and as i said as i think about emie and susan herriman and ilean hansen. >> and dorothy. i have learned that it is so remarkable to create this strange situation in which we can't talk to each other outside and we try to be wise to

and as i said as i think about emie and susan herriman and ilean hansen. >> and dorothy. i have learned that it is so remarkable to create this strange situation in which we can't talk to each other outside and we try to be wise to use your word and just coming together once a month to do in public what people in other processes get to debate in private and yet somehow we have done it respectfully and thoughtfully and everybody on the commission has been really committed to these values each when we disagreed about particular items i have felt a sense of good faith. so 6 years ago, 6 years and 3 months ago i didn't and five months. i don't think that i know how much time it will take, and i did speak about the billing was not quite accurate but i am glad to have served and i wish you all of the best and happy to help any of you or this who process going forward if i can. but, the time has come to let somebody else have this chance, and i just want to thank all of you and jack, i feel the same way that i have learned a great deal from working with you and everybody involve