tirmidhi from the sunnis, from the authentic sources of the sunnis, tirmidhi narrates that on the day of taif, jabir said that we all the companions of the prophet ali were sitting, always waiting for ali , where is he, when will he come, and ali's voice was coming. he used to come to the prophet and he would talk to the prophet privately with ali other than the conversations with ali and whisper quietly. some of the companions said that how much the prophet whispers to ali, what do they say to each other, prophet? saying that it is not only me who whispers to ali , god also whispers to ali, god in my narration also tells us from amir that god can whisper to you all if the flesh of your soul's ears is awake , whether it is open or not. god is talking to you through your intellect, understanding and nature, you don't hear yourself, you don't want to hear the prophet in the sources of the sunnis, they say, "why is the prophet whispering to ali?" umar bin khattab, his excellency umar , the second caliph, this is in sahih tirmidhi , it is in kanz al-umal. various sources of mr. ahmed hanb