situation in dynamics exactly by quarters, and if we take the year 2023 in terms of quarters, and even tantarrms this, then starting from the first to the second and... the third quarter the shadow is the opposite decreased, there was an increase in white sales, there was a quarter-on-quarter increase in taxes and , accordingly, sales, and... and production as well , well, for example, white sales grew , the first quarter is 25.5 billion in white sales of tobacco products, the second quarter already uah 30 billion, the third quarter - uah 34 billion, and only after the end of the third quarter, with the beginning of the fourth quarter, the number of white sales began to decrease sharply, and accordingly, the payment of taxes and , accordingly, production . from time to time in various regions, underground shops, well , they report this to the public, but what prompted the fact that white sales, you say, are falling, and the shadow, on the contrary, began to grow in the last month? we thought for a long time about all possible factors, and we, as analytical centers, as an expert environment, h

take off the bread, tantar, it’s not me, stop the market, dystrophic, it doesn’t affect me, mamay, iditor-in-chief, in principle, approved the topic, but before writing the article, i need to clarify some details, weeks, what do you want from the article, what is your goal? i want the country's leadership to know our success? you do not devoid of ambition, i see, but what do these ambitions have to do with it? i just want the officials from the ministry not to interfere with our work, they interfere with you, i can’t put a toilet on the site. without their permission, that is, you want even more freedom for your artel , not only for the individual, everyone needs freedom, you, including, i want to give people the opportunity to work and earn a lot, but honestly, then maybe we will build communism, capitalism you wanted to say, i said what i wanted to say, such an article will not be missed, but i won’t write it, it’s a waste of time, maybe they’ll let you in after all, okay, i’ll come to your mine, but there’s one condition, whether you like it or not, i’ll write the truth about what