david rohode, also goldie taylo and former congressman patrick murphy, an msnbc contributor and firsteteran of the iraq war to serve in congress. we talk about those strong statements that came out today, one from the u.s. state department says the united states is appalled by today's disgraceful shelling outside of that school in rafa. patrick, let me start with you. what do you make of the two statements today and either one of these strong statements going to change calculations for israel? >> i think skaisrael will take step back. they will pause and you're seeing some troop withdrawal from the gaza right now there. but i will say to you, t.j., and goldie can tell you this as a marine, and david could tell you this as an investigators. war is messy, and those two or three militants that were on the motorcycle that were targeted from the air strike, you know, israel has a right to self-defense. now, that doesn't excuse they were shot down outside the school but we don't know the facts and if they were lobbing artillery shells and putting israelis in harm's way and trying to use the