because you can't just open up the data. you have to do things like this, where you get the community together or you have people actually talking about it because the demand side, as we were talking about it, will be there because there is going to be someone there. there have to be people working with it who are getting out there. i think this is what this city is going to be really powerful. in terms of other cities doing as well, chicago is doing some really interesting stuff. scary cool stuff. they're taking 3 in 1 data, pothole request and crime report and matching it up with social media. they're getting this really deep and rich picture of what is going on in the city. and you can do that with data when you think about it creatively. philadelphia as i mentioned, they are really active in open data. and new york, again with 3 in 1 is doing smart analytics. i think that's what you'll see happening as well, government starts to become smarter, make better decisions, better policies. this term algorithmic regulation, whic

i talk about some of the data sets we use. most people still don't know they exist despite great efforts from the city and others. and, you know, a lot of entrepreneurs that we're looking for is the way to get leverage, a way to build an experience or build a product before we have 100,000 users using it. open data is the key way to do that. you can start out with this experience, very lively and robust with very few users. and then when the first users come in, there is actually something for them to do and see. and i think that you'll start to see as the data sets get more robust and a little bit better and hopefully as we get to improve them ourselves and put them back into the public domain, the innovation that comes off with them is just going to grow exponentially. >> this seems like a really important moment. the world of civic innovation until now has really been focused on sort of open public data and the private data world has been separate. the fact that the city realizes that it is private data that adds to that and

more specifically, the e.u. data protection reform should ensure that the european union is able to in particular situations such as the prism program through its data protection rules with a clear vision of territorial scope. non-european companies when offering goods and services to european consumers will have to apply the e.u. data protection law, a broad definition of data, clear responsibilities for processors and strong rules for international transfers. the proposed general protection regulation reflects our view that in order to avoid -- access by third country law enforcement authorities to the personal data of e.u. citizens held on the servers of u.s. companies should be done via establishing terminals such as the e.u.-u.s. mutual assistance agreements. the european parliament has submitted amendments to further clarify in the provisions the conditions under which the judgment of a tribunal of a third country is enforceable under e.u. law. the commission will look at these proposals. madam president the co

here we have data from the city. we also have data from private data sources that read -- not going to mess with it. there's one of the variables now, the bottom you see there is median household income. we're pulling in all these different data sources, creating a beautiful visualization to tell a story at the neighborv level of how the city is growing. and some of the things you're seeing on the map here are a pipeline of information about both residential permits over the past decade or so, how has the city allocated permits throughout different neighborhoods in the city. and some of the other things you're seeing on the map is the approved businesses, the businesses are currently doing business in the city. one of the things we said once we started visualizing on the map the slow and more rapid growth of residential -- residential property in soma and then in 2011 you just saw obviously a huge residential boom in the downtown area. so, we've just actually -- we're a company in southern california. we just relocate

and in guest it into the system and pair that data to the voter file data. >> people find something creepy about this much data out there about them and used in a political campaign. >> at the end of the day you get e-mails sent to your house all the time. you didn't know the person that sent them to you and they still know he your name. if i say hi pete they are is barack obama that might be jarring. freak you out. just a difference? or are concern about them enveteran's stadiuming your life. >> give me an scam of a program. >> we aired stuff on like judge judy. >> they were running shows on 60 different cable stations and romney was running them on 15 different cable stations. >> patrick is a republican consultant preaching to his party for years about the political power of data. >> i don't think it as question of behind. i think it is a question of almost on two different planets. karl rove is a fox news contributor and former deputy white house chief of staff who was also close to the romneyca. >> the democrats have a big advantage on this. both sides microtargetted. the democr

they hold the data from the american citizen. >> we don't hold data they take civil liberties and privacyn securing this nation. so when people just throw out oh they are going to have all of this stuff at the data center that's balloon knee. that's ludicrous. i am not going to come out and say here's what we are doing in utah. that would be ridiculous, too. it would give add ver terries a great advantage. >> this is about the possibility the government's stunning new capacity to collect store and analyze data would have less than noble leaders if not now than in the future. >> it is a turnkey situation and back totalitarian state pretty quickly. the capacity to do that is there. >> life bliberty and the pursui of happiness are there all of the time. the people we ask american people how much more do you want me to do? >> what should a government computer know and how can it know it? with the nsa we go to silicon valley for answers. a little later how many of you have an iphone or android or galaxy put up your hand. >> teaching kids how not to ruin their lives with a smart phone. {off-lin

and in guest it into the system and pair that data to the voter file data. >> people find somethingreepy about this much data out there about them and used in a political campaign. >> at the end of the day you get e-mails sent to your house all the time. you didn't know the person that sent them to you and they still know he your name. if i say hi pete they are is barack obama that might be jarring. freak you out. just a difference? or are concern about them enveteran's stadiuming your life. >> give me an scam of a program. >> we aired stuff on like judge judy. >> they were running shows on 60 different cable stations and romney was running them on 15 different cable stations. >> patrick is a republican consultant preaching to his party for years about the political power of data. >> i don't think it as question of behind. i think it is a question of almost on two different planets. karl rove is a fox news contributor and former deputy white house chief of staff who was also close to the romney campaign. >> the democrats have a big advantage on this. both sides microtargetted. the d

this is the application to acquire the data. is here i have my verizon phone, my cell phone. what authorized investigation gave you the grounds for acquiring my credit card data? -- my cell phone data?

data? >> i am aware of no one who has broken the law in obtaining this data. there are other issues with the leaks that have gone on here. >> based on everything we have heard today, do you see any problems with 702 or 215 that you think should be changed by this body? >> not right now. but this is something we agreed we would look at, especially the structure of how we would do that. we are looking at all of the key points. what we have to bring back to you is the agility. how we do it in the oversight. are there other ways we can do this? but at the end of the day, we need these tools, and we have to figure out the right way, from my perspective, this court and the body do oversight. i think the american people would agree, that what we are doing is the right way. so those are the steps that we will go back and look at the architecture. that is a commitment that n.s.a. has made to this administration and this committee. >> final question, what's next for mr. snowden that we can expect? >> justice. >> i yield back, mr. chairman, thank you. >> thank you, mr. ch

at work in the civilian data. again these are not age-adjusted so you would want to age adjust them to make the mark operable to the military but there likely is differences between the military and civilian world and work/home leisure activities depending on where the person is living and working especially in the military so that is something that would be worth exploring. also with regard to the military, the activity, 41% having worked duty hours. the question is what is it mean when you are in combat and deployed in that sort of thing? how long does that work they expand? it's not clear from the day that would be a worthwhile issue to pursue to better understand the risk and the exposure that the individuals have. so this gives us, the next slide gives us a context for understanding rape sexual assault reporting to police in connection with other violent crimes and i think the the big take away messages message cures for other violent crimes, serious violent crimes robbery aggravateaggravated assaultassaults,

so for the fbi, the uniform crime reporting program data, and those were the data i present, but if you're interested, i will have you gain those data. , they are frome local police, there from campus, campus police included in those data, state police, county police, so they are all different police organizations that are included in those data. so depending on where the ,ictim, or whoever is making reporting to the police, making unknown to police -- it could be through the campus police. it also depends on their relationship with municipal police. there might be certain things that is reported to campus police, but the name melissa paul -- but then the municipal police takeover. >> ok, thank you. >> thank you very much for your presentation. just a couple of questions. first of all, if someone were to massage the data or suggested be done, what kind of task with at the? how long would it take for the narrative that you mentioned exists to be analyzed and reported on? are we talking about a 10 year job, two months, push a computer button and get it in a second? what are we talking about?

more specifically, the e.u. dataprotection reform should ensure that the european union is able to take in situation such as the prison program through its data protection rules that they clear provision of territorial scope. non-european companies when offering could and services to european consumers will have to apply the e.u. data protection law and foot a broad definition of personal data, career responsibilities for processors and strong international transfers. reciting the proposed general protection integration reflects our view that in order to avoid conflicts of jurisdiction, access by your country law enforcement authorities to the personal data of e.u. citizen held on the servers of u.s. government should be done via established generals such as the e.u. u.s. mutual legal assistance agreement. the european parliament has submitted an ends to further clarify provisions of the regulation the conditions under which the judgment of a court or tribunal is enforceable under e.u. law. the commission was like th

we data mine, we're teaching the computer how to go through large amounts of data. >> reporter: gary l founded sip fon i can, one of the most experienced players in the data mining game, it was recently acquired by ernst and young. >> i am using a tool, this collects information on things like twitter. >> reporter: a big part of what angel does deals with scanning the web and analyzing data, not unlike what government agencies try to do. sift through the noise of all of the world's electronic communication, isolate fragments of troubling data, then connect those dots before a threat materializes. recent revelations show they're pushing to expand capacity to do it. >> what would surprise people most about data mining, what don't they know. >> how clumsy it is, how much work goes into getting simple conclusions from the data. there's a sense that computers can do far more than they actually can. >> reporter: the biggest challenge isn't collecting and storing the information, it is making sense of it all. >> i picked a selection of terms that a national security person might be intereste

there are certain differences between the ncvs data and the military data. the wgra data. probably the largest one is the scope of what's included. in civilian data, we're looking at sexual violence, which is basically completed, attempted and threatened, rape and sexual assault. but the military data also includes in addition to that are the nonconsensual sexual touching, those types of fondling incidents can be included, but what the wtra survey does is it explicitly screens for that. so it asks people about that. you might get more accounts of that. i think that is reflected a bit in this data where you have about 1/3 of the incidents reported are the nonconsensual touching. about 25% are attempts for xual intercourse, oral or anal sex and 1/3 are completed sex, oral and anal sex. the military survey was a web search. an in person telephone survey. again, it is not -- it is not that one is better or worse. there is just differences that can affect the data that are obtained. he web-based is probably there is a lower response rate. they tend to have a lower response rate

the data reports in tracking. we've made some leaps forward in terms of the collection of data. we now have it in place so the district stations report on line. and that is reported back to them so they see what's taken place. we're to input the data for enforcement so the lieutenants know exactly what is take place or not taking place. and as opposed to a data entry clerk just for that task. the leaders need to know what's going on and they see the types of citations and the locations where the sieksz are being issued. one of the things i want to point out one year to date we're hoping to see a continued decrease in pedestrian injuries. unfortunately, we are at 8 pedestrian facility year to date. we're going to increase our efforts to make sure we don't surpass last year. i mentioned the crossroads and how the department is issuing citations to handheld devises. we are having the devises programmed so there is a pedestrian a bike motorist box when you printout the citation so it shows exactly what is it and the court are excited because the prints are bigger. and they're more ex

more specifically, the e.u. data protection reform should ensure that the european union is able to in particular situations such as the prism program through its data protection rules with a clear vision of territorial scope. non-european companies when offering goods and services to european consumers will have to apply the e.u. data protection law, a broad definition of data, clear responsibilities for processors and strong rules for international transfers. the proposed general protection regulation reflects our view that in order to avoid -- access by third country law enforcement authorities to the personal data of e.u. citizens held on the servers of u.s. companies should be done via establishing terminals such as the e.u.-u.s. mutual assistance agreements. the european parliament has submitted amendments to further clarify in the provisions the conditions under which the judgment of a tribunal of a third country is enforceable under e.u. law. the commission will look at these proposals. madam president the co

data? >> i am aware of no one who has broken the law in obtaining this data. here are other issues with the leaks that have gone on here. >> based on everything we have heard today, do you see any problems with 702 or 215 that you think should be changed by this body? >> not right now. but this is something we agreed we would look at, especially the structure of how we would do that. we are looking at all of the key points. what we have to bring back to you is the agility. how we do it in the oversight. are there other ways we can do this? but at the end of the day, we need these tools, and we have to figure out the right way, from my perspectiving -- perspective, this court and the body do oversight. i think the american people would agree, that what we are doing is the right way. so those are the steps that we will go back and look at the architecture. that is a commitment that n.s.a. has made to this administration and this committee. >> final question, what's next for mr. snowden that we can expect? >> justice. >> i yield back, mr. chairman, thank you. >> t

anyone wishing to trade on this data can pay for the service that best meets their data needs. fully discloses the two-second lead time on its website. guys, this is extremely valuable data. the contract shows that thompson reuters pays the university of michigan at least $1 million a year for the exclusive right to distribute it. bill, back to you. >> how long have they been doing this? how long have these elite traders been able to buy those precious two seconds? do you know? >> yeah, the university of michigan told me that this contract -- these contract terms date back to 2007. the contract that cnbc obtained was dated in september 2009 and applied to the year 2010. but in both university of michigan and thompson reuters, they told us this is an ongoing practice as of right now. >> aemon, stay with us. we want to take a closer look at the story from all angles. we have various people lined up to talk about it. >> first, irene from able alpha trading. irene, would your firm -- steve liesman is with us, would your firm exist if you didn't have an edge on data that the rest of

, but the data. only 22 people have access to it. it was queried approximately 300 times. you mentioned that it was responsible and helped in 10% or 12% of the 50 cases where the nsa has said it was helpful. for aking you now qualitative judgment. i have made mine. ?ow do you judge the 10% to 12% highly worth it or not worth it? it is very difficult to judge a program in that part killer way, particularly a program that will give you a key to preventing a terrorist attack. one need you have, how can you differentiate that from five or six others that may come up in the same place? which will be the one to help you disrupt the plot? in my mind, the communications capabilities of terrorist's is the weakest link. we are to prevent terrorist be in thee have to communications. having the ability to identify a person in the united states, one may preventmber that one attack, that boston or that 9/11. yes it is relevant evidence. yes it is critically important that we have that means. when you have these vas

here's the catch -- the previous generation is not done a good job of transforming the data into useful knowledge. that will be up to you as well. the new millennium has been characterized by a series of crises -- earthquakes and hurricanes and bubbles and wars. you name it. not all of these could have been prevented. -- seismologists in japan from my small experience. interdigital, i published a system model for the new york times the pork is outcome of the presidential race. geniuss no particular behind the model. lots of competitors did very well. based on variations of the same approach. the simple model generated an enormous amount of controversy. people wereday, doing more searches for mining the vice president biden. -- my name then the vice president biden. i was vilified by some republicans. "anof them called me effeminate man with a soft sounding voice." other republicans say the polls were skewed by a grand conspiracy of pollsters. some prominent republican columnist addicted that mitt romney would win by a landslide. it was not just republicans who are giving me a hard time.

the problem is that either the data are very important, in which case it should be possible to get a legal basis, or they are not, in which case, this should not be happening. >> legal basis meaning warrants, right? the second question would be what about here in europe? given these developments in the united states, how safe is our data? how private is it really? >> currently, if the data are stored with an american company, the american company will fall under u.s. jurisdiction, and the fis that act in the u.s. in particular gives pretty much unlimited access to the united states to access the data -- the fisa act. >> that means google, yahoo, using services like that, you have no expectation of privacy? >> unfortunately, the way the law is written in the united states, the possibility is always there, and it is pretty much unlimited. >> what about civil society? what about governments? what can they do to rein in intelligence agencies that have no respect for the rule of law? >> intelligence services to what they are told. they are not renegade bodies. the trick is to have rules th

officials claim the data did disrupt the plot. alexander admitted to one of the senior democrats it came from foreign sources. he did say the program still protects citizens and prevents deadly plots. >> dozens of terrorist events that these have helped prevent. >> we collect millions and millions and millions of records through 2-15 but dozens proved crucial, critical. is that right? >>> oo here and abroad. >> there will be another briefing on full senate hearing on the data collection program and alexander will again testify. this will be classified and closed to the public. >> elizabeth pran life in washington. thanks. >> talk about the business now after weeks of record highs on wall street a new streak seems to be taking over that is a losing streak. today's markets may be in for a rough ride. what's scaring traders right now? >> so many things. it's when the feds will pull back on the experience. the dow fell 127 points wednesday closing under 15,000. the first 3 day losing streak this year. haven't seen that yet this year.

the problem is that either the data are very important, in which case it should be possible to get a legal basis, or they are not, in which case, this should not be happening. >> legal basis meaning warrants, right? the second question would be what about here in europe? given these developments in the united states, how safe is our data? how private is it really? >> currently, if the data are stored with an american company, the american company will fall under u.s. jurisdiction, and the fis that act in the u.s. in particular gives pretty much unlimited access to the united states to access the data -- the fisa act. >> that means google, yahoo, using services like that, you have no expectation of privacy? >> unfortunately, the way the law is written in the united states, the possibility is always there, and it is pretty much unlimited. >> what about civil society? what about governments? what can they do to rein in intelligence agencies that have no respect for the rule of law? >> intelligence services to what they are told. they are not renegade bodies. the trick is to have rules th

from those trials for the rest of us these data need to be to be openly accessible to experts who can scrutinize the claims that are being made about whether these pills are helpful are not many thanks my guest say this is a fascinating discussion and many thanks to my guest today in bangor chicago and in new york and thanks to our viewers for watching us here are see you next time remember. this is. wealthy british style. find out what's really happening to the global economy. global financial headlines to name two kinds of reports on our. world. series technology innovation all the lives developments around russia. the future covered. would be his you ready. to change the way. you do what you do that what. you you that. will. keep you uniting. the seriously very real. life. you. are here to a head not was a new. to what you did or didn't. actually do. before. live. flood live. the speech. live. live live. live. live. live. live. live. live. live. live. see. you can't come forward against the world's most powerful intelligence agencies and completely free. the whistle blow up be haul

from those trials for the rest of us these data need to be to be openly accessible to experts who can scrutinize the claims that are being made about whether these pills are helpful are not all right many thanks and i guess this is a fascinating discussion and many thanks to my guests today in bangor chicago and in new york and thanks to our viewers for watching us here are see you next time remember. these. wealthy british style. market why not. come to. find out what's really happening to the global economy with mikes concert for a no holds barred look at the global financial headlines tune into kinds a report on our nobody chooses to be homeless no one chooses to me and my sorrow. is it was for the show to. get in the six pm get out six beat six. they were. trained. to be the class people. they were against. it's tough to think about all of them comes to us and to know that many may not have only been lost to won't should never be but they're also due to for closures that never should have. been told that. i think oh. good speech. her. with. food like this some good. will. come out

it was taking an average of publicly available polls and letting the data determine the forecast. a lot of our competitors did --y well, calling 48 or 59 49 of 50 states right. forecasting the outcome of an election is a simpler problem and much less consequential one than most of what your generation will have to deal with. this relatively simple model generated an inordinate amount of controversy. by election day, more to the work and i think google searches for mining name them for vice president biden. the forecast a lot of by liberals to the extent that may have been unhealthy. i was the subject of one new yorker profile that compared me to justin bieber. by somelified republicans. one of them called me a thin and effeminate man with a soft sounding voice, which could also be justin bieber, come to think of it. [laughter] like it would somehow make mitt romney win colorado. others allege that the polls of been skewed by a grand conspiracy of pollsters. just prior to election day, a prominent republican columnist predicted not around the andpipe -- win, but landslide. there wa

from those trials for the rest of us these data need to be to be openly accessible to experts who can scrutinize the claims that are being made about whether these pills are helpful are not many thanks to my guess that this was a fascinating discussion and many thanks to my guest today in bangor chicago and in new york and thanks to our viewers for watching us here are see you next time remember. this is. i would rather ask questions to people in positions of power instead of speaking on their behalf and that's why you can find my show larry king now right here on r.t. question more. nobody chooses to be a holes. to me and now sorrow. isidro's for the show. in the six pm get out six beat six. they were. for. me the class before. they used the word against. it's tough to think about all of them comes to. an end to know that many may not have only been the last to choose should never be but they're also due to foreclosures that never should have. you can't come forward against the world's most powerful intelligence agency. complete with. the man who exposed washington's all seeing spy n

you can get the data easily. every citizen should have the ability to get their data. >> thank you. i think that is something we should look at some more. interoperability is key. i look that in many areas. i have more, but i will save it for the next round. >> we would like to recognize the gentleman from missouri for five minutes. >> thank you. i guess this means i should put my phone away. thank you for being here today. last week i was disappointed and frustrated by the lack of information of the testimony of the witnesses. i admire what you are doing. i hope that you keep it up. it will make this a better world. very quickly, what regulations are in ways that you have to deal with everyday in regards to barriers that are put in front of you that you you have to overcome that we can have an impact on? what do you see as some problems? >> again, i think i am one of those where the vendors really adhere to the proposed regulation. when it comes to saving lives, when it comes to moving into moving outside the four walls of the hospital, we want more innovation and quality and securi

so, the data challenges and i think that this is really important because without advocacy at the state level it is going to be impossible to collect accurate data on the san francisco foster youth who identify as gay and are working through their gender identity issues. there is no way to capture this information using the data base that the state provides us and the state forms there is no capacity within the state forums to capture this information. >> are remandated to use the state forms? >> yes. >> and so i think that this is really an area for advocacy at the state level and also on the human rights commission and we are certainly at the table. and another, you know, something else that we need to look at and we can really use the help from the youth commission in this is that how to talk to the youth about their sexual orientation and sometimes the youth are... but there is a stigma attached to that and they don't want to talk about who they are and i think that having that kind of information, you know with someone like mia would be helpful. >> and we do know that 20 to 40 perc