second quarter, now 2.2%, those are down -- >> steve are you shocked gdp saw that big of a revision third time around the block? >> i'll not because jim o'sullivanas right. rick, did you see was it sales or demand? >> i haven't had a chance to comb through and not saying, mr. sullivan, my hat's off to him if he predicted it. i'm questioning that it's just a significant percentage revision after we should have tightened up and seen all the final durables and all the final inventories. >> rick, you and i argue about macro things and the great thing about us is let's not get hung up on tenths. i don't know if it was 1.8 or 1.7 i'd argue this is a strong economy. >> but if it revved up to 3% we'd all be talking about it a whole lot more. >> exactly but now it's down to 1.3 it's still a weak economy just like it was at 1.7. >> steve, you know what? this is wonderful because for viewers that don't like to go into the weeds with data, things like gdp, retail sales, durable goods, these are big, lofty numbers, and my opinion, we could talk about the nuances of qe3, we could talk about how the central bankers are going to save the world, but truly, no ma