now we are adding taras zhovtenko, an expert on international security, to our conversation democratic initiative fund. mr. taras, welcome to our air. greetings, have a good day. and about avdiivka, of course, we will first of all ask. our garrison came out, our boys came out, and there are many questions now, in particular, it is important to analyze, yes, whether they used all, all of ours. previous experience, all knowledge, all, all possible experience and of our partners, in order to work out this audi operation as best as possible, as efficiently as possible, with the least losses, yes, because now the united states is also shouting that on the one hand bauer says that, well, not like that already big the loss of avdiyivka, because the city was destroyed and the russians won not so much, the main thing is that the ukrainian fighters left, and they are throwing accusations, it is because of you. because you did not give ammunition, such a situation happened, and we in ukraine, how can we evaluate it? well, we have to remember that in reality, since we are at war with an enemy that