the prosecution left the jury with this. would bonds who relies on his body for his livelihood allow greg anderson unknowingly dose him without knowing what he injected bonds' body with? before closing arguments u.s. district judge instructed the jury of eight women and four men on deliberation rules. if the jury receives the case today, they can choose to deliberate tomorrow. the defense indicated yesterday their closing arguments would take two to three hours. keep in mind that the prosecution is still allowed time for rebuttal afterwards. reporting live in san francisco, jade hernandez, ktvu channel 2 news. >>> all right. thank you, jade. you can learn more about the barry bonds trial around the clock by going to ktvu.com. you'll find the latest developments as well as background on the case. >>> san francisco police are investigating a shooting this morning in the city's bay view district. officers say it happened as a group of teenagers got off a muni bus around 8:00 a.m. investigators say one of the teenagers getting o

>>reporter: just moments ago the prosecution was wrapping up. they want to the defense and then the prosecution at one final moment. the jury will begin deliberations any moment. the prosecution basically said that all they have to do was tell the truth. that is what barry bonds all he had to do was tell the truth. let me roll video. the reason he did not is that he wanted to maintain a powerful secret that which using anabolic steroids. he was afraid that it it would taint his accomplishments. and steve hoskins, kimberly bell were the ones that showed that he was lying. those were his inner circle people that are all lying. those witnesses cannot be trusted. hoskins testimony was inconsistent. also that kimberly bell admitted lying before the grand jury so none of them can be trusted. the prosecution has been trying to demonize. becker. with untested theories of as head of growing. you can see barry bonds is leaving the court right now. the court has gone to the jury in the case has gone to juries. eight women, four men. we do not know how long

>>pam: was the most credible of the prosecution people? she said i don't want to be here, my brother through meat under the boss on this one but i did see barry bonds be injected by greg anderson. the jury hears that, you don't want to be here, you were waterbury's best friends and you're saying he saw him get shot with the needle, there probably going to believe that. that's the one count to might get convicted on terry and >>pam: closing arguments tomorrow, what to both sides have to do? >> the prosecution has to get up and talk about truth and justice. why perjury cuts right to the heart of our criminal justice system. you can't have that going on. but the government will give up, the defense still get out there and make it about steve hoskins and kimberly belton and will be bonds vs. bell and hoskins. if >>pam: the witnesses who allegedly have reasons to be mad. >> the thing we're losing track of a times is, remember barry bonds urine tested positive for steroids. that is one area that the government has in their quiver and it will hav

there were public outcries with the district and state attorney general refused to prosecute the case. >> the boys are vilified and now people know things were not exactly as they were said to have been. >> the defense attorneys argued that the young woman brought beer to the party and was a willing participants and demanded sex in graphic terms . the jury found the two remaining defendants not liable on all counts. ranging from rape and conspiracy to negligence. >> we all had our emotions in certain parts and pieces that we had to make decisions on. but the bottom line ultimately it was the law that we followed and that helped us to render our final decision. >> not all of the votes were unanimous. two jurors cried open encluding one juror who hugged the plaintiff. >> these guys were animals and took advantage of a very young, young girl . in this case, no, justice was not served. >> the young woman sued for 7 and half million dollars. the jury could have given her any amount and awarded her nothing. >> you want to find the truth, come and ask the jury what the truth is, it is a mira

that hurt the prosecution's case that helped bond. hoskins said he recorded the conversation back in 2003, one of those 50 conversations. couldn't find the tape all these years until now. >> i guess we'll have to find out as the court proceeds and find out how the evidence been missing suddenly pops up at the crucial most dramatic moment in the prosecution's case. >> reporter: susan ilston says she has heard the tape and all of it is inadmissible and it's a lot of hoskins talking and not a lot of dr. ting. ruling on the tape probably today. also testimony from lab witnesses about bonds' 2003 sample that allegedly tested positive. they want a ruling withheld evidence, as well. all of this in front of a jury that was dismissed yesterday allowed to go home because one of the members of the jury has a medical problem. he's going to be back today with medication. if he can't go on, they'll bring in one of the two alternates. >> eric: man accused of jaycee dugard is expected to change his plea on thursday. philip garrido will plead guilty. t

the defense is a cuesing the prosecution of hiding the evidence. but the judge is allowing the tape to be used. >>> chilling admission in oakland as confessed killer, devonde broussard described shooting chauncey bailey. in august, 2007. bailey was walking to his office at oakland post where he was editor. broussard ran within an arm's reach of bailey and shot him in chest and torso. he said he started to run but returned firing a third time. hitting bailey in the face. because he was instructed that bailey had to die. bay and another man are on trial. broussard says, the former owner of your black muslim bakery, ordered the killing. >>> the sanity face in the attempted murder trial started. he was found guilty of plotting an attack at hills. dale high school in 2009. he is diagnosed with schizophrenia. more than a half dozen privately hired and court appointed psychologists and psychiatrists examined him in the months after he terrorized hills. dale with pipe bombs, a sword and chain saw. defense attorneys say he cannot discern right from wrong an

they are trying to build credibility with the jury. >> reporter: the prosecution is expected to methodically go down the long list of witnesses and how each contributed evidence that barry bonds talked about taking steroids. as well as how his body appeared to display the side effects associated with steroids. >> hammer, hammer, hammer about the bias and baggage that the particularly -- a couple of inner circle witnesses have. >> reporter: now, as the defense and the prosecution were going over the instructions they want the judge to present to the jury tomorrow, a request came in from greg anderson, barry bonds' best friend and former trainer. he was put behind bars for not testifying in this case. he refused to do that. now that the case is wrapping up, he wants to know when he's going to be released. the judge did not make a decision. live in san francisco, traci grant, nbc bay area news. >> we could have a decision by the jury by early next week. >>> moving on now, a training flight turned deadly. it happened this afternoon outside of fresno. emergency crews are still on the scene. u.s.

the letters. they are looking at four r murders has an identical name. he is prosecuting all of the california as a matter of thentious suspicious. >> you have multiple counties traveled and woven of the prosecution and cooperating the take the prosecution so you don't have toy are ply the case. >> they appear in court a couple of weeks now. does he have the money to play for the taunt . da ask for a death punishment. he's mot saying yet. wayne freedom. >> with the with the unveiled his deficit reduction to cut over the next 12 years . cutting the pentagon 412 buildings and boosting takes on the celthy. the president said it be done on the and middle class. >> one that protects the middle class are promised to seniors and investor in the future. >> the solution falls far short of dealing with the kind of crisis that we are facing as far as the debts are in this country. >> the republican plan would cut six trillion over wes and includes cuts and expeppeding thote who had the bush trash bus. >> they stay university of the campus today. they will demand a end of more shuts

the prosecution is arguing that these men were acting on orders. it's believed the three men targeted daily because of a negative story he was writing about the black muslim bakery. also in oakland an old building will come down in dramatic fashion. using 800 lbs. of dynamite, the naval medical center will be imploded this friday. it's the last military structure to be removed along on boulevard. the 167 a. will be developed into a new community. in san paolo hospital is getting a financial bailout so that it could keep its doors opened. if the contra costa county board of supervisors granted if doctors' medical hospital a $10 million loan. that does come with conditions. the county supervisors what the husbanhospital to solve its budt problems and not to expect any more money. budget woes are forcing caltrans officials to raise commuter fares and cut service. country will halt and 10 trains, closed three stations and raise fares and parking rates. the changes are in an effort to close at $30 million deficit. weekend and special events service inclu

that is after a long morning of rehashing testimony from the prosecution. now, let's go ahead and look at the charges against barry bonds once more. they are on your screen, the three counts of lying to a grand jury, one count of obstruction of justice, and these are the specific points when it comes to the grand jury allegations. bonds said that if greg anderson he didn't know about it, he never got any hga from anderson and bonds said that no one else besides a doctor ever injected him with anything. so first the prosecution this morning was laying out its case starting with the words, all had he to do is tell the truth, saying bonds was given immunity when he testified as long as told the truth. the prosecution alleges that he so wanted to keep his steroids secret from the giants and from his father, that he decided to lie anyway. the prosecution said it's implausible on its face that anderson would inject bonds with steroids without bonds knowing. and the attorneys reminded us about some circumstantial evidence like a huge cache of steroids and syringes

while the prosecution has the benefit of grants. in fact, i believe the district attorney might have at least half of their budget is provided by grants. that is not provided to the indigent defense providers. federal grants are almost all directed toward prosecution and law enforcement. so the problem to have vast resources that i'm facing right now is that you have grant funding the police department, the sheriff's deft, the district attorney's office. there is a share that -- etc., etc. that share, which for them is a portion of their funding is almost my entire funding so when you say you're going to cut 13% off everybody equally. well, 13% for us is more than 13% of their entire budget than for the other agencies. now the problem is that's the ripple effect we just had here. now they still have their investigators because they have other agencies that provide the investigation. we don't. our investigators are the ones that have to be trimmed off because we can't pay for them. our attorneys, again, they are paid for by the count

should the prosecution try it again? >> kristen: it may not feel like it. of cold but we are going to warm up nicely today. >> eric: let's check in with lisa. >> you see the sun is shining and you have an idea, it's going to be a beautiful day, a little bit warmer. if you like it cooler. if you like it rainy. we have that all in the forecast. 44 in livermore. san francisco, 51. 43 in santa rosa with a cool 41 in half moon bay and napa. so we are looking at temperatures, warmer than yesterday. but warmer air is going to make it down to the surface. wind shift and we'll see numbers come up anywhere in 6-8 degrees. so with a cool start, warmer finish and couple systems heading our way. mid-week, much cooler and a little bit of rain coming our way. more widespread 60s, mid and upper 70s today. due to high pressure building in today. so enjoy it today, numbers ranging from the 50s and low 60s by noontime. mid-60s to upper 70s later this afternoon and stay dry tomorrow, best chance of wednesday into thursday. >> i've been watching a couple of injuries accidents. o

to back up the testimony of another prosecution witness. leaving members of the jury to decide who they trust more. dan kerman has more. >> reporter: a bad day for the prosecution in the barry bonds case. steve hoskins, former friend and business manager is contradicted by his surgeon dr. arthur ting. dr. arthur ting testified after ugbonds elbow surgery he did not stave stave the very was caused by steroids, something steve hoskins testified. dr. arthur ting detained he was concerned baseball baseball was taking steroids -- barry bonds was taking steroids. dr. arthur ting's testimony -- steve hoskins is looking like someone who is exaggerating to the government to try to get barry bonds. >> reporter: dr. arthur ting testified all the side effects associated with steroids could be caused by legal steroids which he and the giants prescribed for bonds to help him recover quicker from injuries. >> dr. arthur ting puts a context to that that is legitimate. he became an experts for the defense even though he was called as a prosecution witness. >

as dan curman reports the prosecution caught everybody off guard by announcing they discovered new evidenceat could be critical to the case. a potential bombshell in the barry bonds trial. at of the presence of the jury president announced they found a missing audio tape of a conversation between bonds former business manager steve hoskins and on surgeon dr. arthur ting. recorded shortly after the government's 2003 raids on craig anderson is home. earlier in the trial, hoskins testified he secretly recorded the conversation with dr. tank about steroids, but i didn't do it properly or couldn't find the tapes. prosecutors say over the weekend hoskins found it. the timing couldn't be better for the prosecution. this other case devastated last week when a doctor arthurs testimony contradicted much of what hoskins said. in fact it but boskin said he and king talked about steroids 50 times and specifically discussed it on steroid use, dr. arthur only recalls one conversation in 1999. he says bonds was an even mentioned by name. depending on whats on the tape it could be used to impeach dr. arthur

why i've read articles were they talked about the government spending $6 million on this prosecution.o you and i and the rest of us want the government to go back and redo this for another 6 million? the answer is a resounding no, let it go it's over. >>pam: go will be back with us again at 6:00, there still more to talk to your guarding the verdict today. if in the meantime, kron 4 is live at at&t park he's getting reaction from giants fans about today's verdict. >>reporter: barry bonds remains untouchable. at&t park even after the guilty verdict. many fans still stand behind cliff home-run king. >> was surprised, i am a giants fan i respect barry bonds and he's a great ball player. >> i did a bonds fan and i will stay a bonds stand. i think he did miracles for the giants there and brought a lot of fans and. people came to see barry back to. and still behind him 100 percent. a think it's a fairy,, we all know he's guilty and doesn't no matter fees one of our heroes are not, he's guilty. >>reporter: the fans are still loving him to death. a lot of giants fans now worry, bonds will sta

. >> even the prosecution seems to think its case weak. prosecutors asked the judge to drop one of the charges against bonds. legal experts say it seems like the prosecution's case is falling apart right before are very eyes. barry bonds did not take the stand and in fact no one did on his behalf. the defense rested without calling a single witness. legal experts weren't surprised. they say the prosecution's case is weak and clearly the defense is confident in the case. so the conventional wisdom is that he won't be convicted even if he is, the punishment won't be harsh. it will likely be house arrest. punishment may come to his reputation. >> it's going to be on the ballot for the hall of fame. there is nothing if you are convicted of a felony, that would preclude him from being listed as a candidate. question is how does a possible conviction affect what voters would do? >> bonds is on trial for telling a 2003 grand jury that he never knowingly used steroids. the prosecution took two weeks and called about two dozen witnesses many of whom

>>pam: the prosecution rests, the defense starts. list of possible people to testify. you don't think he well? >> a lot of the a's a to the prosecution i will put my client on or release seriously thinking about it, they have to make a tough decision is one of the toughest decisions that a defense attorney has to make. in your mind have to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt. all tell you when you could decline on the stand, you sit on the edge of the sea because you could have a beautiful case going in and at the jury doesn't believe or trustor doesn't like your client, guess what all of that evidence that came before it goes by the wayside in get convicted. i'm not sure the take the chance. money is on the testimony. >>pam: are going to talk more with michael about the barry bonds development today. we will be back, we encourage you to stay with kron 4 for continuing coverage. you can get the very latest any time at www.kron4.com. we'll be back. ♪ you'll run outside ♪ and i'll pass you by ♪ ♪ i want to see the sunshine ♪ ♪ tak

the federal profession sent $6 million to prosecute barry bonds. the question is, do they go forward and retry them. we thought we would give them a little advice. we have early risers like anthony. good morning. >> morning. >> reporter: do you think they should retry him on those three perjury counts? >> yeah. i think so. perjury is a serious offense. >> reporter: a lot of people are saying it's not as serious as other crimes. it's already cost $6 million, in that neighborhood. what would you say? >> lying in the courtroom is serious to me. i say go for it. >> reporter: are you a barry bonds fan? >> no. hate barry. >> reporter: do you think that played into your opinion at all? >> no. i'm less bias. >> reporter: thanks for hanging out with us. take it easy. they said they are going to contest that if it is not overturned. if he remains a convicted felon. theoretically, it could send him to jail for ten years. federal sentencing guidelines call for two years. not many are saying that, either. if he remains convicted, he would end up with a form of h

so all of those issues are going to go into their attack of the prosecution witnesses combined with the legal arguments, left on the questions and answers. >> closing arguments will take about four hours tomorrow and the jury have the case by the end of the day. >> thank you very much, anne makovec live in san francisco. >>> outpouring of support for the giants fan who was beaten after the team's season opener. right now the paramedic company where bryan stow worked is just starting a fundraiser for stow's family and kiet do is there. kiet. >> reporter: sydnie, we're live here as you mentioned at american medical response. this is the ambulance company where bryan stow works and what you're seeing here is a grassroots community effort that's gone viral as they expect hundreds possibly thousands of people to show up. this is the beginning of an eight-hour fundraiser barbecue where you can have brisket, chicken, hot dogs and all the fixings for free and they ask a cash donation. a lot of what you see here is donated in order to maximize the proceeds that go to the family. paramedics and t

quite frankly this is the one of the weakest prosecution cases anybody has ever seen. the defense is following conventional wisdom, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. >> bonds is on trial for telling a 2003 grand jury that he never knowingly used steroids and witnesses testified that he knew he was getting steroids from his trainer. the defense will argue those witnesses are lying and they all have an axe to grind and part of a conspiracy to get bonds. a conviction won't be that big of a deal for barry bonds, it will likely mean only house arrest even if she convicted. closing arguments are expected to last five to six hours. >> janelle: the man accused of kidnapping jaycee dugard and hold her captive for 18 years is expected to change his plea in court. the an attorney says that philip garrido will change his plea. it's an effort to show compassion to her and dugard. it would to avoid testifying in court. >> in albany, a soccer coach accused of lewd acts with a juvenile girl over a period of several years. police want to know if there are other victims. albany police arr

the prosecution says the 74-year-old paid for sex with a 17-year-old known as ruby. he then allegedly called a police station after she had been arrested on theft charges and ordered her released. the trial is set to resume on may 31. if convicted on both charges, berlusconi faces a 15-year jail sentence. and we'll have more on the case against berlusconi coming up later in "journal" in "the in-depth." in libya rebel forces have been trying to retake the oil port of brega after days after fighting. this despite after coming under heavy fire from forces loyal to gaddafi. thheavy shellg pmpd them toash out at nato. they say nato is not doing enough to protect them and to stop artillery attacks by gaddafi soldiers. >> despite the latest setbacks, the rebels aren't giving up hopepe fresh supplies for frontline fighters are being distributed at this check point near ajdabiya. a spokesman said their withdraw on tuesday had been a tactical move. >> everything is ok. our soldiers are checking the area. sometimes gaddafi's forces shoot at them, and then they pull back. >> fur

>> the prosecution says they have about 20 more witnesses. then it's the defense's turn. some of the witnesses to come include the investigator that the chauncey billy project wrote about, longmire. basically our reporting made him look really bad. the investigation was very incomplete and very shoddy. but the prosecution wants to put him on the stand so he could explain all the things we brought up in our stories. >> belva: we talked about a lot of trouble tonight, john. i'm going to turn to you right now. i was going to say, now we get to talk about dreaming. >> quite a difference. there's the day-to-day reality of the world. then the ways cities take shape and regions take shape. planners and architects and developers and financers and politicians are emergency ning what comes next. you've got that in the oddest place. treasure island. which the navy essentially in the early '90s said, we're leaving. and ever since then there's been talk about, what do you do with it? willie brown at one point suggested a casino. well, in 2005 the idea was, why don't we put a lot of ho

>> a bad day for the prosecution and the barry bonds case. earlier testimony. from hoskins, his former friend/business partner. contradicted by another prosecution witness his orthopedic surgeon, dr. barry bonds. hof the barry tonight that hoskins said he was concerned bond was taking steroids. in fact despite the testimony that they had numerous conversations about steroids. king testified to that he can only recall one conversation. dr. king--his testimony was cold water over hoskins. he looks like he is exaggerating to the government to try to get barry bonds. >>reporter: ting also testified that the side effects of the anabolic steroids could be caused by legal corner course steroids which he and the giants have prescribed to barry bonds to help recovery from that of all injury. >> a legitimate reason why it. bonds could of using he became an expert for the defense even though he was called as a prosecution witness. >>reporter: it is not clear how much the testimony of telling harmed the case. we have one more - ting, could depend detrimental. also, that a a

that hurt the prosecution. oking for the tape, he's been looking for it since 2003 and he found it. prosecution says it proves the conversation did take place. the judge listened to the tape and said she wasn't impressed. a ruling on that today and a sick juror had the entire jury sent home yesterday. big deal is that tape will the mystery tape be admitted into evidence today. >> eric: checking other top stories, it was frightening experience for a mother of two in antioch. three stray bullets from a street shooting pierced through her nine-year-old son's bedroom window last night. they hit normally where he would be sleeping. the mother says it was good thing he was hungry gri and eating in another room at the time. >> from sutro camera, it's beginning to filter in. temperatures coming down significantly in the city. 53 for the high due to a cold front here. that will be pushing through the bay area today bringing the cooler air. 60s and then 70s today. this really starts the cooling trend. in fact we will be l

so all of those issues are going to go into their attack of the prosecution witnesses, combined with the legal arguments left on the questions and the answers. >> reporter: now, the closing arguments are starting tomorrow at 8:30 a.m. they are expected to last about 4 hours. and the jury should have this case in its hands by the end of the day. in san francisco, anne makovec, cbs 5. >>> downing five drinks a day, no problem? the disturbing trend with today's teenagers. >>> i'm a fan of spider-man's and like the other superheros. >> four feet tall, eight years old, and a threat? why one officer says he was forced to pepper spray the kid. >>> and my little -- bovine? her parents refuse to get her a pony so a teenager made due with her cow. ,, [ male announcer ] germs in your mouth build up and form a layer called biofilm so strong it survives brushing. thankfully, there's listerine® antiseptic. its triple-action formula penetrates biofilm, kills germs and protects your mouth for hours. fight biofilm with listerine®. it happened at this home on south 59th street, near highland av >>> a d

the other big news today, the judge ruled out an audiotape which the prosecution said it had of a friend of bonds talking to bonds' orthopedic is surgeon about the slugger and steroids. the judge dismissed the tape as inaudible, which is a big blow to the prosecution. the prosecution then rested its case this afternoon. >>> the confessed killer of oakland journalist chauncey bailey spent his second day under cross-examination today as defense attorneys tried to shake his memory, specifically, broussard was asked whether his boss at your black muslim bakery, yousef bay iv, had used the word kill in allegedly ordering the deaths of bailey and two other men. broussard said he couldn't recall. the attorney tried show that broussard was not intimidated by bay, getting broussard to admit he never had a problem standing up to pay. >>> the trial of seven men accused of terrorizing san francisco in 2008 is now under way. the group is allegedly part of the ms 13 gang. had they are charged with five murders and a racketeering conspiracy. they face life in prison if convicted. 18 other gang members

. >>> the barry bonds trial resuming monday and the prosecution has just one more witness. a sports doping expert will continue testifying monday. yesterday, bonds' personal shopper testified she saw bonds trainer inject something into the slugger's belly button. >>> and major league baseball season officially beginning this evening in the bay area. the oakland as hosting the seattle mariners at the coliseum. game time is 7:05. >>> traffic and weather right after this. stay with us. ,,,,,,,,

showed war crimes other criminal behavior and other misdeeds president obama should discourage the prosecution is to reevaluate u.s. foreign policy so it's not an abuse of the use of empire and part of the international community. at ten minutes time we'll be hearing from a u.s. special rapporteur on torture who's on demand in case our interview. now the story of a convicted killer who wants death himself a russian for is an hour has racked with pain from illness is pleading with the authorities to be released from his misery the case has reignited the debate over assisted suicide a practice that's illegal in the country very thin often reports. in r.t.s.

that was a big blow to the prosecution. today what we expect to see the defense will call three to six witnesses to the stand. one possibly bonds. another hoskins. they are interested in talking to him about a portion of those secret tapes we haven't heard yet. a part they say proves that hoskins was actually trying to extort money from bonds. we're live in san francisco, i'm tara moriarty, ktvu channel 2 news. >>> and just a few hours testimony resumes in the trial of two men accused of killing oakland journalist chauncey bailey. this morning the defense will continue cross-examination. he claims he was ordered to kill bailey in july of 2007. but under cross-examination yesterday he waiverred when asked about being given a direct order by yusuf bey the 4th. the second is accused of driving the get away car. >>> time now 5:04. san roof female police say there's a suspicious man in the area and now they're warning young girls. there's been reports of several incidents where young girls have been approached by a man offering t

dunston chaired his thoughts on what he knew of bonds and the prosecution painted as a villain in the case. >> he is negative and cocky and he is good. tell us why couldn't you hit that ball you ain't that good such and such and starts laughing. with you i look at barry a little different. i could care i'm a grown man. >> we all play the game. there is a mark against us. hopefully the more are we play the longer this gets the testing goes on and eliminates it from the game that can kind of remove the black eye a little bit and go out there and play baseball. i think for the most part you will not see it in the game any more for the most part. >> the giants said the case is ongoing and we expect it will proceed in a fair and orderly manner and accordingly we have no comment at this time. talking with the fans at the game, they love the giants, they love barry warts and all and feel that the whole thing was a huge waste of time and money. i spoke to one dodger fan and she said there is no doubt barry lied. it goes along partisan lines. >> exactly. larry, let's pick up on the point you m

. >> even the prosecution appears to think that the case is wreak. prosecutors to drop one of charges against barry bonds. legal experts say this case is falling apart right before our eyes. barry bonds did not take the stand. in fact no one did on his behalf. the defense rested without calling a single witness. legal experts say they weren't surprised. the prosecution's case is weak and clearly the defense is confident in the case. so the conventional wisdom that he won't be convicted. even if he is, the punishment would likely be house arrest. his punishment may come to his reputation. >> he will be on the ballot on the hall of fame. i don't any there would be anything that would preclude him but the question is how does a possible conviction what voters would do. >> bonds is trial for telling a 2003 grand jury that he never knowingly used steroids. prosecution sent two weeks and called about two dozen witnesses many of them testified that bonds was getting steroids from his trainer greg anderson but the defense will argue they are lying. they all

in 2002. >>> what does it all mean the jury wants to hear that testimony again how strong is the prosecutions case since virtually all evidence is circumstantial. joining us to talk about that is kcbs 5 legal analyst paul henderson good morning. >> thanks for joining us. >> they asked for the tape what do you think. >> they want the tape they got to listen to it. one thing i thought was interesting a lot of people asked me about why don't they get to just bring the tape back into the room. >> or written transcripts. apparently that wasn't part of the evidence please explain that. >> exactly what happens is at the end of the trial the jury is allowed to take into the room everything admitted during the trial things like the transcript have not been admitted so they are not allowed to bring it into the room. >> even though they were shown. >> are they listening to the tape? being told what is on the tape? >> they will get to listen to the tape played. >> basically [inaudible] by the way. >> mostly [inaudible] but two interesting things on the tape. one thing it says when the tape talks about th

. >> the prosecution rallied in the end of the trial. >> for 99 percent of the case if looked like a acquittal. in the final moments jeff pirella said there is evidence on the record that barry bonds knew greg anderson dealt steroid and in light of those remarks, the jury said those statements were evasive and an obstruction of justice. obviously we expect an appeal on what would be the grounds for that. >> the defense telegraphed that and they have trouble with the notion that it is technically true and invasive. it is not all the prosecution wanted for the answer and that is the strongest grounds for appeal. >> and the perjury trial stems from barry bond's 2003 testimony before the grand jury. victor ponzi served time for his role in the standal. they caught up late today and joins us live with his reaction, vick? >> victor conte believes that the verdict makes absolutely no sense at all. how can you convict someone of obstruction when you haven't proved that he's lying. bonds' legal troubles began with valco and that is a company that victo comte founded. federal agents seized the

the jurors. closing arguments wrapped up. prosecutionbarry bonds had to do was tell the truth. and the prosecution is being accused of trying to demonize barry bonds this trial continues tomorrow morning at 8:30 >>reporter: the not guilty from garrido of j.c. dugard. holding her captive for nearly two decades. the public believes that garrido was going to plead guilty to those charges but the lawyers say that those rumors were on not true. those rumors are started by his wife's lawyer. speaking out of turn. there was never a plea deal, and they're saying that he was never going to plead guilty. thompson. >>pam: a live picture in washington. the ongoing budget battle. in an effort to continue to get a budget deal. if one is not reached by tomorrow night? then a government shutdown is expected. we will continue to follow this. let me listen and. >> let me reiterate what this is so important. we are just 30 hours away from the government shutdown. that means that 800,000 families, neighbors, friends who are working hard all across the count

that the witnesses have various financial motives. >>reporter: prosecutiond the jury bonds lied because he had a secret. powerful secret that he didn't even want his father to know. and that reasonable doubt doesn't mean beyond all doubt asking them to does your common sense allow to you believe he was unknowingly duped that taking anabolic stared by his trainer anderson. >> the prosecution is saying look at that big picture. it all is consistent. it all adds up to one thing. barry bonds knew. >>reporter: the jury will be back to begin deliberation tomorrow morning at 8:30. keeping mostly to their trial schedule ending the day at 3:3 3:30. in san francisco, heather, abc 7 news. >> there its a new development in the case of j.c. due gawvrmentd girl kidnapped held captive for nearly 2 decades in antioch home. her accused kidnapper philip garrido expected to plead guilty today after previously admitting to the crime. instead he pleaded not guilty and his attorney filed last minute which will engine to l have the grand jury that indicted him water selected. >> n