. biggs? mr. biggs votes aye. ms. lesgo? ms. lesgo votes aye. mr. klein? >> aye. >> mr. klein votes aye. mr. armstrong? >> yes. >> mr. armstrong votes yes. >> the clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 17 ayes and 23 noes. >> the amendment is not agreed to. >> mr. chairman. >> who seeks recognition? for what purpose does mr. biggs seek recognition? >> i have amendment at the desk. >> the clerk will report the amendment. >> amendment to the amendment. >> i reserve a point of order. >> gentle lady reserves a point of order. the gentleman is recognized to explain his amendment. >> is she going to read the amendment, sir? >> the clerk will rea

amen toted to say a big brother stanton. his blog, youknow should. it is indispensable.ne of our partners in crime who is not in the room at the moment, a professor. i wanted to mention him because his work on the north korea-middle east connection, absolutely indispensable. we have talked about russia, china. you do talk about the middle states andhe terror organizations and their financial support for north korea is something which flies under the radar screen of those of us who work only with open sources. let me give you an indication of how important this is to the toeat being mobilized incinerate san francisco and washington, d.c. from pyongyang. korea's2012 when north currency was still in freefall, signed a and tehran scientific cooperation agreement in september of 2012. six weeks later after 10 years of freefall, north korea's currency suddenly stabilized. what happened in the six weeks after the tehran-pyongyang scientific cooperation agreement? i am sure it was not cooperation on life sciences. my guess is, there was technology going from one country, and fin

stanton? >> no. >> mr. stanton votes no. ms. steen votes no. ms. powell votes no. ms. escobar votes no. mr. collins? >> aye. >> mr. collins votes aye. mr. sensen burner votes aye. mr. chabot votes aye. mr. gohmert? >> aye. >> mr. gohmert votes aye. mr. jordan votes yes. mr. buck? >> yes. >> mr. buck votes yes. mr. ratcliffe? >> yes. >> mr. ratcliffe votes yes. ms. roby votes aye. mr. gaetz votes aye. mr. johnson from louisiana? >> aye. >> mr. johnson of louisiana votes aye. mr. biggs? mr. biggs votes aye. mr. mcclintock votes aye. ms. lesko votes aye. mr. reschenthaler votes aye. mr. cline votes aye. mr. armstrong votes yes. mr. stuby votes yes. >> are there any members of the committee who wish to vote who haven't voted? the clerk will report. >> mr. chairman, there are 17 ayes and 23 nos. >> then the amendment is not agreed to. the committee will now stand in recess for half an hour. >> good evening. you are watching the house judiciary committee debating the impeachment articles before voting. there was just a roll call vote on a republican introduced amendment. it

stanton. ms. dean? ms. powell? ms. escobar. mr. collins. mr. senseson brenner. mr. gomer, mr. jordan. mr. buck, mr. radcliff. mr. gates? mr. johnson of louisiana? mr. biggs? mr. mcclintock. mr. cline? mr. armstrong. mr. stubie? >> has everyone voted who wishes to vote? >> ms. bass votes aye. >> clerk will report. >> 24 ayes and 17 noes. the motion to table is agreed to. >> i have a parliamentary inquiry. >> gentleman will state his parliamentary inquiry. >> the impeachment inquiry procedures states that members of the committee can raise objections relating to the admissibility of testimony in evidence. but it doesn't say what rules apply to admissibility. so i'm hoping you can explain to us what objections may be made under this clause and if you intend to use the federal rules of evidence -- >> the gentleman will suspend. that's not a proper parliamentary inquiry. >> it is. >> it is not. >> i stated a rule -- >> stated a rule, you can ignore it and not answer it, you can't say -- >> i'm asking for the application of the rule for an explanation. >> you will apply the rules, p

stanton? mr. stanton votes. no list? in misty in both. snow is mucarsel-powell? as mucarsel-powell votes. no miss escobar votes. now mr. collins? mr. collins votes. i mr.

stanton. ms. dean? ms. powell? ms. escobar. mr. collins. mr. senseson brenner. mr. gomer, mr. jordan. mr. buck, mr. radcliff. mr. gates? mr. johnson of louisiana? mr. biggs? mr. mcclintock. mr. cline? mr. armstrong. mr. stubie? >> has everyone voted who wishes to vote? >> ms. bass votes aye. >> clerk will report. >> 24 ayes and 17 noes. the motion to table is agreed to. >> i have a parliamentary inquiry. >> gentleman will state his parliamentary inquiry. >> the impeachment inquiry procedures states that members of the committee can raise objections relating to the admissibility of testimony in evidence. but it doesn't say what rules apply to admissibility. so i'm hoping you can explain to us what objections may be made under this clause and if you intend to use the federal rules of evidence -- >> the gentleman will suspend. that's not a proper parliamentary inquiry. >> it is. >> it is not. >> i stated a rule -- >> stated a rule, you can ignore it and not answer it, you can't say -- >> i'm asking for the application of the rule for an explanation. >> you will apply the rules, p

trying to do the easiest way probably of making a trade deal within this 11 month period the bar stanton said himself is actually to remain really aligned to the rules and to remain a sort of rule take for the. ruled out in the campaign but it may be the only way to get a trade deal over the line is to have something a lot like the sort of breaks in the labor's talking about during this campaign rather than the sort of canada. it's been talking about since 2006 i make my statement as well as all that the scottish government will now i just hate even more strongly for another referendum on leaving the u.k. in staying in the european union and bitterness in northern ireland towards johnson's deal has soured relations hugely all in all 2020 promises to be not the end of the brics it story is johnson suggests but just another fork in the road. ok self promise you some more on the on the car crash that has turned out to be jeremy colvin's campaign he gave his speech when he when he sings in north london insults about having a period of quiet reflection before working out what to do next up ac

stanton, mr. steen, miss steen, miss mccar sill powell, miss escobar, no. >> mr. collins, mr. sense inburner, mr. shabbat, mr. gome ert, mr. gome ert, mr. jordon, mr. buck, mr. buck, mr. rat clifr, miss roby, mr. gates, mr. gates, mr. johnson of louisiana, mr. bigs, mr. bigs, mr. mcclintock, miss lesko, mr. rushenthauler, mr. kline, mr. armstrong, mr. arm strong, mr. stuby. >> has everyone voted who wishes to vote? the clerk will report. >> there are 24 ayes and 17 nos. >> the moigs to table is adopted. i recognize professor karlan for her testimony. >> mr. chairman and members of the committee, thank you so much for the opportunity to testify. twice i have had the privilege of representing this committee and its leadership in voting rights cases before the supreme court. once when it was under the leadership of chairman senson brenner and it's good to see you again and with mr. shabbat as one of my other clients and once under the leadership of chairman conyers. it was a great honor for me to represent this committee because of this committee's key role over the past 50 years