at the daily pennsylvanian and there is a dorothy roberts, sarah barringer serena, sophia, tobias barrington wolffwho are they? amy: they are my colleagues and there were multiple pieces published and letters and protests published. that piece was actually an attempt by four historians on the faculty to write a substantive response to our peace. i did not object to that piece. i did not agree with it at all, i thought the argument was transparently fallacious, but they argued that praising boardwalk culture and the 1950's, which was the -- aardwalk -- bush was cash they objected to that. their argument was you cannot praise the 50's because the 50's were a time of patriarchy, ofism, sexism, mistreatment minorities, terrible things happened during the 1950's, discrimination was rampant and ergo, there was nothing good about it. nonnsidered that a complete sequitur and they seemed to be making an argument like the only reason the 1950's were good for the people it was good for because they missed treated all these other people, which is a very strange argument to make. if we stop miss people, things