thank you we have a couple questions one from president swigz swig. the reason you near rehear suggest it was identified this is manifest injustice because the you feel the dt sd got more time to speak than you did. >> the appellate did. >> they got more time to speak the important issues many were. >> excuse me that was the answer. . upon my review and i have the luxury of being able to sit in front of my computer and see it over and over fimented to. the reason than i received more time is not because they were offered more time. but because the commissioners rightfully asked questions because the commissionersmented more information. which would inform them as to make a proper decisions. so why -- that is the reason of the dtse had more actual time the commissioners were asking them questions not buzz this commission offered them in some proprietor fashion. or priority fashion, sorry. the time. so where is the manifest injustice if the commissioners, trying to do the best possible job than i could, for all sides, including the public who is in the