and for residential, the p. c.i.a. is going down. the next slide for commercial -- >> sorry, on the generation, it is going up. >> yes. their generation costs are going down. so the bar on the left is going down relative to the share. really what it is is their generation rates are going down and that is more the issue for residential. >> is that because they are changing their mix? >> it is a variety of things that are affecting that. the increase is one element. they are recovering more revenue another element has to do with the fact with a rates that are in effect may have been artificially high because they put them in place late in the year. they were recovering the same amount of revenue over a fewer number of months. that is another element. there are other factors as well. >> thanks. >> that is residential. this is small commercial. you can see it is more dramatic for small commercial. it is 14% more on generation supply costs for small commercial. i do want to comment. we are showing the portion of the service that clean powe

for the generation rate reduction, the p. c.i.a. will be going up, and the credit will offset that change to the two bars are equal. that is the whole point here. >> can i ask a question? >> sure. >> i understand you are thinking around your reasoning and i think it is good to have p. c.i.a. as a separate line item for future programming and what not. but will they know the small commercial customers if they are not looking that closely at their bill about any of this? i mean the bill is basically the same. >> rights. there will be an outreach effort to help explain to customers about the changes that are coming up. we have several months to work on this. we will work on messaging back we will work on noticing on the bills in terms of these changes. we will look at current and putting articles out to the customer so they will get a sense of what these changes are. >> my point is that this is so complicated, the staff. and it is hard to make it simple it is communicated in some ways. but if the end outcome is basically the same, i thi